4 ms·
The thing that terrifies me is that the law in many industrialized countries would consider the structure that he built to be unfit for human habitation, due to
by logfromblammo 11y ago
The thing that terrifies me is that the law in many industrialized countries would consider the structure that he built to be unfit for human habitation, due to multiple severe building code violations.
100 years ago, it would have been an acceptable dwelling, or even desirable. Thanks to the pace of progress, in just 50 years, houses built to today's standards might be considered too primitive for human habitation.
And you have to wonder what is going to be invented before then that will make us look at the homes we are living in right now and think, "How did I ever live in such a backwards, primitive building?"
We might not even realize the importance of it right away. If you think about an indoor flushing toilet, it doesn't seem all that remarkable, but now every residence needs to have at least one. Grid power wiring isn't all that glamorous, but every home has it. The thing that changes everything might be boring at first glance.
And that's terrifying. A human can see a device with the power to change the entire world and still say, "meh."
And also aliens would probably need to kidnap at least 10000 in order to maintain a stable breeding population. Otherwise, the humans would have to establish some pretty strict rules against monogamy and inbreeding, and the aliens would have to carefully select a very diverse group to begin with.
- kragen 11y agoThat's not progress; that's addiction to luxury and oppression. That's the opposite of progress.
- logfromblammo 11y agoA 30-story apartment building is not practical without indoor plumbing, structural steel, and grid power. The tallest dwellings prior to those maxed out at around 5 stories. What qualifies as progress is a matter of opinion, but generally speaking, denser cities produce more rapid technological innovation. I have no way of knowing whether the new mystery tech would make dwellings taller, or cheaper, or more environmentally friendly, or more mobile, or more self-sufficient, or better workspaces. It's the sort of thing that is only obvious in hindsight. It may already be invented, but does not yet have a practical and economical application. Whatever it is, it might require a cartel enforcer to mandate it in order to yield greater benefit for the society as a whole. You're not being oppressed when the city forces you to give up your well and septic system and connect to the municipal water and sewer. In theory, you're achieving greater gains through (enforced) cooperation with your neighbors. In practice, you may be oppressed by official corruption in such a way that it wipes that common benefit out. And luxury is relative. The poorest person in the U.S. can have a better defecation experience in a public park toilet than the richest king in the world could have had on his private, hand-carved night-stool 500 years ago. One day soon, it might be considered luxury to crap in a hole in the dirt... on Mars--as the alternative would be to do it in a pressurized closet, into a machine that recycles the water out of it and turns the rest into agricultural compost.
- kragen 11y agoBut you know what? It's not luxury to sleep on the sidewalk and get peed on by dogs after your house was bulldozed because it doesn't have indoor plumbing. Or because you didn't start building it in the first place. 30-story apartment buildings might be fine, but declaring buildings "uninhabitable" because they lack luxuries — and prohibiting people from living in them — is an injustice that falls heavily on the poor.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe intent of a building code and the actual result of its enforcement may differ by a wide margin. The injustice largely comes from selective enforcement under inappropriate circumstances. I didn't intend to make a point about building codes, but rather about how quickly humanity changes its standards for technological advancement. For tens of thousands of years, a mud hut with tile roof and underfloor heating would have been a luxury accommodation. Now, for a lot of people, it's rustic and primitive, fit only for camping trips rather than permanent habitation. Humanity is scary not only for its ability to construct shelters like this without any specialty-evolved biology, like a woodpecker's beak, a beaver's teeth, or mole claws, but because it can extrapolate the idea of shelter so far beyond our current survival needs that even a thing that well exceeds the minimum requirements is still considered obsolete.
- kragen 11y agoYes, and of course the result of building codes can often be justice — the people who died in the Haïti earthquake died of a lack of building codes, after all. I agree that we take learn to things for granted quickly. I think that's unfortunate and leads to a lot of unhappiness. Forcing our addiction to needless luxuries on others is a significant way that it leads to unhappiness, but far from the only one. You also see people dying of lack of physical activity, for example. I don't think it makes sense to talk about "the intent of a building code". Since we have not yet produced artificial general intelligence, building codes are not yet sentient entities with intent. Different people who supported the enaction of the building code had a wide variety of intents; the different people who convert it from a piece of paper into a pattern of human behavior, by enforcing it, also have a wide variety of intents. Most of these are unknowable.
- nextos 11y agoOur houses still have a lot of room for immediate improvements. For example having a flushing toilet in the same room where you wash your hands and shower yourself is probably not an optimal design. I've seen a few studies measuring bacterial communities that came into this conclusion. Not to diminish the importance of toilets, though. They are a fantastic Victorian innovation. You also want to control air currents so that mold doesn't go to other rooms, but few designs account for this. Many materials off-gas harmful chemicals. Formaldehyde, often in some glues, is one example. I see a lot of room for measuring and ensuring homes are healthy. Perhaps a big task for IoT.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHeck, nearly everything in a bathroom can be improved: faucets (re-adjust every time you use them, run water until desired temperature is reached); sinks (too shallow to do anything in, faucet gets in the way); medicine cabinet (reach over sink, too shallow so stuff falls out, fingerprints on the glass every time); toilet (cold, too low, smelly, spray goes everywhere, noisy); shower (curtain useless, water leaks out, run wasted water until warm, can't spray water UP at all, crowded for two or more) and so on. Spider Robinson had a character in the Callahan's Saloon series that went into some detail on this.
- gnopgnip 11y agoBathrooms usually have fans that vent outside to take care of moisture. All new homes have ventilation that replaces the air at least twice an hour. This is not to say that it couldn't be better addressed, but these issues have not gone unnoticed.
- linkregister 11y agoWhy do building codes terrify you? If this guy built his house in an Australian suburb, yes, he would be required to tear it down and probably face a fine for failing to get planning permission. Since he's in a remote area, he can build the house if he wants to. Australian residents agree, by their locally elected councils, that houses in suburban areas must have flush toilets. They believe that it's an improvement over dumping household waste in the street.
- mmagin 11y agoI think what the GP may be getting at, with respect to building codes, is that while some of them are valid safety concerns, there's a lot of them that can be attributed to "regulatory capture" -- At least here in the US, I've lived in one jurisdiction where residential electrical (120V 15/20A circuits) was mostly required to be in metal conduit (EMT or better). Elsewhere in the country, as long as it's in a wall, type NM cable (insulated solid conductors in a plastic jacket) is acceptable in the same situation. The only explanation I ever heard for this was that we were in the suburbs of a city where unions had historically lobbied for certain practices in electrical and plumbing work that guaranteed more labor had to be done. (I'm not trying to make a comment about unions here, corporations are responsible for many similar situations in US law.)
- xienze 11y ago> 100 years ago, it would have been an acceptable dwelling, or even desirable. I don't think a mud hut was ever considered acceptable in any moderately advanced country back in 1915.
- andallas 11y agoThank you, if people kept agreeing with him I was about to have an aneurysm. I have a rental property in upstate NY that was built in 1895 and is at least a century ahead of a mud hut. I'd argue several centuries, but I guess it depends on which civilization you are comparing it to.
- logfromblammo 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cob_(material)#Modern_cob_buildings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cob_(material)#Modern_cob_buil... http://www.sotaconstruction.com/project_details.asp?id=42 http://www.sotaconstruction.com/project_details.asp?id=42 Even mud hut technology has advanced well beyond huts. The "greenest building in Pennsylvania" is a glorified mud hut with underfloor heating. It contains more than just one century of advancements over the most basic earthen construction. And perhaps you haven't seen the sort of houses that people lived in, even as late as the 1930s, in some parts of the country. Let's just say there is a good reason why pre-manufactured homes are popular in certain places. Upstate New York may not exactly be a representative sample for the housing conditions in 1915.
- marssaxman 11y agoThe idea that technology has some linear progression is an illusion. I stayed in a "mud hut" several years ago during a trip to Morocco which had running water, flush toilets, and electricity. It was built of mud not because the builders lacked access to "better" technology, but because big mud bricks were a simple, practical, and economical building technology well suited to the desert environment.
- kang 11y agoI live in India and my parents lived in mud homes. My grandparents just upgraded 5 years ago. And by no means am I poor.
- nkurz 11y agoAnd you have to wonder what is going to be invented before then that will make us look at the homes we are living in right now and think, "How did I ever live in such a backwards, primitive building? If you didn't see it, you might appreciate this article from a bit ago about preserving some of the last remaining turf farm houses in Iceland: Until a century ago, and even into the 1940s, the nation’s skyline was dominated by squat, clustered turf houses. Yet despite turf’s vital role in Iceland’s history, you won’t see much of it today. Over a few brief generations, Icelanders have grown ashamed of and buried this architectural tradition, which has taken on the connotation of backwardness. http://roadsandkingdoms.com/2015/turf-war/ http://roadsandkingdoms.com/2015/turf-war/ (Separately, I'll mention that I really appreciate the level of effort you put into your comments here. They are great!)
- lmm 11y agoI don't see the terror. Many of the things we do today will one day be considered hideously backward and barbaric, sure (I've seen comments about manually-driven cars in other threads - how did we ever accept something so deadly as "normal"?) As for people not spotting the value of something, that's ok - the market sorts it out. Not many people would have thought that the most urgent thing African farmers needed was mobile phones. But there was profit in it, so some entrepreneurs did it, and it all works out.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoMaybe not 'terror' (that was just echoing the previous post) but its at least a sad thing that people living closer to nature are in actual violation of a building code.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCheetahs were once down to a couple of dozen members; they are doing fine. A fun fact: any cheetah can take an organ transplant from any other, since they are nearly genetically identical (have identical blood/immunology factors).