6 ms·
> The difference between raising taxes and cutting spending in general are enormous. Money gets shuffled around, economic activity changes, different people los
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> The difference between raising taxes and cutting spending in general are enormous. Money gets shuffled around, economic activity changes, different people lose their jobs, etc. You don't need politics or ethics to see the difference there. Yes, the government's balance sheet has the same number at the end in both cases, but everybody else's are massively changed.
OK, glad we could at least get that far. I wasn't sure we would.
> When you then cut it down to only look at non-profit organizations, and their taxes, all of that goes away. The outcomes in both cases are now identical in every respect.
It's still exactly the same difference between raising taxes and cutting spending.
> If the only difference between giving a non-profit a tax exemption
And here we have the problem. The non-profit already pays 0% tax. Their hypothetical taxes if they were not a non-profit aren't part of the budget in the first place; they don't get counted on the books as incoming taxes and a subsequent payout. Taking away their tax exemption would be raising taxes. Whereas taking away a subsidy given to another organization would be cutting spending. You already acknowledged a difference between raising taxes and cutting spending. Done.
And if you continue to dismiss anything you don't care to hear about as "meaningless politics", you're never going to get why people find some things "disturbing". But I no longer particularly care, either.
- mikeash 11y ago"You already acknowledged a difference between raising taxes and cutting spending. Done." OK, clearly you're not interested in actually paying the least bit attention to what I'm saying, and your complaints about "ignoring arguments" are just projection. Sheesh.
- forestgreen 11y agomikeash I think you were really patient here. Any economist would agree you are correct that there is no practical difference except perhaps electoral spin. JoshT appears to be either trolling or trying really hard to make a point that has nothing to do with your question. I have nothing against his point, I'm not a big fan of taxes either, but it was clear about ten posts ago that he isn't really responding to you. I think anybody reading this finds it clear so, again, bonus points for your patience!