3 ms·
The OP only replaces one fiction with a slightly more accurate fiction. The OP described only of the 'spheres in a vacuum' version of physics that tends to fal
by sandworm101 11y ago
The OP only replaces one fiction with a slightly more accurate fiction. The OP described only of the 'spheres in a vacuum' version of physics that tends to fall apart outside the classroom.
(1) There are no spheres in realworld gravity. Earth is not round. The moon is not round. Even black holes are not round. Realworld orbits, orbits around non-round bodies, are not this predictable.
(2) For purposes of space travel there is no "out of atmosphere". There are detectable wisps of gas out almost to the moon. This is the primary reason orbits decay, especially anything close to earth. The ISS would fall out of the sky very quickly without constant correction for the atmosphere it is flying through 24/7.
Pointing out errors in science fiction is a fools errand. If they listen to you and correct all the errors that you've pointed out, someone else then shows up demanding that all their errors also be accommodated. The next thing you know Freeman Dyson is on set pointing out that the stars in your backdrop are upside down. An inaccurate piece of science fiction isn't as bad a one that claims scientific accuracy when it clearly stopped listening to the Mr Dysons half way through production.
- aidenn0 11y agoGiven that general relativity and quantum mechanics seem to have irreconcilable differences, all of science education is only replacing one fiction with a slightly more accurate fiction.
- sageikosa 11y agoI prefer "usefully predictive" to "accurate".
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoThat's a terrible, terrible way to put it. QM is extremely accurate and useful in its own domain. GR is extremely accurate and useful in its own domain. We're only having problems in those domains where GR meets QM - which happen to be everyday commonplaces such as the inside of black holes, etc. Let's not taint actual science with armchair kibitzing.
- m_mueller 11y agoLots of SF contains black holes however - for which OPs statement basically applies as you write yourself. Knowing the limits of current science is important I think - especially for SF authors, since this gives them some ways to have fantastical elements (i.e. powering an Alcubierre drive) while staying scientifically acurate.