4 ms·
Yeah, I can't wait for the backlash trend, where everything goes back to being smaller, but thinner this time. I really wanted to sign up for Google Fi, but I
by sanderjd 11y ago
Yeah, I can't wait for the backlash trend, where everything goes back to being smaller, but thinner this time.
I really wanted to sign up for Google Fi, but I want a phone, not a tablet.
- masklinn 11y agoSadly thinner and smaller means cutting down the battery by a lot.
- hajile 11y agoBut smaller surface area means a smaller screen as well which works out rather well since the screen is the battery sink most of the time. This is one reason why tablets don't get better battery life than phones.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoYeah but it's not a 1:1. i.e. a 50% smaller screen doesn't use 50% less battery for the screen, let alone cut 50% battery. For one, part of the screen is powered by a controller that's pretty similar whether it's a 4 inch or 5 inch screen. So if you cut the screen in half, you save maybe 40% battery going towards powering the screen. But then the screen is only a fraction of the power usage, let's call it half. So cutting the screen in half drops battery usage not by 40%, but 20%. And then the screen is off half of the time while the phone is still using battery, which is why it's even lower than that. So half as big a screen might reduce total battery usage of the phone by say 20-30% tops. And that's without taking into account that a big chunk of a phone's internals are going to be non-battery (e.g. flash storage, cpu, ram) which don't get bigger (or at least anywhere near 2x as big) if the screen is twice as big, and so the battery-to-volume ratio on a bigger phone is bigger than on a smaller phone. In short, while yes obviously smaller phones have smaller screens that use less energy, overall bigger phones have better battery life because they have comparatively bigger batteries. As for tablets vs phones comparison, it's an apples/oranges comparison as they do different things but, no way. If you want to make the comparison, top iPad has a 42 watthour battery, iPhone 6 has 6.9. About 6x battery difference, despite the fact the 9.7 inch vs a 4.7 inch screen. That iPad has 3x as many pixels to power but 6x the battery to do it. But again, it's apples/oranges. Compare the iPhone 6 to iPhone 6 Plus. According to you the reason tablets get worse battery life is because they're bigger and have bigger screens, which are the main battery sink. So the 6 Plus should have worse battery life, according to you under the same principle. But it's wrong, the iPhone 6 Plus has 60% more watthours of battery, despite being 32% bigger. And if you look at Apple's references (usually pretty good), they rate for the Plus vs the standard iphone: 10 hours more talk time, 34 hours more standby, 2 hours more internet time on 3G or LTE, 1 hour more on wifi, 3 hours more video playback and 30 hours more audio playback. Note the video (where the screen is one of the biggest battery sinks you can imagine), it's got a battery lifetime of 27% more despite a 32% bigger phone, for all the above mentioned reasons that a percentage increase in screen size has a somewhat larger percentage increase in extra battery volume. So I'd say that the notion that bigger phones have better battery life, in general, is true. And when choosing the plus version on the iPhone, the battery life is a benefit. While choosing say the mini version on android phones (even as they're often underpowered, such as the Galaxy S mini series), tends to diminish battery life.
- jdc0589 11y agodon't you ever suggest that manufacturers make things thinner. They already have an inexplicable obsession with it. I'd rather have a slightly thicker phone and more battery
- sanderjd 11y agoI'd rather have both. Are there a fundamental laws of physics that we're hitting with battery thickness and/or component efficiency? If not, I'd rather people keep chugging away on the engineering problem, supported by my willingness to pay them for any progress they make.
- gambiter 11y agoI still think of the scene in Zoolander where he takes the flip phone out of his pocket and it is about as big around as thumb. It was comedic at the time because manufacturers were trying to make smaller and smaller phones to differentiate themselves from the brick cell phones of the past, so this scene was mocking how far it could go. The irony is that now kids probably have no idea why it's funny because all phones are competing to offer larger and larger models. I don't have a problem with the larger phones, personally, but I think it's interesting to see how quickly the industry has come full-circle.