7 ms·
Gravity Basics for Sci-Fi Authors
- mabbo 11y agoBetter alternative: play Kerbal Space Program for a few days. Suddenly, you get rocket science.
- fmorel 11y agoAside from the simplified sphere of influence that objects have (gravity up to radius, then nothing). But I agree, KSP teaches you a lot about motion.
- baq 11y agolack of Lagrange points is barely noticable when compared to some blunders that scifi works commit. every space opera author should land on the Mun to at least know what physics he's going to ignore.
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoYou know, it's really complex sometimes. Here's an example. I'm a fan of the Mass Effect game series. An important place in the games is the Citadel - a giant cylindrical space station, about 12 km in diameter, that makes its own artificial gravity by means of rotating along its axis, about 1 rotation every 3 minutes. There are elevators inside the Citadel, taking people from one level to another. The elevators are pretty fast - about 10 meters / second is my visual estimate. So you have people going "up" or "down" inside the cylinder on these elevators all the time. But wait. Combining the rotation of the cylinder with the radial motion of the elevators, a Coriolis-like force would manifest on anyone inside the elevator. I did the math, and it would be like the floor of the elevator would tilt at about 4% grade (slope) - not huge, but it would definitely push you around. There's no mention of that in the game, and people in elevators are standing straight all the time. But that's not how physics would work in reality. There's a moment in one of the games when you're taking some R&R with your buddy, and you're shooting bottles. You throw a bottle in the air, for your friend to aim at and shoot. In reality, you'll never be able to throw it straight up. Due to Citadel's spin, the bottle would always describe a shallow curve, as if wind was pushing it along the circumference of the cylinder. Granted, this is a subtle effect. Few people would notice or care. But the point is - if you're aiming for high realism, at some point you'd probably need a science consultant to point out all these weird issues that might crop up. Realism is hard.
- exar0815 11y ago"My Name is Garrus Vakarian, and this is my favourite spot on the Citadel!"
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> play Kerbal Space Program for a few days. Suddenly, you get rocket science. Seriously. With my kids (10 and 13), we watch all sorts of videos on youtube - about space exploration, rockets, etc. I talk to them about orbital maneuvers, things like plane change, Hohmann transfer, and when they don't get it, all I have to say is "remember KSP?" And they're like "oh, yeah, that makes sense".
- Jun8 11y agoI know it's basics but we really have to get rid of the bowling ball on rubber sheet or the fat man on trampoline analogies to teach GR to laypersons (http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3324/misused-physics-analogies/13839#13839 http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3324/misused-phys...). A good analogy will teach a few most important principles of a complicated concept to a beginner, this one doesn't come close. In fact, it's very dangerous because it gives the illusion of understanding by substituting the wrong concept with the right one. This can lead to confusions like this one: http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/142344/is-my-interpretation-of-how-a-gravitational-wave-is-formed-correct/142357#142357 http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/142344/is-my-inte...
- zzalpha 11y agoYeah, welcome to all analogies. Sometimes, they cause people to form the wrong intuitions. Hell, one can argue that Newtonian physics is itself a misleading analogy that leads to confusion, since people develop incorrect intuitions about, among other things, how time and simultaneity work. Now, if you can come up with a better analogy, fantastic. But the best science communicators in the world haven't done any better, so I'm not holding out a lot of hope for success...
- baghira 11y agoI strongly disagree. There's a regime in which Newtonian gravity describes the world. There is no such regime for the rubbersheet model of GR, since the Earth's gravity is responsible, not the sheet's curvature. It's the illusion of explanation. EDIT: I'd also remark that collapsing centuries of debate on what's a scientific theory into "everything is an analogy" is a disservice to the public: good luck distinguishing realism, structural realism, positivism, etc., if you put on the same level science popularizations and proper (albeit imperfect and incomplete) scientific theories. Also, the science communication bit is a red herring. There are plenty of concepts that cannot be explained easily to the public. One might justify just as well going around popularizing Laffer's curve, since actual macroeconomics is impossible to explain on a napkin.
- Thrymr 11y ago"Orbital time near the surface doesn’t depend on the size of the object. If two planets or moons, or even asteroids, have density similar to earth, it will take about 90 minutes to get around in low orbit. Size doesn’t matter! (Only density and distance from the surface.)" Density doesn't matter either (at least for objects with a mass that is a negligible fraction of the Earth's, and even if that is not the case it would be mass that is the primary factor).
- Someone1234 11y agoI have perhaps an ignorant question... So the earth's mass essentially causes a distortion in space time which causes gravity. My question is, even to the smallest nth degree, why don't we observe other objects on earth with their own gravitational field? For example if I take a giant ball of lead, and I move it around in a vacuum but on earth, why doesn't it act like it has its own magnetic field and cause dust (again, in a vacuum) to be disrupted as the field passes over them? Has this effect been observed (under controlled conditions)?
- alexbock 11y agoWe have observed the gravitational field generated by lead balls. The classic example is the Cavendish experiment [1] which is rather important historically for figuring out the value of the gravitational constant. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment
- tlb 11y agoYes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment is the original.
- hsk 11y agoEverything has a gravitational field, but gravity is extremely weak, so you never notice it. Just imagine how a tiny fridge magnet can overcome the gravitational pull of the entire Earth. Scale down the Earth to the size of ordinary objects and you can get an idea of how weak gravity is.
- snowwrestler 11y agoBecause every piece of mass has its own gravitational field, the Earth's total gravitational field is lumpy, not a smooth sphere. The lumps are caused by variations in the crust and mantle, like mountain ranges, valleys, and variations in rock types. It is possible to map the lumps using a tool called a gravimeter, which is basically an extremely sensitive mass balance. This is one way in which we do observe (and use) tiny variations in gravity on Earth.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- platz 11y agoRelativity by PBS Space Time https://www.youtube.com/playlistlist=PLsPUh22kYmNAmjsHke4pd8S9z6m_hVRur https://www.youtube.com/playlistlist=PLsPUh22kYmNAmjsHke4pd8...
- snake_plissken 11y ago"By the same token, the force of gravity scales linearly with a planet’s diameter. Half the diameter of a planet and you get half the gravitational force at the surface..." Wait, what? Assuming the mass of the planet remains constant, wouldn't you get 4 times the gravitational force at the surface?
- ISL 11y agoThe linearity result assumes constant density, not constant mass.
- useless 11y agoI think the assumption is the density remains the same (rho=M/(r^3)) stays the same so GM/(r^2) becomes G rho r.
- derobert 11y agoThe article isn't presuming mass stays constant, but rather that density does. (That's a much more realistic assumption—a world made out of similar stuff will have similar density, for reasonable amounts of gravity)
- aaron695 11y ago> Assuming the mass of the planet remains constant, wouldn't you get 4 times the gravitational force at the surface? No idea why you'd ask this question but yes. But the original statement is wrong isn't it, if you half the diameter you 1/8 the gravity [1/8 the mass] [edit] But you'd also be twice closer, which is 4 times the force, got it.
- sandworm101 11y agoThe OP only replaces one fiction with a slightly more accurate fiction. The OP described only of the 'spheres in a vacuum' version of physics that tends to fall apart outside the classroom. (1) There are no spheres in realworld gravity. Earth is not round. The moon is not round. Even black holes are not round. Realworld orbits, orbits around non-round bodies, are not this predictable. (2) For purposes of space travel there is no "out of atmosphere". There are detectable wisps of gas out almost to the moon. This is the primary reason orbits decay, especially anything close to earth. The ISS would fall out of the sky very quickly without constant correction for the atmosphere it is flying through 24/7. Pointing out errors in science fiction is a fools errand. If they listen to you and correct all the errors that you've pointed out, someone else then shows up demanding that all their errors also be accommodated. The next thing you know Freeman Dyson is on set pointing out that the stars in your backdrop are upside down. An inaccurate piece of science fiction isn't as bad a one that claims scientific accuracy when it clearly stopped listening to the Mr Dysons half way through production.
- aidenn0 11y agoGiven that general relativity and quantum mechanics seem to have irreconcilable differences, all of science education is only replacing one fiction with a slightly more accurate fiction.
- sageikosa 11y agoI prefer "usefully predictive" to "accurate".
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoThat's a terrible, terrible way to put it. QM is extremely accurate and useful in its own domain. GR is extremely accurate and useful in its own domain. We're only having problems in those domains where GR meets QM - which happen to be everyday commonplaces such as the inside of black holes, etc. Let's not taint actual science with armchair kibitzing.
- 11y ago
- tbabb 11y ago> Like the coin trap’s slope, the curvature of space becomes infinite at the event horizon of a black hole. So time literally stops [...] so actually you can’t reach the event horizon. I think this is completely wrong. Isn't the curvature at the event horizon large but finite? The curvature is only infinite (in theory) at the singularity.
- hsk 11y agoCorrect. A safe observer far from the black hole will observe a singularity at the event horizon, but that is a coordinate singularity, not a true one. There is singularity at the event horizon for a falling observer. A falling observer will pass through the event horizon and reach the center, which is a true singularity that physics currently cannot explain.
- iofj 11y agoI think you mean there no singularity for a falling observer. Given that time slows down, it is not a certainty that you'll fall through the event horizon. There are two viewpoints: For an outside observer: the black hole will evaporate (over many billions of years) before you ever cross the event horizon. For the falling observer: There shouldn't be an event horizon at all. That brings the question: what happens. Occam's razor would seem to indicate that most likely you'd just keep falling. There are various "solutions" to this problem being worked out. One is that the surface of the event horizon is actually a universe all by itself, with 3d space you can live in. Over time that space would collapse into nothing, and that would happen quickly, but not instantaneously. This space is visible from the outside of the black hole, and you can interact with it but because time goes so much faster in this space any light escaping from it would appear extremely redshifted and weak.
- baghira 11y agoYes, that part is definitely wrong. The free falling observer crosses the horizon in a finite time. It's the external obsever that see the infalling object redshifted to infinity. An the curvature scalar is finite everywhere except that at the singularity.
- codethief 11y ago> Gravity drops on linearly inside a planet, going to zero at the center. Anything dropping through a cored planet or asteroid will bounce up and down the shaft just like a kid on a swing or a pendulum […] …assuming the density distribution is homogeneous which is not fulfilled for Earth [1] and even more unreasonable for gas planets like Jupiter. > So actually you can’t reach the event horizon. As was already pointed out, this is not correct. > The closer you get, the faster the universe behind you moves. Stars are born and die in a tick of the clock, galaxies form and collide, galactic superclusters orbit super-superclusters and before the whole universe can die Gravity is a non-linear theory. Different solutions to the field equations cannot simply be superimposed, so aligning the time variable of a Schwarzschild spacetime (let alone of a falling observer) with the time variable of a Friedmann solution (which describes the evolution of the universe as a whole) is a priori very difficult. I would be very careful about trusting the above statement. > Imagine the lines on a ruler getting further apart the closer you get to a gravitational object. Oh god. This is wrong on so many levels. > Closer to the star, distances seem longer. Longer than where? This seems to assume that one could move a scale from one region of spacetime to another to see it grow or shrink. But this is wrong. Distances are tied to the spacetime by virtue of the metric which is a field and hence depends on where in spacetime you are. It makes absolutely no sense to compare the metric at two different points. > The more gravity, the slower time runs. Slower than where? Similar to above, distant observers cannot simply compare the hands on their clocks, so in general this statement makes no sense, either. The only thing one could compare are the lengths (eigentimes) of time-like curves starting and ending at the same spacetime events (like it was done in Interstellar: One person stayed in the orbit, the others went down towards the black hole and returned later). Also, in what geometry is all this supposed to happen? The author probably assumes a Schwarzschild geometry. But in a Friedmann universe, for instance, where gravity is strong as well, time keeps passing in the same way for all observers moving along with the matter, even as the universe might collapse (and gravity might intuitively become stronger). Conclusion: Gravity is not that simple that it can be broken down to a few easy facts. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_of_the_Earth#Structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_of_the_Earth#Structu...