3 ms·
I sympathize with the problem, and wish for a solution. That said, its not a symmetrical relationship. One party is pressed into the predicament unwillingly: t
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
I sympathize with the problem, and wish for a solution.
That said, its not a symmetrical relationship. One party is pressed into the predicament unwillingly: the refugee or homeless person. Their population can be considered uniform i.e. the presence of a predator is no different than in the general population.
The folks offering their home as a refuge, volunteer. Their population may be laced with predators, who could find this relationship to be fertile ground for abuse opportunities. This could increase the risk to the refuge-seeker by one or two orders of magnitude.
SO the only ones risking anything above meeting any random new person, is the refugee.
This is no fault of all the good people who enter this relationship with open heart and open arms. Its just an unfortunate fact of game theory.
- Mz 11y agoI really do not understand what your point is and I fear that it would be a long, long hashing out process to get my point across, one I am not keen to enter into for a variety of reasons, chief of which is that it sounds like you are justifying the bias against homeless and refugees, so this is likely to be an uphill battle that makes me look bad no matter how I handle it. Suffice it to say I stand by the assertion I have already made at least twice: Dealing with security concerns of all involved parties will be a make-or-break detail for such a project. The specific concerns each side has may differ, but you need to look at making sure everyone is equally protected or this has disaster written all over it.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI'm afraid I didn't express myself well; I mean just the opposite.
- Mz 11y ago:-) I don't know what to do for the refugees, but if you really want to work on homelessness, you can get involved in some way in helping make affordable housing more available where you live (I am assuming you are American). There is a huge deficit of decent, affordable housing. If it were not in such short supply, there would be fewer Americans on the street. If you can think of no other means to get involved, then support Habitat for Humanity in some way. I also run a couple of websites where I talk about the topic, one aimed at helping homeless individuals, one aimed at putting out good information for those interested in the problem space.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoYes I understand Habitat is doing very good work. My sister is part of a womens' roofing crew; my nephew is a regional coordinator. And of course Jimmy Carter endorses it, which is really all I need to know!
- Mz 11y agoThe site is currently tiny, but here is where I try to talk about what helps the homeless: http://whathelpsthehomeless.blogspot.com/ http://whathelpsthehomeless.blogspot.com/ I am trying to frame solutions that are grounded in the realities of what causes homelessness while honoring the fundamental humanity and dignity of homeless individuals. I think anything less tends to make the problem more entrenched, not less entrenched. It is a high bar to meet, and that's part of why the site is being developed so very slowly.