8 ms·
Only because John Deere designed their tractors to require poking around the ECU to replace a hydraulic sensor. They could build that failure mode into a millio
by wlesieutre 11y ago
Only because John Deere designed their tractors to require poking around the ECU to replace a hydraulic sensor. They could build that failure mode into a million places if they wanted.
What if your next car from GM said "Oh the oil light came on. You'll need to go to the dealer for an oil change so they can have the engine control unit turn the oil light off."
Suddenly an easy fix turns into something protected by the DMCA, and we're just supposed to be OK with it?
http://www.wired.com/2015/02/new-high-tech-farm-equipment-nightmare-farmers/ http://www.wired.com/2015/02/new-high-tech-farm-equipment-ni... for anyone who hasn't seen the John Deere story:
> The family farmer who owns this tractor is a friend of mine. He just wanted a better way to fix a minor hydraulic sensor. Every time the sensor blew, the onboard computer would shut the tractor down. It takes a technician at least two days to order the part, get out to the farm, and swap out the sensor. So for two days, Dave’s tractor lies fallow. And so do his fields.
- wlesieutre 11y agoOr on the hypothetical car example, it wouldn't even be "Take it to the dealer." Try "Your car isn't going to start even if you changed the oil. Just have it towed to your driveway and come up with other transportation until an authorized repair tech can come and press a button for a few hundred dollars."
- mc32 11y agoCertainly the move to frustrate easily replaceable parts by tying it in to the ecu is a dick move. However, the push should be to challenge that aspect, rather than say ecus should be free to be modified any which way. Imagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems. So, I'm of two views on this. Critical systems should not be allowed to be modified by uncertified technicians, or similar, but at the dame time, they should not classify non critical components as critical. Some reasonable authority should make those calls, not the mfg or Joe/Jo public.
- nitrogen 11y agoRegulations, IMO, should describe behavior, not implementation details. If my fully customized ECU still passes emissions tests, then nobody should have any say about whatever else I do or do not do with it.
- LordKano 11y agoImagine airbus or boeing or the FAA allowing uncertified code to enter critical commercial aircraft systems. Yeah because some tractor is as much of threat as a 450 ton jumbo jet. Even if there were no regulations preventing it. Even if there were no technological locks preventing it. No one would install unapproved software on such a contraption because the risk of getting sued out of existence would be too great.