3 ms·
You're preaching to the wrong person...I think the world would be a better place if everyone could grep/sed/awk their way through textfiles. That said, imagine
by danso 11y ago
You're preaching to the wrong person...I think the world would be a better place if everyone could grep/sed/awk their way through textfiles. That said, imagine the agency's situation: They have thousands of documents to review before releasing. Many/most of these emails are releasable as is. But some potentially contain classified information that cannot be known a priori...i.e. it's not as simple as doing a grep for "CLASSIFIED" or "OSAMA". In fact, one of the current controversies with the Clinton email is that they're finding information that should have been treated as classified, but at the time of sending, was not...the conditions for classification aren't often based off of keywords, but on the context and who the sender is.
Occam's Razor falls on the side of the print-to-paper-then-scan-to-PDFs. When you print an email or Word document to paper, you have effectively destroyed all non-visible metadata. When you use a Sharpie to rub out a name, you can be sure that mark is going to propagate to the electronic scan. You have none of those assurances if you work electronically...and imagine being someone who _isn't_ a programmer. Not too long ago the NSA was clusterfucked by a low-level employee who ran wget without anyone noticing. If you're the non-programming bureaucrat in charge of this bespoke redaction process, software seems very arcane and insecure...paper sounds pretty nice in comparison.
But yeah, I do wonder about the amount of human labor and late nights that go into this. But apparently, a lot of our legal system has revolved around legions of paralegals and lawyers sifting through uncountable volumes of paper...and a lot of the people doing the current redaction probably came from that field of work.
- brc 11y agoI meant Occam's razor as a way of explaining why they were handed over as paper - the simplest explanation being they were intentionally making it harder. I get why the agency might print it out- but I don't get why the Clinton staffers would print them out. If the government is going to subpoena or raid me, they're just taking my computer. Sure, if it gets to public release, then they might print/redact. But they sure are not going to wait for me to print out stuff and hand it over. Given the original 'two phones are too difficult' excuse for having the private emails, I can't see how printing out the paper and handing that over can be seen as anything but deliberate delaying. Unless I'm missing something here, it's not like the Clinton staff redacted the mails themselves - they just deleted the ones they didn't want to hand over. If the agency staff are redacting for public release, then that is a different thing altogether, they could have done that from the original emails.