3 ms·
Is College Tuition Really Too High?
- ArtDev 11y agoThis shouldn't be a question as college should be free.
- closure 11y agoNothing is free. Even if the student isn't paying tuition, someone is. So in your opinion who should that be?
- throwawayredux 11y agoAnyone else but her or himself, obviously.
- lokedhs 11y agoEverybody, in the form of taxes. After all, education benefits the entire society so it makes sense everybody helps pay for it. It's also a good way to take advantage of all potential instead of only the ones that happen to have money.
- closure 11y agoThat's already happening in the U.S. - State schools are heavily subsidized by taxes. I went to one which was (and still is) relatively inexpensive for in-state students and delivered fantastic value for what I paid. Saying "universities should be free" and that it should be paid for "by taxes" without being more specific about which universities and what taxes paid for by which specific people doesn't really add anything.
- lokedhs 11y agoWhich universities? All that gets anything from the state (like subsidies, etc) Which people? Everybody that can pay for it. It should come out of the state budget. I.e. the same people who pays for the military, the roads, the politician's salaries.
- cableshaft 11y agoThose subsidies have gone way, way down since at least 2008, for quite a few states. That's part of the reason tuition has been skyrocketing, to make up for the reduced subsidies. At one school that I know someone who works on the staff, the state was perpetually six months behind where it was supposed to be for payments and they had to go through a 40% reduction in their subsidy. In Illinois, they even proposed a bill to privatize their public schools this year. I don't think it passed, but the fact that it was even proposed says something. Source: http://www.dailyeasternnews.com/2015/03/24/senator-proposes-bill-privatizing-public-universities/ http://www.dailyeasternnews.com/2015/03/24/senator-proposes-...
- jazzyk 11y agoInexpensive? It costs $26K/year (tuition + room&board) to attend University of Massachusetts.
- pluma 11y agoEveryone. Other people's education is a form of infrastructure. Everyone benefits from living in an educated society so everyone should pay for it via taxes. But of course this is completely unrealistic in the US where even socialised healthcare is looked upon as bordering on communism.
- ionised 11y agoThe tax payer.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"these schools spend considerably more than $100,000 a year educating each student" Averaged over 30 weeks, that's $3.3k. I could pay a private tutor $100 per hour ($150 including payroll taxes and benefits) for 20 hours per week and still pay less than $100k per year.
- SixSigma 11y agoMy University has five floors of library and a multi million pound budget that includes student access to online electronic versions of books and journals. It also hosts regular events and guest speakers. It organises paid industrial placements for students, foriegn exchange programmes at no extra cost, it's own concert hall, a super-computer and, until he stepped down this year, you got your degree handed to you by Sir Patrick Stewart (Capt. Picard) but for my graduation I will have to make do with Prince Andrew. There are more benefits my tution goes toward. Economies of scale are a thing.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"Economies of scale are a thing." Yes, economies of scale are a thing. They generally cause average cost per unit of output to decrease, as total output increases. As I said, for the $100k/pa cost quoted by the article, a single student could afford to pay for pay+tax+benefits for a 1:1 tutor, 20 hours per week. Given that most university lectures/seminars/tutorials have a much larger student:teacher ratio, economies of scale should mean universities would achieve a much lower cost of tuition. I get that universities do other things. I get that they need to build and maintain infrastructure. I get that they need to subscribe to journals. But all of that is spread over all of their students. Regarding the example you introduced: The University of Huddersfield has ~20k students. Its total expenditure is ~120m GBP ($180MM) per year[0]. That's about $9k per student per year. That's less than 1/10th of the $100k expenditure per student quoted in the original article. [0] http://www.hud.ac.uk/media/universityofhuddersfield/content2013/services/finance/Financial%20Accounts%202013-14.pdf http://www.hud.ac.uk/media/universityofhuddersfield/content2...
- 11y ago
- camillomiller 11y agoYes. End of article