3 ms·
> First, there's the "me too" effect. If colleges pay football players, other athletes will want to be paid. They'll ask, "What makes football special?" That's
by smacktoward 11y ago
> First, there's the "me too" effect. If colleges pay football players, other athletes will want to be paid. They'll ask, "What makes football special?"
That's easy: what makes football special is that it generates absolutely gigantic piles of cash. If a delegation of athletes from, say, the college ultimate frisbee team were to demand similar compensation, the burden would be on them to demonstrate they're generating similar revenue.
(And if they can actually make that case? Then heck, pay them too!)
> Then we'll run into some unhappy truths regarding sports. For example: If colleges base compensation on revenue, the wage gap between male and female athletes will be massive.
Wait -- because we might end up paying female athletes less than male athletes, we shouldn't pay any of them anything? Surely we can cross this particular bridge when (and if) we ever actually come to it.
> Then there's the problem of mixing sports and education.
Which isn't really a problem, because the "education" many (most?) college football players currently receive is pretty nominal anyway.
> It seems to me that most of these problems would be solved by creating a minor league separate from college.
I'm always wary of a proposed solution whose first step is "change everything," not least because frequently it's proposed less to provide an actual alternative than to delay taking any steps at all to improve the situation. Don't make the perfect the enemy of the good, in other words. You can advocate for creating a whole new league if you want to, and maybe someday that will happen, but in the meantime there's all these real people getting really screwed out of real money they've really earned. A whole new system that takes 10 or 15 or 30 years to get worked out and implemented doesn't do them any good. So let's just start paying them, and then we can take all the time we want to work the bigger questions out.
- chroma 11y agoI'm fine with a huge wage gap, but most people aren't. There's an odd defect in most people's thinking where if you make some small contribution toward solving a problem, they'll berate you for not doing more.[1] I'm simply pointing out that because of this, the author's solution is politically infeasible. Paying college athletes is probably as difficult as starting minor league football. There are a significant number of regulations in place to prevent college athletes from being compensated, to ensure gender parity, and to stop colleges from spending "too much" on sports. Their efficacy varies, but repealing them would be an immense political effort. For starters, you'd have to get rid of Title IX. There's no hill-climbing solution here. We're in a local maximum. :( 1. http://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ http://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethi...