4 ms·
You've never heard God mentioned at a conference because the religious people are hiding from bigots like you. Plenty of scientists have seen a connection betwe
by sp332 11y ago
You've never heard God mentioned at a conference because the religious people are hiding from bigots like you. Plenty of scientists have seen a connection between faith and science and if you can't, it's probably your own fault.
- NN88 11y agoI judge the religiosity of the scientist by the field they're in. Social sciences and economics get more leeway than say...physics or chemistry. Then you have a few in the middle like biology or math.
- sp332 11y agoAd hominem arguments are of course irrelevant. A person's work should be judged on its merits.
- unmole 11y ago> I have never heard the word “God” mentioned in a scientific meeting. Belief or nonbelief in God is irrelevant to our understanding of the workings of nature The second part is key here. Whatever connection 'plenty of scientists' see between faith and science, it has no place at a scientific conference. That aside, calling someone a bigot or some other label in order to distract from the actual topic at hand is hardly productive. Like he says at the end: > If that is what causes someone to be called a militant atheist, then no scientist should be ashamed of the label.
- PascLeRasc 11y ago> Whatever connection 'plenty of scientists' see between faith and science, it has no place at a scientific conference. I'm assuming that you mean that non-science has no place at a science conference. Scientists who see a connection between faith and science will see that as science, which is why it's as important to them as a type of protein folding or particle decay might be to someone else.
- jeremysmyth 11y agoScientists who see a connection between faith and science will see that as science Only if such a connection is documentable, predictable, hypothesizable, and reproduceable. Calling anything else "science" is diluting the word. (apologies to string theorists: https://xkcd.com/171/ https://xkcd.com/171/ )
- sp332 11y agoScientists still talk about food, art, ethics, and so on. They just avoid talking about religion.
- deciplex 11y ago> You've never heard God mentioned at a conference because the religious people are hiding from bigots like you. They probably should. Religious belief betrays at least a partial rejection of what science even is. If you can apply one set of rules to determine, say, the efficacy of some new drug undergoing testing, but another set of rules to how you believe the universe works, then you don't really understand either.
- PascLeRasc 11y ago> Religious belief betrays at least a partial rejection of what science even is. Can you go into more detail about what this means?
- deciplex 11y agoIf you are religious, then you either think that religion is a valid alternative to science for certain problems, or that testable predictions are not important in some domains. Which is to say, either you think that scientific reasoning isn't always a good way to understand our world, or you don't think understanding how our world works is really so important. All else being equal, good scientists will possess neither of these qualities.
- sp332 11y agoScience only has bearing on testable, repeatable hypotheses. History, for example, isn't science even though it tries to deal in objective truth. "Testable predictions" aren't everything.
- deciplex 11y agoTo the extent that history is the organization and interpretation of known past events, no it is not science. But, neither does it need to be, since it is not factual discovery - it is not dealing in objective truth, rather cataloging known truths. However, the part of historical study that concerns itself with gaining knowledge about the past is absolutely science, and it can and should make testable predictions. If you read historical accounts of Mongolian invasions of Eastern Europe, you might expect and predict that Eastern Europeans would have a genetic heritage that is partially shared with present-day Mongolian people - and indeed that turns out to be the case. If they didn't, we would have reason to believe the historical accounts are exaggerated or even false. In other words, "history" might not be science depending on your definition, but anthropology certainly is. Any statement you make about reality, or a model for reality, should have a consequence in anticipated experiences. If it doesn't, you haven't gained any knowledge.