4 ms·
">>Making it easier and faster to approve transit projects." I moved out of CA, and man alive is it surprising how... corrupt... Caltrans is. I mean, really. I
by Balgair 11y ago
">>Making it easier and faster to approve transit projects."
I moved out of CA, and man alive is it surprising how... corrupt... Caltrans is. I mean, really. In Denver we are building a rail line all the way out to the airport from downtown, something that I got to see start (2011) to finish (granted, spring 2016, but I have no doubts about it) for $1 billion total([2], projected cost) at ~8200 per foot. It's not a subway, so no digging, and the land is cheaper, but all the same. Something like this would be unimaginable in CA to take less than 15 years. The AirBart cost about $29,000 per foot and still costs $6 per ride [0] with a development time of ~30 years([1]data is suspicious though). Yes, it's elevated and in earthquake country, but my god, 29k a foot?! That's 3.5 times the cost per foot than in Denver. I honestly don't see it. Sure, the balance sheets are all likely out there in the public ledger, but honestly, I don't if I can trust them. In the end here, the author of this piece is right, but he misses the issue of corruption that plays into "Showing a willingness to think big." You can think big all you want, but if there is excessive need to 'grease wheels' to get something moving and built, then all the pie in the sky thinking in the world isn't going to do anything without the cash.
[0]http://archives.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/controversial-bart-to-oakland-airport-connector-opens-but-questions-remain/Content?oid=2912859 http://archives.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/controversial-ba...
[1]https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2014/news20140612-0 https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2014/news20140612-0
[2]
- spikels 11y ago$29k a foot is nothing! The Central Subway project currently under construction from Chinatown to the CalTrain station (the only major subway project built in SF in many decades) will cost $1.6 billion (assuming no cost overruns) to build and go 1.7 miles. That's around $190,000 per foot!
- crygin 11y agoThat's 3.5 times the cost per foot than in Denver. Heh, given that land out there east of the Arsenal refuge is almost free and the cost of building an elevated structure in an earthquake zone... this comparison is the first time the AirBART replacement has sounded cheap!
- hapless 11y agoThe second avenue subway is 3.2 km long, and the projected cost is 4.45 billion. That's $428k per foot.