4 ms·
Um, you can't wave a wand and get more housing. It has to go for a rent, that pays the developer for the construction AND land price including annual property t
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Um, you can't wave a wand and get more housing. It has to go for a rent, that pays the developer for the construction AND land price including annual property tax. In a high-land-value area, available housing will only be built for those that can afford it. No magic bullet.
- simoncion 11y agoCouple of things: * Generally, in CA, unless a property changes hands, its annual property tax increase is capped at 2% per year. * AIUI, SF could waive any property tax increases for residential properties that would have been triggered by flattening the existing structures in order to build much more rental housing. [0] [0] I'm not convinced that there would be any if the property didn't change hands, but it has been years since I read Prop 13.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Generally, in CA, unless a property changes hands, its annual property tax increase is capped at 2% per year. I think you are referring to the maximum increase in tax basis value (which is only equal to the maximum property tax increase if it is taxed at the maximum value already, though that's probably the case, given the low cap on property tax rates also in Prop 13.) And you are oversimplifying in a way which is misleading in this discussion: new construction triggers full cash value assessment not limited to the annual 2% increase. > AIUI, SF could waive any property tax increases for residential properties that would have been triggered by flattening the existing structures in order to build much more rental housing. To the extent that they could, where would the sense be in that? Accommodating more people, but reducing the public available to provide services needed by those people?
- simoncion 11y ago> And you are oversimplifying in a way which is misleading in this discussion: new construction triggers full cash value assessment not limited to the annual 2% increase. 1) That's why I listed two points, rather than just one. :) 2) According to the Alameda County Assessor's office, the situation is not as grim as you seem to paint it (for every situation except the "building flattening" situation): "Only the portion of the property which was newly constructed is subject to reassessment at market value. For example, if a family room is added to an existing home, only that portion is reassessed and the existing home will retain its previously established Proposition 13 base year value." [0] This might partially explain all the damned San Francisco apartments with funky vintage 1970's-era single-paned windows. :P > To the extent that they could, where would the sense be in that? To encourage the build-out of housing in an area that has roughly between three and ten new people move in for each new housing unit constructed annually? 1) It's not like SF is currently starving for cash. 2) In the -very, very unlikely- scenario that only the ultra-wealthy, pensioners, and property "investors" occupy San Francisco, what happens to the tax base? What happens to the character of the city? [0] https://www.acgov.org/assessor/about_property_assessment/new-construction.htm https://www.acgov.org/assessor/about_property_assessment/new...
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoIsn't 2%/year enough of a property tax increase? Why should I suddenly get a tax bill I can't afford because some idiot bought the house next door to me for too much money, causing my "property value" to skyrocket?
- yummyfajitas 11y agoBecause you don't own your home, you are renting it from the state. The state has just discovered that it has a higher market value and can use the money to fund all sorts of cool CA government projects. Maybe one day Jerry Brown will find enough money to adopt Narendra Modi style initiatives to end open defecation.
- simoncion 11y agoYou don't appear to understand what Prop 13 means for Californian real estate owners. Either ask Google, or check my comment history for a primer.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoI own a house in 94087, and I absolutely understand Prop 13. And if it were to fall, I'd leave CA immediately.
- jacobolus 11y agoThe “wand” here is zoning. All the pale yellow areas in this map are zoned to allow only low density residential, mostly one unit per lot: http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1569 http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1569 If you re-zone some significant portion of the western and southern 3/4 of San Francisco by zones that allow for e.g. the construction of 4–5 story low-rise apartment buildings (ideally allowing ground floor retail), there will be room for dramatically more housing units to be built. Developers are currently rushing to build on every bit of available land in SF that allows medium density construction (all the bits of that map that aren’t pale yellow). All of the parking lots, warehouses, and little one-story buildings in such areas are being converted to luxury condos at maximum speed. With better transit and municipal planning throughout the Bay Area, there are many places where it would be possible to dramatically expand housing stock and bring housing rent down to more reasonable levels.
- teacup50 11y agoIf this even worked in the short-term (and so far, no city that has tried this has been successful in making a meaningful dent in the problem), you'd just be delaying the inevitable, and once that inevitable hit, the affordability problem would be even worse. You can't increase housing supply without affecting demand. You also can't increase housing supply to meet demand ... unless you actually make the area so undesirable that demand itself drops, meeting you halfway.
- jessaustin 11y agoThis observation could be made about anything. If more restaurants open, more people will go out to eat. If more people go out to eat, restaurants will make more money. A vicious cycle! Soon everyone in the world will eat lunch in our city, every day! The humanity! In fact, interesting yet flawed theories of supply and demand are seldom used to justify some sort of "protect existing restaurateurs' oligopoly" law. That isn't to say that it isn't valid to limit the number or type of restaurant in any particular area for e.g. safety reasons. But that has to be process-based, not just a declaration that this neighborhood has enough. You can't argue that allowing single-family structures to be replaced by e.g. townhomes in a reasonable fashion is somehow beyond us as a society.