4 ms·
What's the difference between me giving you $X and me ever so generously not taking $X from your bank account? Also note the phrase "non-profit". This isn't a
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
What's the difference between me giving you $X and me ever so generously not taking $X from your bank account?
Also note the phrase "non-profit". This isn't a benefit we give to everyone; you have to have a registered non-profit that works towards some charitable cause (such as, in this case, giving people a free or low-cost education). If you want to argue that non-profit organizations should not exist, or argue for more constraints on the definition of public benefit, feel free; the article likely didn't because that would garner a lot less sympathy than disingenuously equating non-profits to picking the government's pocket at the expense of taxpayers.
Now, that said, I do have a fair bit of sympathy for the idea of limiting the granting of non-profit status, as well as many tax deductions, but only in conjunction with drastically reducing taxes for everyone. Non-profit status and tax deductions would matter a lot less if everyone paid an order of magnitude less in taxes across the board, and then we could eliminate the administrative overhead of tracking all of those things.
- mikeash 11y agoThe difference between your two scenarios is that in one scenario I have $X more than in the other scenario. In my two scenarios, the money you have at the end is the same for both. As for "If you want to argue," I'm not arguing anything. I'm asking what the difference is between a direct subsidy and a tax exemption, as the comment I replied to is complaining about the author conflating the two.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> In my two scenarios, the money you have at the end is the same for both. How do you figure? Could you elaborate on the baseline assumptions you're making there? Note that the universities getting paid tax money collected from taxpayers don't pay taxes themselves either.
- mikeash 11y agoThe article counts tax exemptions as "subsidies." The comment I'm replying to calls this "disturbing." Therefore I'm asking what the difference actually is between a tax exemption and a more overt subsidy. For an example, let's say you'd normally pay $1 million in taxes. I could subsidize you by paying you $500,000. Or I could give you a tax exemption worth $500,000. The net result on your finances is the same. So I'm wondering what mhb sees as being the difference between the two, such that it's "disturbing" to mix them up.
- punee 11y agoYou only need to read the second sentence of his post. It couldn't be any clearer.
- mikeash 11y agoThat doesn't explain what the difference actually is, merely a perceived consequence of mixing it up.
- punee 11y agoThat's because you're being unnecessarily obtuse. It's fairly obvious what the difference is between not being compelled by the government to give $500,000 you have earned, and being given $500,000 worth of taxpayer money.
- mikeash 11y agoSo you say. But if the net result is the same, then is there any actual difference, or just ideologues being upset because they want people to think of them differently?
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> For an example, let's say you'd normally pay $1 million in taxes. There's the problematic assumption. As stated in my previous post, the public universities receiving taxpayer funds aren't paying taxes either. So the article compares universities paying no taxes and receiving no taxpayer funds with universities paying no taxes and receiving taxpayer funds. And then they try to skew the comparison by equating "taxes we could get if we took away non-profit status" with "taxes we already take from taxpayers and pay out". The amounts might both be denominated in dollars, but the payer and payee are materially different. Among other things, consider that people donate and make endowments to public universities as well. (Oddly enough, this never causes those universities to ask for less taxpayer funds.) For that matter, raiding a non-profit's coffers won't lower everyone else's taxes by the funds raised. The difference making the comparison somewhat more "disturbing" is an appearance of entitlement: making the comparison implies an entitlement to take those funds, subject only to a decision to take them.