7 ms·
It is disturbing that the author so lightly morphs a tax exemption into a taxpayer subsidy. As if the natural state of things is for the government to tax ever
by mhb 11y ago
It is disturbing that the author so lightly morphs a tax exemption into a taxpayer subsidy. As if the natural state of things is for the government to tax everything and whatever it doesn't is being subsidized.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat's the difference between giving you $X that other people don't get, and asking you to pay $X less in taxes that other people have to pay?
- rubidium 11y agoBecause it's an educational institution. That's the whole point! Harvard gets to have people with no money get degrees from their school for free because of this. It's a wonderful thing for society that they have such a big endowment. Why anyone would get so money hungry as to attack them is beyond me.
- hackuser 11y ago> Harvard gets to have people with no money get degrees from their school for free because of this. As far as I know, enrollment at Harvard and most other elite institutions skews heavily toward wealthy people.
- smeyer 11y agoYes, Harvard disproportionately has many wealthy people compared to the population at large, but it also provides free educations to large numbers of people. Last I checked, the cutoff was around 60k (meaning, if your family makes less than 60k, Harvard will foot the entire bill). The challenge of overcoming this skew towards wealthy students has more to do with education in general and recruitment than the price tag when it comes to some of the wealthiest schools.
- Retric 11y agoHarvard does this to maintain it's rankings not because there operating a charity. If the goal is to educate people with tax payer money giving lot's of it to a private group who then goes and spends a tiny fraction of that educating high achieving poor people is a ridiculously inefficient use of public funds.
- smeyer 11y ago>Harvard does this to maintain its rankings not because they're operating a charity I disagree. I'm not saying that the tax exemptions are the best or justified or anything, but Harvard has consistently been one of a few leaders in financial aid, dragging other schools with them. Harvard could have excellent rankings regardless of financial aid, but provides great financial aid to get the best students. When such a small fraction of the money comes from tuition, it just doesn't make sense to try to squeeze every last penny out of tuition and force less wealthy students out in the process.
- hackuser 11y agoOne reason, at least, that they skew toward wealth is that they don't market themselves to others. Recent research has shown that the best poor students often have no idea that Harvard and other elite schools exist (as hard as that is to believe for most people on HN), much less that they might be accepted and afford to attend, and that they never apply. Remember that many of these students come from a world where few go to college, much less where elite schools are discussed or where their graduates and others with those kinds of career are around them. And the few who make it fail at much higher rates; from what I recall research points to the fact that colleges are geared toward middle/upper-middle class students, mostly white. The cultural adjustment is huge (remember these are 18 year olds leaving their neighborhoods for the first time) and few adults or peers understand their situation. Also, many have poor support from home, financially and socially; rather than receiving encouragement, they get asked why they are wasting time and money on college. In effect (and assuming Harvard follows those patterns) Harvard offers aid with the knowledge that few will take it, and without orienting their services to serve the new students. They could do much better. From what I understand, Amherst has gone a long way toward solving these problems.
- mikeash 11y agoHow does that answer my question? If you want to complain about attacks then you can do it at the top level.
- mhb 11y agoOne difference is that there aren't just two sets in the tax-paying universe. Another is that this isn't zero sum.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't understand, how are either of those differences between the two scenarios?
- JoshTriplett 11y agoWhat's the difference between me giving you $X and me ever so generously not taking $X from your bank account? Also note the phrase "non-profit". This isn't a benefit we give to everyone; you have to have a registered non-profit that works towards some charitable cause (such as, in this case, giving people a free or low-cost education). If you want to argue that non-profit organizations should not exist, or argue for more constraints on the definition of public benefit, feel free; the article likely didn't because that would garner a lot less sympathy than disingenuously equating non-profits to picking the government's pocket at the expense of taxpayers. Now, that said, I do have a fair bit of sympathy for the idea of limiting the granting of non-profit status, as well as many tax deductions, but only in conjunction with drastically reducing taxes for everyone. Non-profit status and tax deductions would matter a lot less if everyone paid an order of magnitude less in taxes across the board, and then we could eliminate the administrative overhead of tracking all of those things.
- mikeash 11y agoThe difference between your two scenarios is that in one scenario I have $X more than in the other scenario. In my two scenarios, the money you have at the end is the same for both. As for "If you want to argue," I'm not arguing anything. I'm asking what the difference is between a direct subsidy and a tax exemption, as the comment I replied to is complaining about the author conflating the two.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> In my two scenarios, the money you have at the end is the same for both. How do you figure? Could you elaborate on the baseline assumptions you're making there? Note that the universities getting paid tax money collected from taxpayers don't pay taxes themselves either.
- mikeash 11y agoThe article counts tax exemptions as "subsidies." The comment I'm replying to calls this "disturbing." Therefore I'm asking what the difference actually is between a tax exemption and a more overt subsidy. For an example, let's say you'd normally pay $1 million in taxes. I could subsidize you by paying you $500,000. Or I could give you a tax exemption worth $500,000. The net result on your finances is the same. So I'm wondering what mhb sees as being the difference between the two, such that it's "disturbing" to mix them up.
- rubidium 11y agoNo kidding. "And since bestowing tax exemptions is the same as spending cash from the government’s perspective". I physically shuddered as I read that. The authors entire argument falls apart right there.
- guelo 11y agoAn accounting truism made you shudder?
- jobu 11y agoHow is that wrong? The government decided not to tax these college endowments because they were considered a public good. That decision had a direct effect on the government's budget - a cost.
- vixen99 11y agoIndeed that's true. A government in a country which decides to absorb all wealth created by its citizens (100% taxation) would bear a cost should it allow any dispensation. I guess there'd be a powerful debate on whether the latter was justified and fair.
- hackuser 11y ago> As if the natural state of things is for the government to tax everything and whatever it doesn't is being subsidized. Why shouldn't everyone pay their share? If I'm paying my share and you aren't paying yours, I'm subsidizing your government services.
- kailuowang 11y agoNot the same thing here. The rich people already pay their share in tax that supports public education that they don't benefit from. The people who go to public education don't pay anything more. Now the author is arguing that the rich people needs to pay more tax because they pay for their own education by going to a private school? That doesn't make sense to me.
- hackuser 11y agoIt depends on how you define a 'fair share'. In my mind, it's defined as everyone making the same amount of sacrifice. Equal sacrifice does not mean an equal amount of money; $1K is much more of a sacrifice for someone with $10K than for someone with $10 million. It does not mean the same percentage of tax; again, 20% of your income is a much larger sacrifice if you make $10K than if you make $10 million. > The rich people already pay their share ... I'm not sure we can say that without first defining their share? Maybe they are paying less or more than their share. > public education that they don't benefit from I disagree strongly. The wealthy have benefitted much more from public services than everyone else, including from education. Could you imagine a country without education? Without public education who would be their employees? Who would be their customers? Their vendors? Who would provide the endless network of services on which our economy and their wealth is built, from banking to research to roads to the political and legal systems to security to technology ... Even the wealthiest have built only a tiny edifice on a massive foundation built by our predecessors, and are wholly dependant on our contemporaries.
- chrisBob 11y agoFurthermore they focus on per student numbers when a lot of the work done at private universities is graduate education and research work. Comparing based solely on the tax advantage / # of undergrads doesn't capture the difference in what the schools do.
- scott_s 11y agoThat's how most economists view a tax exemption. An exemption means that ordinarily, this entity would be taxed, but because it is deemed to be special in some way, they get an exemption. From the perspective of an economist, that's money the government is giving up, which is no different than paying that money out.
- ovulator 11y agoThis was my biggest problem with the article, he also goes on to compare direct funding for public university vs tax breaks on the private university, but completely ignores that public universities ALSO have endowments which are also not taxed, and should also be factored into the equation. Obviously Harvard's still shadows everyone else, but he isn't comparing apples to apples. For instance, the school with the second largest endowment? University of Texas $25 billion.
- dalke 11y ago"completely ignores that public universities ALSO have endowments which are also not taxed, and should also be factored into the equation" About 2/3rds of the way through the first page, the author addresses not only that topic, but even references the endowment of the University of Texas system. I quote: > More substantively, Schneider and Klor de Alva’s report probably exaggerates the overall subsidy gap between elite private and state colleges to a degree. For instance, it doesn’t count the tax savings that some large state institutions enjoy on their own endowments—the University of Texas at Austin, for instance, is part of a nine-school system with a $25.4 billion endowment, while Rutgers has more than $900 million to its name. The study also doesn’t consider subsidies from the federal Pell grant program, which mostly benefit lower- and middle-income students at public institutions. And, perhaps most importantly, it probably overstates how much money colleges are saving thanks to their nonprofit status each year, because it treats all increases in the value of their endowments as taxable income, whether or not they were actually realized.
- jedrek 11y agoIn the context of competition, tax exemptions are de facto subsidies. If my company has an ETR of 10% and yours would be the same if it weren't for the 50% reduction you got, you can underprice me by a few points and still have a higher profit all other things being equal.