4 ms·
The difference is that in the case of a car insurance web site, I know before I pay them any money that I have to provide them with personal information. Also,
by lisper 17y ago
The difference is that in the case of a car insurance web site, I know before I pay them any money that I have to provide them with personal information. Also, it's clear that when the product is insurance, there is a legitimate need for the company to have your personal information.
In this case, I don't find out that I have to turn over my personal information until after I've paid for the product, and after I break the seal so I can no longer return it. And there is a penalty for not turning over my information: I don't get the instruction manual. It is certainly a mild form of extortion, but it is extortion nonetheless.
- gaius 17y agoExtortion is a crime - it means obtaining money, property or services from another through threats of physical harm. Did that happen here? Umm, no. The author is just incoherent with made-up internet-privacy hysteria. Secondly, you have statutory rights. That little EULA is meaningless and everyone knows it, hell there's a bloke on GMTV nearly every morning banging on about consumer rights. If the product's not fit for purpose then that's that.
- lisper 17y ago> through threats of physical harm No, physical harm is not a necessary element of extortion. All that is needed is a threat of harm. In this case, the threat of harm is to deny the customer access to the manual for the product they bought and can no longer return. It is certainly not the most serious extortion ever perpetrated. But it is extortion nonetheless.
- fatdog789 17y agoHarm, as the law defines it, must be physical injury, monetary loss, severe emotional distress, or a substantial interference with recognized contractual rights. Denying access to a manual is not a cognizable harm, since the customer is not contractually entitled to a manual. (Unless the box says, "Contents:...manual..." Hence, no extortion, legally, or otherwise. Furthermore, the manufacturer does not get to set return policies -- the STORE sets return policies. (Also, if the product was purchased with a credit card, the CC company should be more than happy to handle the billing dispute for you.)
- gaius 17y agoWords like scam, extortion, blackmail, evil don't mean, well, anything to Internet people. Or maybe, everything is.