4 ms·
The exam paper is interesting to look at, but whether it is actually a difficult exam to pass depends far more on the stringency of the marking scheme and how m
by notahacker 11y ago
The exam paper is interesting to look at, but whether it is actually a difficult exam to pass depends far more on the stringency of the marking scheme and how much the average entrant actually knows. If half the people taking the exam don't know who Weber was and you can pick up 3-4 marks on the question for making generic comments about the internet and rationality, that question suddenly looks a lot less challenging, especially when it's only 2-5% of the paper.
I'm not well qualified to comment on the Indian-themed questions, but most of the world affairs questions don't appear especially difficult to write a vague statement that picks up some marks even with general ignorance of the subject matter, and I'd suspect that most people with a decent interest in world politics and current affairs (and a good education) could get middling scores on those questions.
If anything, I'd be more concerned about losing marks from not sharing the same view as the examiner on "Africa was chopped into States artificially created by European expansion." Analyse and "Male membership needs to be encouraged in order to make women's organization free from gender bias" Comment. (especially if being marked by a bureaucrat rather than an academic) rather than the inherent difficulty of the subject matter.
What matters much more for the actual difficulty is whether it's intended on selecting the top .5% or just screening out the bottom 50%. And perhaps also whether some of the more controversial political questions are marked based primarily on knowledge, nuance, or adherence to the viewpoint of the examiner.
- logfromblammo 11y agoI know enough of the art of bullshittery to recommend a general strategy. If you don't know to respond to a question that does not have an objectively correct answer, first transform it into a question that you can answer, then answer that question instead. For an example of how this works, just watch any political debate or interview with a politician. In any venue where the questions are not known in advance, the speaker prepares a limited set of possible responses, then weasels from the actual question to the closest possible prepared response before rattling off whatever that may be. So rather than memorizing key ideas from all famous philosophers, you learn about 3 things about just Nietzsche, then preface your show-off response with a sidestep and a hand-waving shuffle from Weber to Nietzsche. It's a lot easier to do when the questions are bullshit in the first place. And on a civil service exam, I'm pretty sure I'd also intentionally add a slightly wrong "duck" somewhere in my answers, so the examiner can feel intellectually superior to me while marking me down for it. The impression you want to convey is "this person is smarter than the other applicants, but not as smart as I am."