12 ms·
TSA Security Directive SD-1544–09-06
- beeker 17y agoThe more scared people are, the easier they are to control.
- waterlesscloud 17y ago"Disable aircraft-integrated passenger communications systems and services (phone, internet access services, live television programming, global positioning systems) prior to boarding and during all phases of flight." Because you can't blow up the plane if you don't know where you are.
- timcederman 17y agoI did notice that the map was disabled on my flight back from Australia yesterday. Pretty annoying. By the way - GPS watches work just fine in a plane.
- mrduncan 17y agoBy the way - GPS watches work just fine in a plane. It sounds like they are not allowed to be used according to that document though. I would imagine that cell phones also work just fine (I've never had the urge to try), but that doesn't mean their use is allowed. Edit: Misread the document, I stand corrected. This is just another one of the TSA's typical security illusions.
- rufo 17y agoThe document specifically mentions "aircraft-integrated" GPS devices.
- mdasen 17y agoCell phones are a bit of a different story. Cell phones were designed to be operated somewhere around 0-100MPH from the surface (or very close to it). A plane violates those assumptions. That's important in a couple ways. First, if you're in the air, you have line of sight to a lot more cell sites than you normally would. While there might be a couple sites at any give point that are a similar signal strength to you, here there could be hundreds. Basically, cellular wireless is based off the idea that your transmission only goes so far and therefore they can re-use the same spectrum in different locations (or, in the case of CDMA systems, not have every code talking over each other, but rather have a limited number of voices screaming). Being on a plane violates that. With a CDMA system, you'd either be drowned out by closer signals or you'd be causing a ton of interference for all towers within range and it'd be a lot of cell sites. With a TDMA system, you'd be transmitting on a frequency/time-slot that would be re-used on another tower that could similarly hear you. To explain that a bit more: in real life if you have: Tower FreqA :: Tower FreqB :: Tower FreqC :: Tower FreqA in a linear fashion and you're transmitting to the first tower (using frequency A), your signal won't reach the last tower (which is using frequency A to talk to a different customer). However, if you're flying above all the towers, all of a sudden you have line of sight like you've never had before and if you're transmitting to the first tower on frequency A, your signal is also likely being heard by the last tower as well meaning that the entire theory of re-use goes down the drain. Likewise, you're travelling at (potentially) 500 miles per hour. Travelling at 60MPH, you'll likely need a new cell site every few minutes (depending on geography and the like). At 500MPH, you could be getting new sites more often than not. Combined with the fact that you'd be in "range" of so many sites as noted above, it would become difficult for the network to determine which site you should be transmitting to/from. And that is important. Cellular wireless only works because the same finite bandwidth can be reused since you aren't using that bandwidth in all locations. So, unless microcells are used on the plane itself, wireless service is a terrible idea in the sky. A microcell in the plane would get the phone to transmit at a very low power (therefore not interfering with customers on the ground) and the cell site would be a constant distance from you. It's why even in countries where the aviation folk are moving toward cell phones on planes, they're doing so through microcells. I'm not saying that it would't work. I haven't studied it, but it wouldn't be a wonderful experience and would cause havoc for the network. EDIT: It seems that it's an FCC (in addition to FAA?) prohibition in the US (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_phones_on_aircraft#USA_Channel_reuse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_phones_on_aircraft#USA_C...). The article on Wikipedia also mentions airlines installing microcells (although not by name) to allow people to call on planes.
- johns 17y agoI think he was referring to cell phone GPS
- mrduncan 17y agoFor the record, I was referring to transmitting information with another party (either text or voice) - should have been more specific.
- mrduncan 17y agoVery interesting explanation, thanks! I would imagine that text messaging probably wouldn't be subject to these issues since it's just a quick burst of data. It would also be a little easier to get away with using too.
- mdasen 17y agoWell, the issue is even having the phone on since your phone needs to been in communication to cell sites via the control channel (which determines how to send an incoming call to you, what tower you should be using, and allows for sending/receipt of text messages). So, you might not be causing problems for the traffic channel and the speed issue probably wouldn't be a problem, but you'd still be causing problems on the control channel even by having the phone on. Granted, if a few people did it, it might not matter, but if everyone did you'd have the exact same problem where you'd be defeating frequency re-use.
- lallysingh 17y agoBy the way - a departure time, and arrival time, and a wristwatch all work fine in a plane.
- jm4 17y agoI think you're missing the point. The idea is to make it more difficult to stage an attack around a specific location, such as a heavily populated area or landmark.
- jrockway 17y agoAirplanes have windows. Also, I could write a computer program to use my cell phone's GPS receiver to activate an electronic device at a given location. (Hell, I do this to turn off my ringtone at work.) Stuff that into the overhead compartment along with your bomb, and the plane is finished... at exactly the location you pre-program. (You don't even need to be on the plane. Put your bags in the overhead compartment, stuff some other bags in front of it, "oh shit, I forgot $foo in the terminal", done.)
- imajes 17y agoThe don't need to be on a plane bit- if you end up leaving the plane once you've boarded, the plane isn't going to pull away from the gate till you're either back on the plane or everything you took onboard with you is deplaned. Now, that doesn't mean to say that you couldn't hide a bag onboard with such a device, and then make some kind of excuse that you have to go back to your office because there's some kind of emergency, and you won't be taking the flight after all. But then, you'll have had to somehow get your device into the sterile area (requiring accomplices who work there, or some surprisingly good luck getting through the x-ray scanners and explosive detection machines). In other words, the security we had pre 9/11, with a little bit of modernizing, does the job fine. The rest of it (shoes, liquids etc) are really just theatre.
- encoderer 17y agoHave you ever tried to leave a plane after boarding? This isn't fool proof but the FAA policy that my dad experienced years ago was that the passenger was dissuaded from leaving, the captain came out, and he was told that if he exits the plane they have to sweep it and because of that he'd be denied reentry. Passenger insisted. Argued a bit. Long story short, the passengers all had to disembark with their luggage and go back through security screening. And the flight crew presumably did their standard pre-boarding sweep. This was, oh, 2002 or so. I wouldn't be surprised if they even let you off the plane anymore, at least not until the 3-hours are up that the new regs mandate. And similarly, there has long been double-checks to make sure that no checked luggage is on a flight that isn't matched to a passenger. My understanding is that luggage that is freight checked (like, they lose your luggage and throw it on a later flight to get it to you) has to be more thoroughly screened.
- bmm6o 17y agoYes, this is the part of the rules I find most confusing. Someone with the ability and desire to blow up a plane wouldn't do it unless they could be sure they were on approach to the destination? There would be more devastation if the plane crashed into a densely populated area, but he would give up if he couldn't maximize the impact? The only thing I can think is maybe it has more to do with the altitude of the aircraft and the hour window is whether the plane is on its final descent or not. Perhaps the explosion is not too powerful, and the pilot could recover in time if the plane is high enough? I'm not sure that's plausible.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoIt's not too difficult to notice your plane is descending. And you know the length of the flight, within a reasonable tolerance. So timing can't be too hard. This rule makes no sense at all.
- ojbyrne 17y agoNor is it difficult to look out the window and see that you're over an urban area.
- dagw 17y agoLet's say you are a terrorist organizer and have found a novel way to get a bomb onto a plane. Assume also that if you abort the mission before detonation chances are good you'll get the bomb off the plane without detection. You probably also realize that any method you use will only work once, so you want to make sure that one use is used to best effect. Given this I can see the logic in aborting a mission which would give a sub-optimal result given that there is a reasonable chance you can try again for a better result later.
- shin_lao 17y agoBeing able to blow up the plane in the sky is terrorizing enough I think. You don't care about the death toll, you just care about the fear.
- mrduncan 17y agoThe original posting (as best I can tell), which has additional information, is at the following site - http://boardingarea.com/blogs/flyingwithfish/2009/12/27/tsa-security-directive-sd-1544-09-06-the-fallout-from-nw253/ http://boardingarea.com/blogs/flyingwithfish/2009/12/27/tsa-... This blog appears to have just repeated what was posted there.
- _ck_ 17y agoThat 1st hour and middle hour or two are perfectly safe. Apparently only the last hour is unsafe on a plane. Seriously, stop flying people. They have you because you give yourself to them. Just work online, etc. drive otherwise. Once the airline industry needs bailouts and the TSA have people visibly twiddling their thumbs, suddenly rules are going to become much more reasonable.
- jparise 17y agoThe liquids aspect of this sounds like a pain to enforce. At least in the US, the initial security screening (before you get to the gates) is supposed to filter out all liquids (over 3oz.), but once you're through security, you can buy gallons of drinks, etc. from the stores in the terminal. Thoroughly inspecting those liquids at the gate without advanced equipment sounds really difficult.
- apgwoz 17y agoWhat's interesting to note is that I've found box cutters in the stores within the gates of one airport before. I wonder what the regulations are for airport merchants?
- steveklabnik 17y agoOften, restaurants 'on the inside' will give you knives with your steak.
- imajes 17y agoRight, one large argument against the 'sterile area' joke is that it's very easy to acquire weapons - anything from workmen's tools to steak knives are easily accessible.
- zandorg 17y ago2.1. All people wishing to fly must flap their wings. Airplanes are banned for being unsafe.
- flatline 17y agoAt least they are (so far) only enacting it for a few days. I really wonder what would happen if people consistently, politely resisted, by keeping things in their laps, by getting sick and having to run to the bathroom in the last hour of the flight, etc. Seriously, how are flight attendants supposed to enforce this stuff, and what are they to do about unruly passengers? An airplane is not exactly a high-security area.
- mrduncan 17y agoThe security on an airplane is the other passengers (and air marshals). I can guarantee that if you start resisting commands from the flight attendants you're going to attract attention from other passengers. Like it or not, the first thing that's going to pop into their heads is that you're planning on bringing their plane down. Hypothetically, lets say that all passengers coordinate such an event - I'd imagine that's a really easy way to gain admittance to the no-fly list.
- pavel_lishin 17y ago> I'd imagine that's a really easy way to gain admittance to the no-fly list. And that's probably your best case scenario.
- henrikschroder 17y agoWhy even comment on this story? It isn't even security theater anymore, it's amateur's night at the corner pub, with knee-jerk policies that a normal five-year-old kid can figure out how to get around.
- maxklein 17y agoAnd people still ask me why I prefer taking high speed trains! Flying by plane is so nerve-wracking nowadays, what with dogs sniffing about and burly custom agents and you have to arrive 2 hours beforehand, wait in long lines, sit in an enclosed room and wait even longer, share a bathroom with hundreds of other people. In euro style fast trains, you arrive 2 minutes before, walk in, you can go have a meal, there is electricity for your laptop, there are toilets everywhere. For any journey that can be done in 6 hours with the train, the plane journey, which would take between 1 hour and 2 hours actual flying, will take much longer. That high speed train china built is the way to go. Planes should be used for flying really big distances, and then trains should be used to go on. The entirety of europe should be connected with trains, the U.S should have 10 major airport hubs and the rest done with trains. Nowadays, flying is just such a bother!
- dtf 17y agoIn euro style fast trains, you arrive 2 minutes before, walk in, you can go have a meal, there is electricity for your laptop, there are toilets everywhere. Or for those stuck on last Friday's Paris-London Eurostar, not so much toilets everywhere as everywhere a toilet. I payed a premium to use the channel link to get me home this Christmas and, after 3 days of travel hell and sheer incompetence before I finally got on, I can't see myself ever using them again. In fact, after reading what actually occurred under the channel on Friday - tunnel operators seemingly asleep, staff going AWOL, passengers urinating on the floor, not to mention Kent police interrogating those who finally made it out as if they were potential terrorists (save for Claudia Schiffer, who got a police escort home and a free croissant) - I'm not sure I actually trust them to even run a safe service, let alone a convenient one. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/12/22/eurostar_eurotunnel_fiasco/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/12/22/eurostar_eurotunnel_... My faith in international rail travel from the UK has been destroyed completely in one fell swoop, and it has nothing to do with the engineering malfunction that instigated it all.
- ams6110 17y agoTerrorists blow up trains, too.
- deleted 17y ago
- axod 17y agoI still really want someone to try and blow up a plane by dousing their clothes in some flammable/explosive/unstable chemicals. Then we'd all be told to fly naked, or in airport provided suits.
- jrockway 17y agoI'm waiting for people to start blowing up expressways. Then maybe we can get some decent public transportation.
- msluyter 17y agoI used to joke that in the future they'd simply take all of your clothes and personal possessions at security, stamp your hand with an ID number, and make everybody wear hospital gowns.
- cjoh 17y agoKeep in mind this is only about flights originating in non-US airports with destinations in the US. None of this stuff applies to your flight back home to New York from Kansas next week.
- acangiano 17y agoFor now.
- mixmax 17y agoNot all of us are from the US.
- cjoh 17y agoNo America-Centric implication was intended and I apologize if I came across that way. Just seemed important to bring up since the lead comment as of this writing is about using high-speed trains as an alternative. And unless there's something happening that I don't know about, there isn't a high-speed transatlantic train in the worls.
- mixmax 17y agoNo worries mate :-)
- akl 17y ago.. kind of. There are some reports of these rules being enforced on domestic-only flights, too: http://gizmodo.com/5435117/the-unofficial-guide-to-flying-after-the-underwear-bomb?skyline=true&s=i http://gizmodo.com/5435117/the-unofficial-guide-to-flying-af... (scroll down to the 'be ready for anything' part)
- muriithi 17y agoThe terrorists have won.You don't have to bring down an aircraft to make flying a nightmare. I know this sounds insane and the Terminally Stupid Administration will not allow it, but if someone came up with a "low security" airline, where screening was done by the airline itself using their own guidelines, I would be an enthusiastic customer. We only need two things, an airline that values it's customers but is not willing to lose any planes and passengers who are alert and ready to take on any threats in the air. The latter attitude has been there since United Airlines Flight 93, the former is a mirage.
- decadentcactus 17y agoI agree. I don't see the need for such an invasive govt run organisation to get airlines to provide security - they already will have an interest in not losing their planes, they're expensive as hell.
- lssndrdn 17y agoIt's true that these security directives don't seem to make much sense, but what is the alternative? I think what they are tring to accomplish is to simply reduce the risk of a repeat "accident" along the same line of the one that happened on Dec 25. After an incident like that, the TSA just cannot afford to have someone else pull a similar stunt, it would only further ruin their already low credibility. The challenge is about striking a balance between having passengers bring whatever they want on a plane and having them fly naked and anesthetized, just like if they were cargo.
- trafficlight 17y agoNobody is going to pull the same stunt. The people building these devices aren't stupid. Kneejerk reactions never solved anything.
- jsz0 17y agoIt sounds like these directives are based on specific intelligence of currently planned attacks and not meant to be broader long term regulations. What if there is good intelligence to suggest there are a dozen other attackers known to be trained and ready for this mission? If they are already in-transit and have a communication black-out from the leaders it seems entirely possible they would attempt it despite the failures.
- mortenjorck 17y agoThe TSA has now officially become like an abusive, paranoid husband. Every event that has happened thus far has made him more suspicious and less rational, but the "lap burner" has at last pushed him over the edge into raging paranoia, doubling down with fevered lists of arbitrary, bizarre restrictions that make sense only to his unhinged mind. And there's nothing we can do. We depend on him. We can't just walk out; where would we go?
- elblanco 17y agoI've noticed though, that ever sense the TSA got their new dark blue uniforms (from the old white ones), they seem to be quite a bit more respectful at least.
- icey 17y agoWhat do you think will happen after this directive expires? EXPIRATION: 0200Z on December 30, 2009
- nollidge 17y agoI was going to point that out also. This isn't a permanent change. It's still silly, but at least it's not permanent like the stuff with liquids and toenail clippers.
- pmorici 17y agoNotice how the thing is signed, "Gale Rossides Acting Administrator" In other words the TSA still doesn't have a permanent head even though the new administration has now been in office for a year.