6 ms·
Decoding Steve Jobs, in Life and on Film
- tptacek 11y agoAll of this misses the point entirely. We don't mourn people as a sort of achievement award for a life well spent. We mourn people we feel a connection with, because of the pain we feel at losing the connection. Jobs was a gifted promoter whose public speaking style tilted casual, informal, and personable. He was effective in part because, at least on stage, he made you like him. Lots of people are likable, and when they die we don't mourn them, because we never think about them. But Jobs forced people to think about him, because he was the public face of a blockbuster series of products that people talked about year-round. It's not that launching those products was so praiseworthy that it "earned" him a mourning. It's that the combination of his on-stage personality and the popularity of those products more or less forced us to. That's not a bad thing, by the way. I think there's something human and basically nourishing about thinking about strangers as people, and constructing even a fabricated, artificial form of empathy for what they and their loved ones are going through. That those emotions have no practical connection to the world we live in is irrelevant.
- MCRed 11y agoAlso, this is the guy who really made a dent in the universe. While HP was founded in a garage, the Apple Garage is the story people know. He lead passionate and talented people for many years to create or fundamentally transform significant industries and inventions-- everything from the GUI, the Laser Printer to the phone were hugely impacted by teams he lead... not to mention NeXT and the first real object oriented operating system. By the way, I worked at Microsoft on an object oriented operating system at the same time that Steve was leading NeXT. Microsofts effort was cancelled because it was a threat to windows, but I can say, having worked with both NeXT did it right, and microsoft totally missed the mark-- that's because of Steve inspiring innovation, as opposed to Bill Gates controlling engineering-- two very different styles of management. I mourn Steve because he was a great guy, a nice guy, and a true leader. There hasn't been another on par with him in the tech industry... interestingly the closest possible people to reach this same stature are Tim Cook and Elon Musk. One was taught by Steve and the other is another very unique light.
- dragontamer 11y ago> Also, this is the guy who really made a dent in the universe. Dennis Ritchie died around the same time as Steve Jobs, and I always found it a shame that one is remembered significantly more than the other. Creating Unix and The C Programming language counts as making "a really big dent" in the universe. But maybe that's just me.
- pekk 11y agoMore people have a stronger emotional response to iPhones, which Steve Jobs is identified as being responsible for.
- dragontamer 11y agoI recognize this. But Hacker News is a technology forum. I'd hope people would recognize the relevance of Dennis Ritchie to our field around here. Alas, popularity is a weird thing.
- tptacek 11y agoMourning is not a lifetime achievement award. Frankly, when I hear people comparing Ritchie to Jobs, the (unkind) thought that pops into my head is: "This person feels nothing about either death, but feels strongly that people should know how much smarter they are than everyone else". Increasingly elaborate justifications, for instance about how important Ritchie is to the work people on HN do, don't help that.
- randallsquared 11y ago> Mourning is not a lifetime achievement award. It certainly is one metric by which you could measure lifetime achievement. I don't really understand the apparent strength of your reaction against it, though.
- dragontamer 11y ago> Increasingly elaborate justifications, for instance about how important Ritchie is to the work people on HN do, don't help that Co-Inventor of C and Unix doesn't need any explanation, and is hardly "elaborate" if you work in this field at all.
- melling 11y agoSteve Jobs was relatively young when he died. He had finally turned Apple around and probably would have led Apple for at least two more decades. Wonder where a guy who cared so much about product would have taken us? If he were 90 years old, the loss would have felt a lot less impactful.
- larrys 11y ago"We mourn people we feel a connection with, because of the pain we feel at losing the connection." Large groups also mourn because (for lack of a better way to put it) a crowd effect. There are people who are impacted for sure but then there are people who will come along for the grief ride that really wouldn't care if their friends didn't drop the idea and the importance into their head. Or if there wasn't a great deal of media coverage which stokes the grief.
- bitwize 11y agoI'm sad that he died, eapecially so young and by delaying treatment that could have improved his prognosis. But one thing I'm beginning to appreciate is that the reality distortion field is sort of fading away. Wozniak has stepped up and talked more frankly about Jobs's real role inside Apple, especially during the early days. And increasingly though he is still regarded as a Leonardo among product managers, people are recognizing that Jobs was a control freak and that technical people do not want to live in his locked down, curated universe. So we mourn, but we also feel free to acknowledge things after his death that we stifled while he was still alive for fear of our hero losing his glamour and being less of a guiding light.
- tptacek 11y agoAnd that's totally fine, and probably (given current SFBA ethos) healthy. But "too many people were mourning for Jobs" is a weird reason to start that evaluation, and it's the reason the filmmaker gave. My only objection is to the idea that people need to earn mourning. I'm not trying to defend Jobs beyond that. I didn't know him, or work for Apple.
- pekk 11y agoI follow your point about personal mourning, it doesn't have to be earned. But this is tangled up with public recognition of the man's achievements on the level of Einstein, Gandhi and Martin Luther King. So maybe the filmmaker misstated a more reasonable point.
- codecamper 11y agoI think a big reason why Steve Jobs has had a couple movies made was because the Mac has been used by creative professionals for many years. Apple almost died in the middle 90s. Now Apple is the most valuable company on Earth. It's an epic story. Plus, he was weird. Black turtle neck uniform? Ideologies formed in the 60s and yet transforming the modern era? This is great stuff and perfect for story telling.
- coldtea 11y ago
- johnchristopher 11y ago> That's not a bad thing, by the way. I think there's something human and basically nourishing about thinking about strangers as people, and constructing even a fabricated, artificial form of empathy for what they and their loved ones are going through. That those emotions have no practical connection to the world we live in is irrelevant. But the Steve Jobs persona, you describe how it was built in the previous paragraphs, was not a stranger to anyone. The whole Apple marketing team and Jobs built that. He's less a stranger than some people you meet everyday on a commute.
- inthewoods 11y agoAndrew Sorkin lost me with the comparison to MLK.
- melling 11y agoYou might dismiss Sorkin but Wozniak's approval is significant: http://www.cnet.com/news/woz-aaron-sorkins-steve-jobs-movie-gets-it-right/#ftag=CAD590a51e http://www.cnet.com/news/woz-aaron-sorkins-steve-jobs-movie-... Update I guess I'm guilty of not realizing there are two different people named Sorkin working on a Steve Jobs movie.
- andrewtbham 11y agoAm I the only one confused by the fact Andrew Sorkin just released a documentary about Steve Jobs, but Aaron Sorkin is about to release a dramatic movie about Steve Jobs. Their names are very similar.
- jccalhoun 11y agoOne of us is confused because I thought Andrew Sorkin was the guy who wrote the article not the guy who made the documentary.
- jasode 11y ago>Mr. Gibney held out John Lennon and Martin Luther King Jr. as somehow more worthy than Jobs of the wave of grief that took place after they died. So all it boils down to is if the particular flaws of a person pushes a critic's hotbuttons, he/she deserves less praise. For example, if someone's hot button is "wife beater" or "pedophile", he will dismiss John Lennon and Jimmy Page. If someone else's hot button is "plagiarizer" or "adulterer", she will dismiss MLK and JFK. As far as we can tell, Steve Jobs never raised a hand against his wife. But, he did treat subordinates very callously. What to make of all this? Society doesn't venerate people for the wife beating or employee mistreatment. It's always the other accomplishments that overshadow those flaws.
- larrys 11y ago"Steve Jobs never raised a hand against his wife. But, he did treat subordinates very callously." Part of it might be simply that people don't recognize mental pain as being as bad as physical pain. [1] The truth is mental pain can last a great deal longer and have much greater impact than physical pain but that is often not the way the world sees things. [1] Not that getting hit by a spouse doeesn't cause mental pain of course.
- MCRed 11y agoBy the way, it's interesting how we hear about all the "evil" things that Steve did-- often overblown for political reasons- but we never hear about the far more heinous things done by others, for example, Bill Gates retarded the entire tech industry by a decade with dishonest, and criminal behavior. Yet he's seen as a "good guy" because he's got a really good personal PR agency and has been spending 20 years rehabilitating his image. Steve's real crime- - why so many people who never met him and don't really actually know much about him, yet still hate him-- is that he didn't employ PR to polish his image. This is also why people think Amazon-- a horrific place that abuses workers and has little technical innovation-- is a "tech company". That's what you buy with effective PR.
- GCA10 11y agoToo funny! Both Apple and Microsoft have huge PR teams. Apple's is relentlessly effective at creating product awe; Microsoft's not so much. Both Jobs and Gates lived the lives they wanted and talked to the media as they saw fit. The results speak for themselves. If you look at billionaires' standing in the course of American history -- going back to John D. Rockefeller and Henry Ford -- they always end up with a tangled blend of admiration and loathing. In the end, PR has surprisingly little impact. There's always plenty of achievement to satisfy the fans; plenty of villainy to justify the critics.
- dragontamer 11y agoBill Gates is also seen as a "good guy" because he's spent the last decade of his life eradicating Polio in developing nations. Steve btw has "retarded" the ebook industry, built up "closed gardens" across the application universe, and has prevented the iOS from ever receiving 3rd party hardware upgrades by design. Bill Gates may have been ruthless ruling the 90s with Word and Windows... but even he was significantly more open than Apple ever was with their iPhone.
- pekk 11y agoYour perspective on this seems skewed. We have never stopped hearing about how "evil" Microsoft was. Microsoft is a company most people love to hate. There are not any movies painting Bill Gates as an inspired, messianic product visionary. Apple used monopolistic practices many times itself, but this is rarely discussed. There would not be much backlash against Steve Jobs if he had not been beatified by a brand-loyalty cult as the Design Messiah Who Changed Everything. That story was written by Apple, and now nobody can get away from it. There are plenty of other execs who made piles of cash selling widgets that were slightly different from other widgets, but we don't develop strong opinions about those guys because we never have to hear about them.
- andrewtbham 11y agoThis article makes me think of pg's recent essay... Why it's safe for founders to be nice http://www.paulgraham.com/safe.html http://www.paulgraham.com/safe.html
- draw_down 11y agoIt's impossible to get an accurate measure of the man now, there is just too much noise that comes along with the cementing of his status as a cultural icon. It's impossible to escape interpretations of certain parts of his life. Huge chunks have been forgotten, etc. Even while he was alive everyone had their take on him, but now to try to contend with the books (widely-panned authorized biography) and movies (also panned), forget it. I would be interested to see more examination of his illness and how he handled it, though. Seems like he completely blew it.
- atorralb 11y agoI can only think he was a piece of shit for prohibiting engineers to be emploeyed in other tech companies