15 ms·
How do these things work in the case of physical goods and documents? For instance, suppose you and I are both US residents, residing in the US. You loan me so
by tzs 11y ago
How do these things work in the case of physical goods and documents?
For instance, suppose you and I are both US residents, residing in the US. You loan me some item. I fail to return it and you sue me. The court orders me to return the item to you.
If I had that item in a storage locker in Los Angeles, there is no question that the court would have the authority to order me to retrieve that item and turn it over to you or to the court.
Suppose, however, I have taken the item to Mexico and have it in a storage locker there? Can I now get away with telling the court that since the item is in Mexico, the court does not authority to order me to retrieve it (or to order me to instruct the storage facility to retrieve it and ship it to me)?
Similar question for physical documents. For instance, if GM set up a documents storage facility a few miles away from its headquarters, across the border in Canada, and kept all documents not actively in use at the Canadian facility, would they then be able to fend off document subpoenas from US safety investigators this way?
- datapolitical 11y agoWhat if you stored it on a cloud server, but you encrypted it with strong keys and a password?
- cletus 11y agoThere are two entities in question: you and the object. You are within the jurisdiction of the U.S. And can be held in contempt, charged (even in absentia), etc. The object is now within the jurisdiction of Mexico so it gets complicated. A Mexican court can be petitioned to require the entity that (unwittingly or not) possesses it to turn it over, etc. The difference with data Ina server is that a company has the power to turn it over regardless of where it's stored and the U.S. Government is having their hat on that. By physically locating servers in other jurisdictions you have to comply with their laws too and that gets complicated. You can end up Ina situation where one government doesn't recognize the authority of the other and you're damned if you do, damned if you don't. Personally I find the constant overreach of the U.S. Government to be appalling and entirely short term I it's thinking.
- mcv 11y agoThe problem in this case is that the data does not belong to the US government, but to a private person. If the law in Mexico says that you're not allowed to give someone else's object to the US government, obeying US law might require breaking Mexican law.