3 ms·
The thing is, a lecturer spends 20 minutes doodling this and can explain most of the same, especially if there is some ability to directly interact with the aud
by jacobolus 11y ago
The thing is, a lecturer spends 20 minutes doodling this and can explain most of the same, especially if there is some ability to directly interact with the audience and clear up misconceptions. Maybe in the worst case a good lecturer takes twice as long to get the explanation across. If need-be, the lecturer can elaborate on any piece, or draw a completely new picture as the situation demands.
By contrast, making the fancy animated version takes 20 hours, plus another several hundred hours (or perhaps 1-2 orders of magnitude more) to build the framework underneath. Even better would be to make interactive explanations, but that would take dramatically more work than even the animated version.
If someone can spare the time to do it, it obviously has tremendous value, but each animator can only explain a tiny number of things in this medium, compared to, say writing a whole book with the same amount of effort. It’s similar to the contrast between telling hundreds of stories around the campfire or writing a novel vs. animating a few minutes of a Disney film.
Ideally we’d have ten thousand skilled animator/programmer/educators working on creating such explanations, sharing tools and ideas, coordinating effort to build more complete curricula, etc., but there’s not currently anyone paying them to do it, so today there are only a handful, working as volunteer hobbyists. There’s no incentive for current educators (say, college professors or high school teachers or textbook authors) to spend their time making this kind of thing, since it’s not an established and recognized genre yet, and a vanishingly small proportion of them have the requisite skills.
- efaref 11y agoBut you only have to spend those 20 hours once.
- chrismorgan 11y agoI’m not quite a fair case as I already understood all of the stuff in this talk (or at least broadly in the case of the more advanced maths), but I’m quite confident that when I was starting delving into graphics stuff that I would have got more out of half an hour going through this presentation by myself than ten times as long with a lecturer at Uni. Even one-on-one would have taken a few times as long without such visible demonstrations as are contained so beautifully in this presentation. Uni lecturers can actually work on these sorts of things if they are so inclined; I remember one lecturer who had developed such a system, with the assistance of one of his students for part of the time as part of a research project, all as a part of his job at the Uni, not as volunteer work. You are, of course, quite correct that the actual implementation of such a thing would take a long time; I’m familiar with this as I’ve been working on a number of more advanced interactive things and visualisations as part of some Rust training materials that I’m producing (“a book” is such a sad way of expressing such a rich subject). These things definitely do take a long time, but if they’re done well, they seriously are well over an order of magnitude better than the alternatives. Most of all, I just want people to see things like that so that they realise just what is possible. Slides! Oh, such shackles we needlessly place upon ourselves. Static text! Oh, the vistas of imagination never explored, never seen, never even imagined.
- benihana 11y agoThat's really what good teaching is. It's the condensing of years work and thought into a 10 second blurb someone else can consume. I really appreciate this presentation and I can't imagine the amount of work that went into making look it effortless and seamless.
- coldtea 11y ago>The thing is, a lecturer spends 20 minutes doodling this and can explain most of the same, especially if there is some ability to directly interact with the audience and clear up misconceptions. And most of it, even in the best universities, flies right over the student's head, or they understand how to handle the abstraction and notation, but lack an intuitive model of what's going on in their head. >By contrast, making the fancy animated version takes 20 hours, plus another several hundred hours (or perhaps 1-2 orders of magnitude more) to build the framework underneath. Once it's built though, it can be delivered to billions of students. There's not even a contest between the quality of this and some lecturer's doodles -- this is an order of magnitude better. And if we want, we can always augment it with a lecturer explaining the graphics further and going into detail. >Ideally we’d have ten thousand skilled animator/programmer/educators working on creating such explanations, sharing tools and ideas, coordinating effort to build more complete curricula, etc., but there’s not currently anyone paying them to do it That's the problem -- noone paying them --, not that it's too difficult or expensive. If anything we spend several orders of magnitude more on BS such as dog toys anually that it would cost to hire those "ten thousand skilled animator/programmer/educators".
- sdenton4 11y agoAnother issue here is that, in addition to taking a bunch of time to build these presentations, there are piles of other demands on a prof's time. If they're a pure instructor, they have three or four other classes to teach, papers to grade, etc. If they're a researcher, they've got maybe another class or two and a strong obligation to produce world-class research, or else their teaching load will go up... The other issue is that presentations with shiny graphics probably aren't the best way to teach, either! I can give the best lecture or presentation in the world and still have a room full of students who couldn't reproduce even a tiny bit of it. The reason for the slow pace of lectures is to break up material into small, reproducible bits: we want students to understand the ins-and-outs of the cross-product, rather than just leave it as another wikipedia link to follow when there's time later (ie, never). That said, good course design will have some 'overarching themes' or big examples that are returned to time and time again, filling out more details as students have more depth of knowledge. This is often missing in, eg, intro calculus courses, though there are exceptions.
- greggman 11y agoHonestly this presentation didn't work for me. I was amazed at the spectacle and a few things like perfect math world vs pixels and multi-sampler helped explain a few things but over all it was all over the place and didn't seem to get to many points or insights. It seems more like someone was asked to do a presentation, didn't have a solid idea of what to talk about, and so threw together a bunch of stuff until it filed their allotted time. I'm not trying to be discouraging. A great presentation can go a long way to making things understandable. For example this video explaining jpeg worked for me https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q2aEzeMDHMA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q2aEzeMDHMA My point is only that fancy graphics and animation are not enough. The presentation actually has to get it's points across. Maybe this one worked for everyone but me but it didn't really work for me. I don't really know what to suggest to make it better. Maybe it all made more sense live with more talking. There were a few "bugs" For example slide 22, bi-linear filtering, pixels can't be 2 colors so that slide made no sense. On the positive side I would love to know what software to use to make presentations easy. Yea, I get the author made his own but in general, making animation is hard work. Worse, once I've made them, even if they didn't end up being good for explaining I put so much work into making them that I can't justify starting over for something that works better. So, anything that would make that process not be so much work would be amazingly helpful.
- jacobolus 11y agoTry the lecture: http://acko.net/tv/webglmath/ http://acko.net/tv/webglmath/
- delinka 11y agoThe beauty of the digital world is scalability. Certainly each lecturer that spends 20 minutes doodling this, all combined, is repeating more effort (and 'wasting' more time) than Steven expended making this presentation. Someone only has to do this once, in the 20+ hours it takes, and any individual student in the world can peruse it. Or any lecturer in the world can make use of it in their class.
- Apofis 11y agoCheck out an actual lecture made by the same guy: http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ It's amazing and I really wish all future science educational materials are like this. His framework MathBox is a really great step in the right direction and I hope it's picked up for some future material. Imagine learning calculus or physics from this? It would be a snap! It really solves the visualization problem in math education. Now imagine building interactivity into it---the possibilities are endless.