4 ms·
Hanging out in YVR right now - the line that normally takes 15 minutes took 95 minutes today. It is the first time I've ever been told not to arrive so early f
by ghshephard 17y ago
Hanging out in YVR right now - the line that normally takes 15 minutes took 95 minutes today. It is the first time I've ever been told not to arrive so early for a flight. Apparently people showing up 3 1/2 hours early for a flight screws it up for other people somehow. Mea Culpa.
1. Every single person had their luggage opened and sorted through, item by item.
2. Every single person was being fully patted down. Including checking the soles of your (shoeless) feet.
The pat down was remarkably thorough - the seams of my pants were checked. The waistband, shirt cuffs, pants cuffs each carefully probed, hair was cautiously checked.
I was particularly impressed with what a good mood all of the screeners and passengers were in. Nobody was grumpy, and everyone was basically taking everything in a pretty good way, despite the inordinate delays.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoOf course, it's all meaningless if you're just going to let people on your watch lists waltz on to your planes.
- jrockway 17y agoWhat value do watch lists have? If someone is a danger to society, then charge and convict them of a crime. If they are not guilty of any crime, though, it makes no sense to punish them. The 9/11 hijackers had valid passports, visas, and were not on any watchlists.
- pmorici 17y agoThere weren't "watch lists" prior to 9/11, The FBI was alerted to shady behavior by a number of them though which seems to be exactly what happened in this case. Do you similarly think sex offender lists are a joke?
- philwelch 17y agoI think a 16 year old kid caught fucking his 15 year old girlfriend, or a drunk college kid caught pissing on the sidewalk, deserves a punishment that's a little less severe than lifelong registration and shame.
- jrockway 17y agoBut it was sex. SEX!!!!
- NikkiA 17y agoThere absolutely were 'watch-lists' prior to 9/11 - in fact, I recall when I entered the US in 1995 watching as the passport control guy checked me against the watchlist - what there wasn't, was a 'no-fly list'.
- jrockway 17y agoDo you similarly think sex offender lists are a joke? Until we have murder offender lists, traffic violation list, and credit-card-bill-underpayment lists, yes. Why only shame sex offenders when we can exile everyone for one mistake? I think the next step is to require sex offenders to wear little stars on their clothing when they go outside. That way they can be recognized and treated appropriately. I hear that worked pretty well for getting rid of Germany's Undesirables.
- ahoyhere 17y agoWe know sex offender lists are a joke -- because you can get on them for pissing in public, having sex with a fellow teenager, developing photos of you/your wife breastfeeding your baby, and, most ridiculously, for distributing naked pictures of your underaged self. And, we know the no-fly lists are also a joke. Unless the Penis Bomber also burned off all the memories of the "2-year-old Toddler Not Allowed To Fly" and "Senator Not Allowed To Fly" etc new stories from the past 6-7 years. It's sheer populism, pandering to the worst impulses of everyone. Bad bad bad -- not to mention ineffective.
- coffeemug 17y agoIt's not binary. You may have enough evidence to suspect someone may be planning a crime, but not enough to go to court, or enough to go to court but not enough to get a conviction with any degree of certainty. In this case it might make sense to perform a more detailed security check. It makes sense for a minor inconvenience at the airport to require a different standard of proof from sending the person to prison. Of course with TSA watch lists "your name sounds fishy" appears to be a sufficient standard of proof, but that's a problem with the implementation, not with the concept itself.
- jrockway 17y agoYou may have enough evidence to suspect someone may be planning a crime, but not enough to go to court, or enough to go to court but not enough to get a conviction with any degree of certainty. So the solution is to create a secondary judicial system with no oversight so that anyone the government doesn't like can be punished for something they haven't actually done? Sign me up! It makes sense for a minor inconvenience at the airport to require a different standard of proof from sending the person to prison. Why wouldn't someone on the watchlist not just pay someone not on the watchlist to carry the bomb through security then? For enough money, this would be very easy to do. (It's easier if you ask, "can you smuggle these drugs in for me", though, instead of "can you help me murder 300 people".) Everyone criminal commits their first crime. For someone, that's going to be blowing up a plane. A watchlist does not handle this case.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoThe simple, clear, undeniable fact (not theory of what could happen, but fact) is that in this case, placing extra attention on this person who was on the watch list would have kept him and his bomb off an airplane full of people.
- jrockway 17y agoHis leader would have gotten someone else. This guy on Flight 253 was not the planner of the attack, he was just one of many people that wanted his 69 virgins or whatever.
- ghshephard 17y agoJust landed in SFO. Some observations: o United has (for now) discontinued Channel 9 (the pilot/ATC channel) o The Pilot said the following "The TSA has requested I notify you of the following - You will not be allowed to move around the cabin for the last hour of the flight, you will not be allowed to have anything in your lap in the last hour of the flight, no blankets, jackets, nothing. We will make an announcement 15 minutes prior to the last hour of the flight so you can use the washroom." So, when the announcement came that there was 15 minutes until lockdown in our seats - there was an immediate rush to line up for the washrooms, that spanned most of the cabin. Interestingly enough, absolutely nobody paid attention to the 'Nothing in your lap' rule, and nobody policed it. People kept working on their laptops, tray tables were down, and nobody said anything. People kept wandering to the washroom. One of the more ironic elements of the trip was as follows, the pilot announced "I will not be allowed to point out landmarks as we are flying" - and then 30 minutes prior to landing he noted "As you can all see on your left side, we are flying over the Golden Gate Bridge" Definitely a bizarre experience.
- nostrademons 17y agoI got in from Boston -> SFO about an hour ago. The only major difference I noticed was the lack of channel 9. The pat-down did seem a bit more thorough than usual, perhaps. I had no problem with electronic gadgets in my carry-on, passed through Boston security with no problems, there was no lockdown for the last hour, and I had my jacket on my lap for half the flight. YMMV. I suspect things are pretty inconsistent between flights at this point.
- marvin 17y agoThe pilot obviously thinks the new security measures are stupid.