5 ms·
What F. Scott Fitzgerald’s tax returns reveal about his life and times (2009)
- gwern 11y agoRemarkable to think that in those days one could become so wealthy off short stories, of all things. Business models keep changing, in literature as elsewhere.
- danko 11y agoIt's interesting how this article conflicts the narrative (and indeed, Fitzgerald's own narrative) about his life. The narrative was that they lived fabulously until the simultaneous stresses of the the stock market crash and Zelda's mental breakdown in 1929. Turns out that at least from an income perspective, he was doing quite well up until the moment he died. But Zelda's healthcare costs ruined him anyway, and he cognitively backed himself in a corner in terms of making adjustments. It reminds me of a quote from another famous author, one Charles Dickens: "Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen [pounds] nineteen [shillings] and six [pence], result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery."
- dang 11y agoHe gave that line to Mr. Micawber and of course was intimately acquainted with poverty, but by the time Dickens wrote that he was as rich as a 19th century rock star. Indeed he made piles of money by touring—writers used to moonlight as performing artists. Once movies came out, that dried up, so they wrote screenplays instead, like Fitzgerald.
- njharman 11y agoEnding with (non-adjusted)$35,000 in the bank is hardly "ruined".
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoTo me, the most fascinating thing about this story is the starkly different picture it paints of wealth in America. We're currently debating how much of a middle class there even IS anymore, and they're talking about how upper-middle class families had servants. There's a lot going into the difference, for sure, but its quite a different world.
- rayiner 11y agoThat's the wrong takeaway from that point. It's a good thing that upper middle class people today can't afford to have lower class people do domestic services for them. It's an indication that lower class people can make a lot more money doing non-domestic work. Although the task rabbit economy is pushing us back in that (wrong) direction.
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoYou'll notice I wasn't passing judgement, merely noting the WOW factor. As I said, there's a lot going into that difference but it is quite stark nonetheless.
- eru 11y agoThe same developments are happening as we speak in places like South America. The Economist runs enlightening articles about this. (A collection available via https://www.google.com.au/search?q=economist+domestic+servant https://www.google.com.au/search?q=economist+domestic+servan...)
- hugh4 11y ago> It's a good thing that upper middle class people today can't afford to have lower class people do domestic services for them. It's an indication that lower class people can make a lot more money doing non-domestic work. Not necessarily. Many lower-class people are unemployed. It may also be an indication that lower-class people are getting lower in, well, class. Many, many rich people would be happy to employ in-home servants for some reasonable wage (say, more than minimum) but the days when you could get servants who knew how to dress, speak, et cetera properly around upper-class people are long gone. Culture has bifurcated, the lower class have no idea how to behave around polite society, and more problematically don't think it's worth trying. It's much better to be a butler (or even a footman) than a janitor at McDonald's, but the average McDonald's janitor isn't someone you'd want inside your house.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIt's actually an indication that lower class people can consume quite a bit regardless of whether they work. It's hardly clear that this is a good thing. http://www.bls.gov/cex/2011/Standard/income.pdf http://www.bls.gov/cex/2011/Standard/income.pdf It's hardly clear how task rabbit is pushing is in that "wrong" direction - it's not as if task rabbit has somehow eliminated other good options (such as not working and receiving wealth transfers, or perhaps those unsustainably overpaid factory jobs politicians like to talk about).
- roymurdock 11y agoBefore World War II, the government did not know what anyone made. Only the wealthy and upper-middle class filed returns—less than 10 percent of the population. The system was based on what the irs called “self-assessment,” which meant that the taxpayer told the government what he or she earned the prior year and then sent a check on March 15. Some information returns were sent to the government, but the government had no capacity to match the return to the taxpayer and the returns piled up in warehouses. Not until 1962 did the government’s computer system begin to efficiently match the information returns to the taxpayer. During the 1920s and 1930s, the tax system relied almost entirely on the honesty of taxpayers. It's amazing to think that there was once a time in US history when the government could sustain itself through the honesty and goodwill of the richest 10% of its citizens. I wonder what would happen if we returned to the goodwill tax model. If we had a simple tax code with self-reported earnings where we spent far less on hunting down and punishing cheaters and freeloaders, and instead left it as a matter of conscience for those who had amassed their wealth and raised their families through the good grace and fortune of living in the US. Do you think our collective social fabric would be strong enough to fund an effective government? Or are we too far down the path of the self-centered, get mine at all costs, cheat the system if possible mindset?
- waterlesscloud 11y agoOr is government too far down the path of ineffective sidetracks? There's two sides to the equation. Both have probably gone too far.
- refurb 11y agoIt's amazing to think that there was once a time in US history when the government could sustain itself through the honesty and goodwill of the richest 10% of its citizens Honesty and goodwill? I'm guessing there was rampant under reporting of income back then.
- hugh4 11y agoAnd yet the US government still managed to get by, and the US grew rapidly to become the richest and most powerful country on the planet.
- rsp1984 11y agoWhat I don't understand is how in the US in the 1920s the tax rate was in the single digits while deficit was negative (!) and debt was low [1], while today tax rates are at 40%, deficit is about 17% (!) of budget and debt is over 100% GDP. What on earth went wrong? [1] http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/debt_deficit_brief.php http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/debt_deficit_brief.php
- dllthomas 11y ago"What on earth went wrong?" Immediately thereafter? The Great Depression.
- rsp1984 11y agoWell that one wouldn't have lasted until today, would it?
- mhuffman 11y agoThe govt. began to care for people that had previously been cared for by family members or religious groups. This includes the very poor, the elderly, the disabled, etc. That makes the bulk of it.
- jhayward 11y agoEnormous military spending makes up the bulk that is not (at least theoretically) paid for by the SS trust fund.
- rayiner 11y agoMilitary spending is only 3-5% of GDP while total government spending has gone up from 10% of GDP to over 35%. The vast majority of the increase is not military spending.
- cft 11y agoIn exchange for votes from such people. Before, many of those people were disenfranchised.