4 ms·
Be interesting to see how this plays out with the "Anti-GM is irrational anti-science woo" brigade. Yes - genetic modification is not doing anything that could
by andybak 11y ago
Be interesting to see how this plays out with the "Anti-GM is irrational anti-science woo" brigade.
Yes - genetic modification is not doing anything that couldn't happen by normal mutation/selection - but it accelerates the process by multiple orders of magnitude (that's the whole point).
Making the debate one of 'show us evidence of harm or shut up' always felt fairly short-sighted.
I always felt that there is a huge 'unintended consequences' factor lurking somewhere. The need for a deep sense of caution when working on a new frontier struck me as more rational than a stance that basically boiled down to "let's assume we haven't overlooked any potential risks".
- hurin 11y ago> The need for a deep sense of caution when working on a new frontier struck me as more rational than a stance that basically boiled down to "let's assume we haven't overlooked any potential risks". It's an economically profitable assumption for the particular businesses which happen to operate with it. Especially when they are able to lobby congress to encourage this point of view.
- powertower 11y ago> Yes - genetic modification is not doing anything that couldn't happen by normal mutation/selection Transgenic GM crops have genes inserted into them from viruses and bacteria.
- xkcd-sucks 11y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer