6 ms·
He might have changed the way a few scientists and a few more philosophers think about science but most people including most practising scientists don't think
by kwhitefoot 11y ago
He might have changed the way a few scientists and a few more philosophers think about science but most people including most practising scientists don't think about such things at all. The general public, I suspect, isn't even aware that there is a 'way the world looked at science' much less that there is a different way of looking at it.
I wouldn't have bothered writing this rant except that the sloppy use of words like 'world' when all that can really be meant is something like 'the world of science' or possibly 'the views of some academic observers of science' is one of the defining characteristics of journalism (both high brow and mass market). When one claims far more than is plausible one does a disservice to the truth and misleads the interested lay person and when that person discovers that the claim is untrue the reputations not only of the journalist but also of the original work suffer.
- jmcmichael 11y ago> He might have changed the way a few scientists and a few more philosophers think about science but most people including most practising scientists don't think about such things at all. The general public, I suspect, isn't even aware that there is a 'way the world looked at science' much less that there is a different way of looking at it. There's a word for the state of these scientists and laypeople: ignorance. Edit to add some substance to the name-calling: There's a certain perspective held by many scientists that the scientific method can and will describe the purposes and meaning behind every phenomena both natural and man-made that have any relevance or importance to our lives as humans. If those holding this perspective grant that valuable knowledge lies outside the ability of science to observe and explain, they tend to view it as irrelevant and frivolous. Those who hold this perspective tend to view philosophy as mere wordplay, and the idea of studying science from the perspective of philosophy (as Kuhn did) as pointless or an usurpation of their position at the top of the intellectual ladder. Feynman embodied this attitude when he said, "Philosophy of science is about as useful to scientists as ornithology is to birds." It's a belligerent and proud ignorance that puts a black stain on the practice of science today, and an attitude that threatens some of the most valuable academic disciplines in the humanities, to the detriment of our culture. My brief statement above was meant to call attention to this belligerent ignorance and poke fun at it a little bit.
- vixen99 11y agoCan you offer a bit more than name calling. That's what you get mostly in the Guardian comment section and it's pretty depressing.
- jmcmichael 11y agoYes, updated. Sorry to have (hopefully temporarily) made this thread look like a Guardian comment section...
- conistonwater 11y ago> Feynman embodied this attitude when he said, "Philosophy of science is about as useful to scientists as ornithology is to birds." Your comment still does not explain how philosophy of science should be useful to scientists. It would be much more convincing if it did.
- theoh 11y agoSee also Barnett Newman's use of the same metaphor in reference to aesthetics.
- mirimir 11y agoSelf-awareness is always a good thing, no? Kuhn's key point is that scientists (like many humans) tend to be herd animals. When you get results that are inconsistent with the public record, not to mention current dogma, there's a tendency to dig seriously for systematic errors. And when you start getting results that are consistent with the public record, you tend to get on with the writeup. Being aware of that stereotypic behavior is the first step in being free of it. No?
- jules 11y agoI agree, but doesn't this mean that scientists should read about the history of science, or sociology of science, not philosophy of science?
- paulojreis 11y agoTo be honest, Kuhn's work had its influence on my academic (and not so academic) writing: no more invoking the word "paradigm" in vain. :)
- zevets 11y agoI read Kuhn in my second year of grad school and his bit on the structure of a scientific paper I found very helpful. His section on what goes in an introduction to was supremely helpful in demonstrating how to frame your work so that it finds acceptance. After reading that portion, I observed that I was getting much nicer peer reviews, and I've since recommended it to several people.