4 ms·
Infinity can be difficult to grasp. Fortunately, there is a huge difference between "infinite" and "really large," which is often key. So applying these result
by mikeash 11y ago
Infinity can be difficult to grasp.
Fortunately, there is a huge difference between "infinite" and "really large," which is often key. So applying these results to the real world often doesn't work out.
As the Wikipedia article points out, although the expected value of the game is infinite if the casino has infinite money, it's not only finite but quite small if the casino has finite money. Even if the casino were backed by the entire world GDP, the expected value of the game is only around $50.
This to me is a satisfying resolution to the problem presented.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 11y agoNot only that, but the most common outcome is $2. The median is $3. The chance of winning $1024 is less than 1/10th of a percent. Even if the house had unlimited resources, it'd be hard to convince me to pay a large amount of money to play -- assuming I could only pay once.
- agsamek 11y agoI fully agree with this simple observation. If you have below $1M in your pocket, then there is no point to pay more than $1K for the game unless you are a gambler because probability of win is low (not expected value but probability) even with multiple runs. On the other hand if I had $2M spare money, then I would happily invest $1K in each of 1000 runs even if casino only had $10M in the bank. I would not spend $1M for a single run.
- femto113 11y agoThese analyses mostly ignore the obvious fact that the value of infinite money isn't, in fact, infinite, because eventually you'd run out of things to buy. Using the aggregate wealth of the entire world (which is probably in the neighborhood of $250 trillion[1]) as a bankroll yields a expected value of about $50. [1] http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/04/stop-adding-up-the-wealth-of-the-poor/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/04/stop-adding...
- mikeash 11y agoThat's somewhat covered in the "Expected utility theory" section of the Wikipedia article. In short, if you double your money it doesn't double the usefulness you get out of it, so you have to take that into account. However, that analysis assumes that additional money always adds some additional usefulness, and then you can make the problem reappear. To get rid of it entirely you have to declare that there is some point beyond which provides zero additional value no matter how much more money you add. And as you say, such a point surely exists.
- cperciva 11y agoTo get rid of it entirely you have to declare that there is some point beyond which provides zero additional value no matter how much more money you add. No, you merely have to declare that there is some amount of utility which can never be obtained no matter how much money you have. (Or as the Simpsons put it: There's one thing you can't buy: A dinosaur.) In mathematical terms, if your utility function is f(x) = 1 - 1/x, every marginal dollar adds utility; but the added utility is never enough to make the gamble profitable.
- AstralStorm 11y agoOh but you can but a dinosaur - a dead one. Given enough money you could potentially clone one too. Utility function analysis is arbitrary just as the article says. Compare this to ergodic theory (used for proper dynamic system analysis), where you can clearly derive the value function over number of plays, including infinite number. What an ergodic process is you can see here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodic_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodic_process By computing the limit of the ensemble average you will derive the logarithmic utility function. This works for finite resources as well, but then you can also derive the time it takes to bankrupt the bank, as well as probability of that ever happening.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thetruthseeker1 11y agoIf you were paying 50$ to play this game, you would have to play around 2^50 (each time paying 50$) times to even break even! I think the article is a good illustration of how expected value can't be really used as the only parameter.
- AstralStorm 11y agoExpected value is limit at infinity. Instead, you should use ergodic theory expected value, which takes number of plays into account. Then the result is a simple log function.
- caf 11y agoIt is debatable which is the more unlikely out of the two premises "The entire world puts up their GDP for a year to back the game against a player paying $50" and "The game is played around 2^50 times".
- bradleyjg 11y agoI thought it was even more satisfying that the number given by Ian Hacking (few of us would pay even $25 to enter such a game) turned out to be near what the equation would give you for a realistic casino bankroll ($16M < W < 34M).
- SixSigma 11y agoInfinite return would also take infinite time to toss the coins.
- JesperRavn 11y agoIndeed, and modern economics as a discipline goes out of its way to keep everything finite. I was going to post the same thing: that the finite version solves this problem completely. The only case where economics cannot avoid dealing with infinite quantities, is with dynamic issues, since most models assume that various quantities though finite at a given point, could grow without bound (e.g. GDP). One case this comes up is in debt, especially national debt. Most models posit a transversality/"no ponzi" condition, that states that the present value of debt at time t will converge to zero as t goes to infinity. On the other hand, if national debt was a constant proportion of GDP (which in the long run should grow at the same rate as the risk free interest rate) then this would in fact be false, and national debt is a kind of free money that comes out of nowhere, i.e. a real ponzi scheme. Imposing a finiteness condition (e.g. and end to the universe) would imply that in the far future, some generation will pay for current consumption that is based on either national debt, or the corresponding internal borrowing from future generations (e.g. social security as understood in the overlapping generations model). That is why, in my opinion, it is completely wrong to say that household finances don't apply to government. The only difference is the kind of consumption and investment being done, but the financial constraints are identical.