3 ms·
The generational shift isn't between people, but between decades. Many of the "leave no trace" hikers today were very different in their youth. Look through t
by sandworm101 11y ago
The generational shift isn't between people, but between decades. Many of the "leave no trace" hikers today were very different in their youth. Look through the history and you will find people in the 60s regularly doing things that today are simply not allowed (fires, cutting down small trees etc). So it isn't that people are different today. There are just more of them on trails.
Some would say the answer is to provide more services such as better camping accommodations and harder trail surfaces to handle the extra people. I do not support this. I suggest that making trails easier attracts more people, only exacerbating the problem. It's a game that cannot be won.
So rather than try to accommodate all these people, perhaps parts of the trail should be made less accommodating. Rock climbers do this all the time. See debates over sport (heavily bolted) v. traditional climbing methods. Adding safety features to a route attracts more traffic. Making/keeping a route difficult or even dangerous keeps beginners away, which reduces traffic. If we assume that there will always be more people in the future than there are now, that if nothing changes population pressure will always increase, then actively trying to keep people away may be the only sustainable plan.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> So rather than try to accommodate all these people, perhaps parts of the trail should be made less accommodating. Rock climbers do this all the time. This makes perfect sense if the goal of being a hiker is to show that you're more macho, or otherwise more morally worthy, than non-hikers. It makes no sense at all if your viewpoint is that nature is beautiful and people should be encouraged to experience that.
- ctdonath 11y agoSometimes demand exceeds supply's ability to cope therewith, and some form of "friction" need be applied to reduce that demand lest the supply be destroyed. It's not about being macho etc, it's about "experiencing nature" unavoidably leaving a trace which, in great enough volume, destroys the beauty of that nature - and preserving that fragile beauty requires SOME barrier to persuade some it's not worth pursuing.
- sandworm101 11y agoBut allowing so many people to enjoy that beauty simultaneously works to destroy that beauty. So to protect you must either you take steps to dissuade people, or resort to some form of enforced quota system. When it comes to public resources I'd rather see dissuasion than quotas. If machismo works to reduce the footfall on a trail, so be it. That's much better than a gated trailhead manned by a guard taking tickets. And its far better than paved sidewalks and concrete staircases replacing trails.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> to protect you must either you take steps to dissuade people, or resort to some form of enforced quota system This isn't true. You can channel people into the behaviors you want by making them easier; it's not an all-or-nothing "no matter what our environment is like, 3% of visitors will leave litter" situation. There are many things you could do to reduce environmental damage while accommodating more visitors: - You could put handrails around the trails. People aren't supposed to leave them anyway. - You could station trash cans along the trails. This makes it much easier to throw your trash in an appropriate place. - You could establish fire pits in which it was officially OK to have fires. - You could patrol the trails. This doesn't work well when hikers are rare, but it scales beautifully as they get more common. Or, you could have a stationary security presence in problem areas. - You could blaze new trails. Everything I've listed except trail patrols is something I've personally seen in some areas. (Full disclosure, I'm actually just assuming that new trails get blazed from time to time. I have, however, personally experienced trails being radically reworked between visits.) > [machismo is] far better than paved sidewalks and concrete staircases replacing trails Why?
- jack-r-abbit 11y agoHandrails don't keep off-trail hikers from hiking off trail. Trail etiquette keeps people on trail. Respect to nature keeps people on trail. Garbage cans in the middle of nowhere still need to be emptied or else they become full and no longer serve the need. A lot of these places are remote. It might take several hours to empty one trash can. Our parks barely have enough resources to maintain as they are. We shouldn't need to pay someone to hike in and remove your trash. I don't think it is too much to ask that if you hiked in with 5 full snickers bars that you hike out with their wrappers. Your pack always gets lighter as you go so there really is no excuse for not coming out with all your trash.
- hueyp 11y agoKatahdin -- the northern terminus -- is the hardest climb of the trail and is the biggest focal point regarding the discussion of overcrowding.