3 ms·
Pets and rogue camping do cause damage. If more usage is what's important, why not just pave the whole AT? Because we already have plenty of those kinds of plac
by mindslight 11y ago
Pets and rogue camping do cause damage. If more usage is what's important, why not just pave the whole AT? Because we already have plenty of those kinds of places!
I pondered this for a while the first time I saw a "stay on the trails" sign at a national park. The immediate reaction is to think that we're just animals like any other, so wherever we want to walk is "natural" and should be perfectly fine.
But then I realized the differentiating factor is that the only reason I was at this specific place is because somebody put a dot on the map and built a road most of the way there. So even when we leave behind most of the artifacts, we're still part of a populous advanced civilization that can easily destroy these places. No matter how alone you seem, the trail is more like walking through a "nature museum" than actually being part of nature.
Irresponsible drug use could cause an increased load on emergency rescues, but it's probably just a red herring focused on by overproscriptive government agencies. Most park rangers are awesome people, but they've still drank that LEO kool aid.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> No matter how alone you seem, the trail is more like walking through a "nature museum" than actually being part of nature. That's true, but it's largely to help people avoid getting lost and dying in authentic nature. Backpacking trails are much further toward the "what trail?" end of the spectrum, but they're still marked trails. Going off the trail is dangerous. (That said, another purpose of "stay on the trails" signs is to help prevent shortcut-based erosion, an entirely different goal coming from an entirely different motivation for leaving the trail.)
- mindslight 11y agoI didn't really think of the getting lost aspect. I was in the Badlands when I started thinking about this, where IIRC getting lost didn't seem like a major concern. But yes, not being able to easily find civilization is one of those changed assumptions people need to be constantly reminded of. Erosion and other destruction is what I was focusing on, either concentrated because of a "shortcut" or not. We're not worried about the erosion/destruction caused by animals running all over, so what makes human animals different? That's what I was trying to tease out.