4 ms·
Logic Lunch Counter
- tome 17y agoI really like this article Daniel. It's a very interesting talking point regarding the kinds of discussion that happen on the internet. Here is a related article about the "Ad Hominem Fallacy Fallacy" http://plover.net/~bonds/adhominem.html http://plover.net/~bonds/adhominem.html
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThanks. That's a good link too. I found myself drifting towards attacking the Ad Hominem, probably because it's done wrong so much. But the general point is that all logic critiques are in themselves flawed in some way. For instance, how else would two people discuss something rationally without one person saying something like "If I understand you correctly, you're saying X. But X doesn't make any sense at all to me" To which the other person can yell "Straw Man! Straw Man argument!" like a little schoolkid or they can try to move on towards some kind of reasonable discussion. Intent and nuance count a lot, I think. And these are the very things that are toughest to do well on the 'net. (sigh)
- mquander 17y agoIt's not tough to do well if your aim is really to "discuss something rationally." Most of the time, people are not trying to discuss anything in particular, or understand anything better; they're just trying to socialize, and whatever they're arguing about is just a medium in which to play games of flag-waving and oneupmanship. (I know that sounds dismissive, but I'm not trying to crap on it; I do it too. It's just the way it is.) It's silly to look at the result and say, well, you would communicate better if you did X, because that's not the goal.
- sketerpot 17y agoAll I'm taking from this is that people often misapply shallow knowledge of logical fallacies. Look, not all reasoning is equally good, and the fact that no essay is a mathematical proof doesn't mean that we shouldn't point out problems in reasoning. If someone sees mysterious lights in the sky and thinks that it was aliens, that's not entirely invalid -- but because of a false dichotomy and confirmation bias, the assumed probability of the lights being aliens got exaggerated. tl;dr version: fallacious reasoning should be guarded against not because it automatically destroys any argument containing it, but because it skews our estimates of probability.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agobecause it skews our estimates of probability is based on a group understanding of the situation applied through many filters and not by some appeal to universal tenets of logic. Each of these fallacies carry subjective and conditional baggage not understood by many commenters. If you got that, then you don't need the article. I'm just not sure from your reply if you got it.