5 ms·
What bugs me about this is when I asked them about the change on Twitter and they kept trying to blow smoke up my butt about how it's better for everyone. Thei
by mikeash 11y ago
What bugs me about this is when I asked them about the change on Twitter and they kept trying to blow smoke up my butt about how it's better for everyone.
Their first response was that it's cheaper than before. Except it's not. Did they think I wouldn't actually go look at the prices?
Then they said it's better because you can jump in and out at will. Only need Product X for a month? Only pay for a month. Which is fine, except I've never heard of a developer who would do that.
This move wouldn't bug me so much if they were just honest about it. If you're doing it because you need the money or it makes your life easier or whatever, then fine. I don't like it even so, but I could deal with it. But when you try to convince me it's better for me, while treating me like a fool, I start to have a major problem with the whole thing.
- stoshe 11y agoA typical move to subscription based pricing LOWERS costs to the consumer, but the company gets the benefit of more predictable recurring revenues. That makes the pricing JetBrains puts out a little bit of a head-scratcher.
- acveilleux 11y agoStarting from zero, their pricing is lower over a set number of year. They got rid of the initial "hump" and in turn made the annual amount higher. I didn't look too closely but I guess the cost evens out over a 3-4 year subscription span. For a business this is actually going to simplify accounting I would think. It's no longer a cap-ex with a maintenance fee, it's just rental so all pre-tax. My guess is that overall their spreadsheeting makes this even out based on how customers have been paying. The fringe bits (loss of permanence, ability to install a home copy) will disproportionately hurt solo/small business folks and hobbyists. The very people that have been their champion getting their software into enterprise dev teams. I don't understand why they don't go to the rental model with optional one-time permanent license add-on. So like hypothetically 100$/year rental and a 100$ supplement for permanent license. Basically option into the current deal. They can even make the sum total greater then it used to be. Like 120$/year rental + 100$ permanent license supplement.
- Oletros 11y ago> Starting from zero, their pricing is lower over a set number of year. Starting from zero the prices are the same or higher. The worst offender, Webstorm, from 49€ first year and 29€ next years to 99€/year from the start PyCharm is 40€/year more expensive from the second year
- hinkley 11y agoWhat typical ones are you thinking about? And are you American? Americans are bad at math. Companies selling to us know this and it's common for them to offer a monthly contract for a device with an expected life of three years as price/24 if they're feeling generous, and price/18 if they aren't. I think the worst one I ever saw was price/14, and people still bought it. TiVo has prices closer to the worse end of that spectrum, drove me nuts.
- nitrogen 11y agoI suspect your comment would get fewer downvotes and still be useful if you dropped the jab at the parent commenter's math abilities.
- hinkley 11y agoIt wasn't meant as jab at his math skills, but our math skills. Companies offer predatory monthly rates and we gobble it up, much to my dismay. Edit: my ISP, for instance, will happily charge me $7 a month for an $80 router that I won't upgrade for 3-5 years. Who does that?
- balabaster 11y ago> Who does that? A company that knows that people will blindly say "Hey, if I only have to fork over $7 a month instead of finding $80 plus tax, plus gas, plus the inconvenience of going and finding a router myself, and configuring it so that my network works, seems like a good deal" and they purchase the rental - even though $420 for an $80 (plus tax and inconvenience) router is a terrible deal. Then you get the types that have a box full of routers at home or know that if they purchase for $80, then in a year, it's paid for itself and everything else is gravy.
- fastball 11y agoContractors that work with different clients using different languages? You've never heard of someone that works with different languages at different times? Huh.
- estefan 11y agoWhy not just use IDEA ultimate and install different plugins per language?
- toyg 11y agoI tried, it's not the same. The dedicated tools are better.
- estefan 11y ago@toyg (not sure why I can't reply to you so I'll reply to me instead) - really? I've never tried them. I thought Intellij was the same with the appropriate language plugin. Maybe I'll give some of them a go...
- fenomas 11y ago(aside: HN blocks replying to your replyer for a short while to discourage heated exchanges. If you wait a bit the reply button will show up.)
- hinkley 11y agoI dunno what it's like now, but there was a time when, among other things, IntelliJ could not open a project created in rubymine. They were providing ruby support as a plugin and it was considerably broken, for about six months.
- jasonlotito 11y ago> Their first response was that it's cheaper than before. It is cheaper if you are using a number of their products. It's the same price for the individual products I'm currently using. Net for me is that it's cheaper. > Which is fine, except I've never heard of a developer who would do that. I don't code in Python or Ruby every day, but when I do, it's usually for a specific project, and having PyCharm or RubyMine at a low price point and in an environment that I'm familiar with is nice to have. I wouldn't want to buy the IDE outright, but the lower price point is more attractive.
- nadams 11y ago> Their first response was that it's cheaper than before. Except it's not. Did they think I wouldn't actually go look at the prices? Uh - their "everything" price is $20/month = $240/year (or $200 for the annual plan) (All renewal at current license price) PHPStorm - $129 PyCharm - $99 ReSharper Ultimate - $600 (no renewal price) If I were to purchase that with their old license it would cost me $828, with the new plan I only pay $240. And those are just the tools I have an immediate need for (I do Python, PHP, and C# on an almost daily basis). $20/month for their full suite of tools? Count me in. When I first found their tools - I was like "ehhh I don't know - I'll stick with Eclipse/Netbeans etc". Eventually I tried IntelliJ, PHPStorm and PyCharm and they have been the best IDEs I've ever used. Trust me I'll advocate open source when I can - but after all the issues I've had with Eclipse and Netbeans I almost just totally switched to vi.
- mikeash 11y agoI'm glad it's better for you (really!). But they shouldn't present it as better for everyone when it's clearly not.
- enraged_camel 11y agoHe is specifically refuting your argument that the new model isn't cheaper than the old model.
- mikeash 11y agoAnd I'm accepting that but pointing out that it still applies to many.
- rangitatanz 11y agoYes you are but you are providing no concrete examples of that. I'm interested to hear your examples?
- nadams 11y ago
- mattkevan 11y agoThe problem with SAAS pricing for previously bought software is that the conversation changes from 'Pay us for this great bit of software, then pay us again when we make it even better', to 'Pay up or all your years of work goes away'. It's a fundamentally different relationship.
- codersteve 11y agoAgreed. The incentive to make it better becomes less because users are on the auto-pay plan. Whereas they have to prove themselves worthy of the upgrade otherwise.
- specialist 11y agoEveryone's just trying to get their nut. I imagine they're stumbling thru this viable business model notion, just like everyone else. Cut them some slack. I frankly don't care about the price. Developers need to get paid. I hope they figure out something fair (reasonable) with modest profitability, so they can enjoy vacations and have hope of someday retiring. If I ever stop renewing (or subscribing), I can just use the community version.