5 ms·
Uber is the archetypical example of a Silicon Valley company projecting it's narrow US-centric-view onto the rest of the world. From what I gather, taxi busine
by flohofwoe 11y ago
Uber is the archetypical example of a Silicon Valley company projecting it's narrow US-centric-view onto the rest of the world.
From what I gather, taxi businesses in the US seem to be in the hand of Mafia-like criminal organizations. That's not the case in most Western-European cities with good and cheap public transport and well-regulated taxi systems.
If I can get from anywhere to anywhere at any time for little money already for the last 30 years, what's the point of a service like Uber, especially Uber with their shady business practices and aggressive stance towards established labour laws.
- xenolies 11y agoI'm pretty sure that creating a fleet of self driving cars operating on dynamic dispatch would have worldwide ramifications. But I see your point re public transport.
- eterm 11y agoExcept then dynamic dispatch won't be fast enough, so they or a competitor will have a fleet of self driving cars driving around 24/7 most of the time empty so that there is always a nearby car ready. The kind of market "efficiency" seen in the housing market where huge amount of property is left empty.
- flohofwoe 11y agoThat must be a different company. The Uber I know is that evil company lead by incredibly arrogant *ssholes trying to aggressively price-dump taxi drivers (that don't make a lot of money to begin with) out of their jobs by employing-but-not-really-employing a cheap workforce without paying their part on the drivers insurances. Basically an illegal taxi business ;)
- icebraining 11y agoYes, that's the story that people like Evgeny Freidman paint, when they started seeing their rent-seeking investment - buying medallions and charging drivers hundreds of dollars to rent them so that they could work - begin to drop. This story shows the situation for taxi drivers, way before Uber: http://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/nyregion/driving-a-taxi-difficult-in-best-of-times-gets-tougher.html http://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/nyregion/driving-a-taxi-di... Some quotes: The average rate a cabbie paid to take a taxi out for a 12-hour shift climbed 11 percent, to about $85, between 1990 and 1993 (...) In 1993, 32 to 45 percent of the income of a fleet or lease manager was profit, or $16,000 to $21,300 per car, up from $5,500 to $9,800 in 1986, according to the taxi commission. Lease drivers rent the medallions, and usually the taxis, for a day or a week from their owners or a middleman. Depending on the owner and the night of the week, a lease driver pays $72 to $100 to take a car out for a 12-hour shift, or about $450 to $650 for a weekly lease. The driver must also pay for gas, at $15 to $20 a night. Drivers keep whatever fares and tips they collect, but they often start a day's work $100 or more behind.
- jsjohnst 11y agoPlease don't take this as me defending Uber, I agree with your general sentiment, but your salient argument against them is a bit misleading. Almost all taxi companies in major cities in the U.S. use a similar "employment" model for the drivers. Honestly, the only major differences between Uber and the old school firms is technology, customer support, and ubiquity. Uber is no more abussive really to drivers and is also just as corrupt (maybe in slightly different ways, but still the same level).
- icebraining 11y agoI live in Western Europe, and I welcome Uber after years of waiting 20-30m in the cold or torrid sun for a car that should have gotten there in 10m, getting berated for taking short trips, having friends and tourists scammed by drivers taking much longer routes than necessary, etc. Their latest move - after getting a court order to ban Uber, which they fortunately were too incompetent to get right - was trying to leech tourists by asking for a flat fee for any trip starting at the airport that would be enough to cross the whole city. Regulations protecting the safety of citizens (both inside and outside the taxi) might be necessary, and Uber should be punished if they violate them. But competition shouldn't be regulated away, and Uber for all its flaws has given a well overdue kick in the pants of complacent companies.
- crdb 11y agoSingapore has a great, well regulated, honest taxi industry with ample taxis just about everywhere and a plethora of ways to order them from apps to call centres and taxi queues. Yet I find myself using UberX practically all the time except if there is literally a free taxi flashing green right in front of me (and even then I'll hesitate). Uber offers me these small things that stack up: - automatic transaction - google maps destination (one less thing to explain to the driver) - happy drivers, always - slightly higher air conditioning temperature by default (taxis like to blast you with cold air and you have to ask them to put it up) - lesser chance of a bumpy driver - a chance to meet and chat with a new person, who isn't necessarily a professional taxi driver, and from that a fun life story or two And that's enough to make me switch and even evangelise the service. Then I go abroad and I get google maps "taxis" with no need to take out foreign cash, and it's warming somehow.
- rawTruthHurts 11y agoHmmm... good and cheap... well, that definitely leaves London out of the equation.
- Tycho 11y agoI don't know about the rest of Europe but in Scotland the taxis are definitely in the hands of gangsters. The drivers will tell you as much. I'm not sure what the reason is but I'm guessing it's because it's a cash-in-hand business that would be easy to use for money laundering. Here's some real problems which Uber addresses: - taxi services being run by organised crime - taxis wasting fuel driving about looking for fares - massive shortage of taxis on a Saturday night in the city centre - having to wait on the street in a queue for a taxi rank, probably in the rain, in a crowd of drunk people - people getting mugged/assaulted because they had to walk home because they couldn't get a taxi - being totally surrounded by cars but unable still being unable to get from Point A to Point B - owning a car and a drivers licence, being unemployed, and not being able to put your skills and capital goods to use - taxi drivers not knowing how to get to your destination - not being able to get a taxi because you don't have cash - not knowing when your taxi is going to arrive - not having any log of the fact you ordered and got into a taxi, in case no one ever hears from you again Ironically in ex-communist Russia, they don't really have these problems because people apparently just flag down any car on the road and hitch a ride, probably for a little cash.