4 ms·
Good lord, who taught these guys to draw schematics?
by CamperBob2 11y ago
Good lord, who taught these guys to draw schematics?
- unwind 11y agoThat guy, Charles Platt (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Platt_%28author%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Platt_%28author%29) probably taught more people about electronics than most. I believe the schematic is in his breadboard-friendly style, which takes a bit getting used to but is optimized for easy implementation on a breadboard. So, I guess CamperBob2 is right that it's optimized for building rahter than theoretical analysis. Usually the text does a pretty good job of explaining his circuits.
- lstamour 11y agoAs someone new to schematics, my question is -- how would you improve it? Genuinely curious...
- mindslight 11y agoRearrange components to group functional blocks, and minimize the number of wire crossings. Replace explicit power busses with supply arrows (more (+9) and (-) like they have for external connections). Splitting monolithic chips into individual gates can help too, but probably isn't needed for this.
- CamperBob2 11y agoIn addition to what mindslight's saying, a schematic should be drawn to make the signal flow as evident as possible, usually from left to right and top to bottom. Sometimes this isn't practical or reasonable, such as when everything's hooked up to an 80-pin IC or something like that, but for a project this simple it wouldn't have been a problem. This diagram is a dog's breakfast. The draftsperson apparently thought this style would make the circuit easier to construct, and perhaps it does, but their real job was to make the circuit easier to understand, and that definitely didn't happen.
- mindslight 11y agoI think it's just the same placement as the breadboard layout. But yeah, it doesn't really help understanding. BTW for anyone copying this onto a breadboard, I've never seen one where the busses are split like the picture. Make sure your 5v and 18v aren't actually connected! Perhaps by building in the middle of the board if the bus is split there.
- Vexs 11y agoReally? I've seen plenty of breadboards with split busses like that, but that could just be the fact that it's one of the longer breadboards. There's been a handful of times where I'm wondering why a circuit isn't working only to realize I hadn't bridged the power/ground rails.
- mindslight 11y agoYes, most breadboards are split in the middle. But that picture shows a split only three groups from the end. FWIW I generally just leave those bridged and a healthy supply of decoupling and supply caps as things that just stay on the board. Circuits that want more than 2 rails + ground get built on a larger board consisting of multiple basic boards, so there's never a need to pack things in.