5 ms·
I read hoping to see some analysis of counter-steering, for the benefit of one or two people I know who shall remain nameless and don't believe counter-steering
by dahart 11y ago
I read hoping to see some analysis of counter-steering, for the benefit of one or two people I know who shall remain nameless and don't believe counter-steering exists, because of course, they've never actually ridden a motorcycle.
Went looking just now and found better explanations online than the last time I tried, years ago, but I have yet to see a satisfactory analysis of the physics. Many of the explanations claim that counter-steering is only done temporarily to begin a lean, only for "setting up" a turn, and then switches to normal steering. After a lot of experimentation, I'm pretty convinced counter-steering is actually always happening on a bike, but relative to the turning radius of your lean, not relative to straight, which makes it a little subtle and harder to demonstrate. If anyone knows where a solid analysis of the physics is, I'd love to see it!
- function_seven 11y agoHa. I don't know why but I've recently become involved in a couple of arguments regarding counter-steering (check comment history :) ). It's the new Monty Hall puzzle. Or "does 0.999... === 1?"
- dahart 11y agoYeah, he was confused and skeptical. A lot of people are, and that's okay because it is unintuitive. I don't bother trying to convince non-riders generally, but I might suggest if they want to argue with me they must first take the MSF course and attempt a few sharp turns before I will bother to engage. :)
- YZF 11y agoYou can also counter-steer a bicycle (at speed)... Also at least the gyroscopic component of it can be felt simply by trying to turn a spinning wheel held in your hands... Something I've seen in a few science museums... I guess the difference with a motorcycle is that it simply can't be steered effectively any other way at speed... So you're not going to find any biker who says this doesn't work ;)
- dahart 11y agoYes, true! So my pet theory is you're always counter-steering even on a bicycle, its just really hard to tell.
- jessaustin 11y agoIf you ride a bicycle with wet tires on dry concrete, your tracks will prove that you're constantly steering small amounts back and forth to remain balanced. So a counter-steer is kind of inevitable: if you're turning left now, you were probably turning right a moment ago. Even so, that's somehow different than counter-steering a motorcycle. I haven't ridden motorcycles nearly as much as bicycles, but my sense is that motorcycle tires/wheels are so much more massive that at normal highway speeds they really do have the gyroscopic effects that everyone mistakenly believes are present in bicycle tires/wheels. When these effects cannot be counteracted by increased steering force, steering requires precession/counter-steer. So there is sort of a progression from low-mass systems that must be steered to stay upright to high-mass systems that must be tilted to steer. It's not clear whether these are really different phenomena, or just two values that have an inverse relation.
- dahart 11y agoEverything you said is right. I'm going to totally geek out here, so forgive me. I don't intend to argue with you at all, just clarifying my own thoughts and explanation. I would call the back and forth "balancing", and not counter-steering. You go back and forth in order to keep your center of mass positioned, on average, over the line that connects your two contact points with the ground. But I think you're continually counter-steering while you balance! (Unless you are leaning really fast back and forth, but that's not how we ride bikes, right? We steer to balance...) Counter-steering (in my mind- this is not necessarily generally accepted) is always an instantaneous effect where you steer the front wheel to the left of where it is, in order to turn more right than you're currently turning. I think that you are always counter-steering, even on a bicycle. My theory is that if you put any inline two wheel vehicle, regardless of motor or mass, into a constant speed, constant radius right turn, then the stationary position will be the front wheel is steering to the right a bit. Now is where counter-steering comes in. In order to increase your turning radius, or straighten out and stop turning, you steer into the turn by pushing forward on the left side of the handlebars. In order to decrease your turning radius, or turn tighter, you push on the right side of the handlebars, thus steering the wheel more left than it currently is. For this second part, your front wheel might be steering right of center the entire time, the critical bit is that you're steering left of where you were in order to tighten your right turn. I think counter-steering is going on at all times, even while you're swinging back and forth balancing on a bike. In fact on a bike its a lot easier to experience counter-steering when you're coming out of a turn than when you're going into one. I think this is what people mistake for steering right to turn right. You do steer right, but it happens after the turn started, you always turn into the turn in order to straighten out. It just happens so quickly and automatically its hard to notice its there. What do you think, sound plausible? The implications of this would mean that mass & gyroscopic effects don't have much to say about counter-steering specifically, they just change how much you can turn by leaning vs turn by counter-steering. With bigger bikes, you can't do much by leaning. (I think I'm just repeating what you said here.) But I also think we use a lot more counter-steer than lean on bicycles, and just don't know it!
- barrkel 11y agoCounter-steering applies a torque to the bottom of the bike. For example: when you steer to the left while having lots of forward momentum, the contact patch of the front wheel wants to go left, so the bike starts rolling to the right, around its centre of gravity. Gravity itself, along with suspension, keeps the bike in contact with the ground even as it rolls over. Once the bike is rolled over into a lean, it will start falling over, but if you leave it at that, it won't simply fall on its side. The steering geometry (specifically, front-loaded steering geometry, you can look it up separately) wants to steer the bike back upright again, by steering into the turn slightly. Depending on how much it's steering into the turn, the bike will either turn quickly and come upright through the same mechanism as counter-steering, or it will turn smoothly in a circle if the steering exactly counteracts the centrifugal ("fake") force. And if it's not steering enough into the turn, then the bike will eventually fall over. Counter-steering while leaned over in the steady state will increase the angle of lean, meaning later, more steering into the turn will be required to maintain lean angle, which will cause the described circle to tighten. Steering more into the turn while leaned over will cause the bike to straighten up. Additional bonus: the width of the front tyre has a large effect on how much the bike straightens up when using the front brake. When leaned over, braking with the front has a torque effect on the steering axis: the contact patch is off to the side of the tyre, and if you've got a wide front tyre, it'll have leverage over the steering. Braking will cause the road to push back on the side you're leaned over on, which will cause steering into the turn, which will straighten the bike up. Steering geometry probably also affects straightening up on front brakes, but I've always noticed it far more on big bikes than ones with narrower, higher aspect ratio front tyres.
- lutorm 11y agoThis is not a correct picture. You shouldn't have to watch a GP race for long to realize that, at speed, the bikes don't pivot around their centres of gravity, they pivot around the contact patch. This is because applying torque to the front wheel through the handlebars (essentially around the yaw axis) results in a gyroscopic rotation around the orthogonal, roll, axis.
- barrkel 11y ago
- rudedogg 11y agoCheck out this clip from "A Twist of the Wrist II": https://youtu.be/8_5Z3jyO2pA?t=3m17 https://youtu.be/8_5Z3jyO2pA?t=3m17
- TrevorJ 11y agoHave him try it on a bicycle. Make sure he wears a helmet though, it works a little too will on bicycles it just dives into a turn if you aren't careful. https://youtu.be/C848R9xWrjc?t=155 https://youtu.be/C848R9xWrjc?t=155
- function_seven 11y agoI was trying to demonstrate this to some friends on a bicycle not too long ago. I learned from that experience to not wear flip flops. I ended up with bloody toes and unconvinced friends...
- fancyketchup 11y agoI think different people may have differing ideas of what "counter-steering" means. That said, the correct way to ride a bicycle down a curvy mountain road is for the rider to put his weight on his outside foot and inside hand (pushing forward against the drop) until exiting the turn (and, in fact, the bike will feel "unsettled" if this technique isn't used).
- plaguuuuuu 11y agoI find that amazingly funny Great anecdote - the first time I rode on a quad bike was after I'd bought a motorcycle. I felt pretty confident and got going at a decent speed. I then had to turn for the first time... imagine my surprise when the bike went the WRONG WAY. WTF. Because of the handlebars and my muscle memory, I tried to counter-steer into the turn and nearly stuffed myself into a huge tree. Luckily, I somehow managed to get the rational non-automatic part of my brain working quickly enough to avoid it, but it was a bit too close..