5 ms·
Hmm. I very strongly got the opposite impression. "Today, we need geniuses like von Neumann and Turing more than ever before. That’s because we may already be
by jameshart 11y ago
Hmm. I very strongly got the opposite impression.
"Today, we need geniuses like von Neumann and Turing more than ever before. That’s because we may already be running into the genetic limits of intelligence.... AI research also pushes even very bright humans to their limits.... The detailed inner workings of a complex machine intelligence (or of a biological brain) may turn out to be incomprehensible to our human minds—or at least the human minds of today". (emphasis mine)
The entire thesis seems to be we will need artificial cognitive enhancements to be able to comprehend AI sufficiently to create it. It really sounds like he thinks we are too dumb to figure this out, that we are just scrabbling around in the dark trying solutions at random.
- jessriedel 11y agoEven if it's true that humans are too dumb to crack AI from first principles -- which as I said is certainly conceivable, and which Hsu alludes to in the quote you've selected -- he's not basing that on the infinite-dimensional space description in the second paragraph. The point of the second paragraph was just to caution against concluding it's an easy problem based on the abundance of intelligence around us.
- jameshart 11y agoAnd my point is that that's not a very good argument. We don't have to use random walk algorithms to look for our solutions to the problem. If someone shows you a list of sorted numbers and tells you they were sorted over a period of millions of years using bogosort, that may be true but it is not a good argument against the existence of efficient sorting algorithms.
- darkmighty 11y agoEvolution is not exactly a random walk, it's a lot better. But it's plausible that creating an AI more "intelligent" than humans (whatever that means) is beyond our current intellectual capabilities, although I seriously doubt it. He's forgetting two other scaling modes applicable to human intelligence: accumulating knowledge and collaborating. By accumulating knowledge we can build upon the work of the generations before us and take essentially unlimited time to crack a problem. Collaboration allows not only parallel processing of problems but also interacting and exchanging inspiration towards the solution of a single problem; both which scale quite well with a lot of intelligent people. Note that there are almost trivial arguments showing some problems are beyond the means of our finite brain (viz unbounded algorithmic complexity or the halting problem).
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>The detailed inner workings of a complex machine intelligence (or of a biological brain) may turn out to be incomprehensible to our human minds—or at least the human minds of today". Did he really say that? I probably should avoid talking right now. Ahaha. Ahahahahaaaa. Oh boy. I mean, the mind isn't that hard to crack once you start conceiving of exactly what problems it was designed to solve, what functions it was designed to perform. We don't have complete theories yet, but generative causal inference in Turing-complete domains gets us into replicating "psychological" behavior and explaining cognitive-psychology experiments, so hey. And then we've got solid overviews of how you'd go about combining concepts into theories into worldviews, and such. There are a bunch of open problems remaining, but not nearly as many as people think.
- jameshart 11y agoWhile it's great to hear of progress in the AI research sphere, if you are working in this field, and are truly close to creating true artificial intelligence, I have a little tip for you: You probably want to learn not to include maniacal laughter in your forum posts. Just, you know, when you do combine the concepts into theories into worldviews, and you come to post your "Show HN: Generative causal inference in turing-complete domains replicates cognitive-psychology experiments" announcement to share with the world that you have birthed a genuine universal AI, please don't start that post off: "Ahaha. Ahahahahaaaa." People will likely get entirely the wrong idea.
- yellowapple 11y agoImplying that "mad scientist creates an artificial intelligence" is anything but the right idea :)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThat was actually not traditional maniacal laughter. That would have been more like, "Muahahaha! AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAA!!" That was uncomfortable laughter. I'm by no means a researcher, just some guy trying to learn enough to volunteer with a lab and eventually become a PhD student. >Just, you know, when you do combine the concepts into theories into worldviews, and you come to post your "Show HN: Generative causal inference in turing-complete domains replicates cognitive-psychology experiments" announcement to share with the world that you have birthed a genuine universal AI, probmods.org has been on HN before, you know.