4 ms·
What are seeing isn't a shift to the service economy but a shift to the automation and digitalization economy. In other words and to paraphrase – It's the techn
by ThomPete 11y ago
What are seeing isn't a shift to the service economy but a shift to the automation and digitalization economy. In other words and to paraphrase – It's the technology stupid!
Look at any sector and you will see that the only way to further improve production-output is to add more technology or artificial enhancements, which means slowly; less and less; jobs for everyone.
Now if the price on all products and services went down at the same time as the number of jobs are disappearing and the wages goes down, we wouldn't have any issues.
But the problem is that urbanization pushes prices up and so even though production gets cheaper and cheaper, the cost of living still seems to be going up which means we will need to digitalize even more to make up for it. But that takes time and in the meantime millions and millions of people in the west are loosing any ability to participate in the job-market because they aren't just competing against each other or outsourcing but everyone is competing against automation and digitalization.
This global slowdown is different because the shift to the service economy in China means that production have no other way to go than automation which means you won't have the benefits of humans getting jobs and therefore become part of the global economy.
Instead wealth goes to those who own the robots and Marx although wrong in most things, was finally right about something :)
- cylinder 11y agoI agree with you, I think the deflationary effects of technology are vastly underestimated. Have a look around at what technology is doing day-to-day to consumption and costs and it should be obvious, and yet talking heads still expect CPI inflation. We just got a nice patch because of China's malinvestment stimulus but now they are forced to rebalance regardless of Xi. The commodity supercycle is over and that's bad news for many countries (not really the US).
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly. What happened was that globalization moved the jobs somewhere else, it didn't create more in the west. In fact each decade less and less jobs have been created. The fact is that there is no new industry for people to flee into and if people think there is they have to explain what that would be. https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-states/ https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-... As long as economist keep talking about technology as an externality, they have no business talking about where the economy is headed. IMO.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The commodity supercycle is over and that's bad news for many countries Bluntly, Australia and Canada are screwed.
- Kalium 11y agoMarx was right if you interpret him as only concerned with unskilled, menial laborers. And yeah, non-service-sector unskilled labor is going the way of the dodo. I'm having a difficult time mourning this, as it frees up an awe-inspiring amount of human potential.
- jcfrei 11y agoVery interesting that you bring up Marx! However if I recall correctly Marx was mostly worried about the complete commoditization of work (which we see to some extent with service companies like Uber). I don't think he considered the possibility that there simply might not be any work for anyone. It'd be interesting to hear his views on these contemporary developments: Because the co-ownership of a factory by it's employees (which communism envisions) is a mentally reasonable concept that a lot of people love. However how would you go about a company that only requires three people to service millions of customers? Does communism have an answer to that? Would Marx suggest to just turn every company into a state owned company? Could the free software movement by Richard Stallman be a clandestine communist movement to socialize the ownership of the modern means of production (ie. software)?
- sologoub 11y agoBecause theoretical communism has no use for money, the notion of ownership of that factory also goes away. The theory (at least the way I understand it) is that in a communist utopia, the society is not constrained as much by consumption and therefore everyone has enough. Ironically, we might be approaching that point from the basic needs level - food and shelter for everyone is not such an outlandish idea anymore. However, I do not believe that people will be magically able to distribute that shared wealth evenly, so the more dystopian future is more likely where for the majority of manufacturing-related needs, capital completely replaces rank and file labor. Personally, I think the idea of basic income or some other redistribution of wealth that keeps the demand alive is a more reasonable solution to the shrinking labor pool, as the need for labor will not evaporate completely, but instead individuals will be displaced from the labor pool in ways that will prevent them from effectively competing again.
- ThomPete 11y agoEveryone white a 401K is a capitalist today and so in that respects it's a solved issue. The problem of course is how those money are invested.