3 ms·
My point is that if I wanted to start my own company (which I don’t), I wouldn’t feel nervous. The reason is clear: By earning a PhD in computer science at MIT
by dasil003 17y ago
My point is that if I wanted to start my own company (which I don’t), I wouldn’t feel nervous. The reason is clear: By earning a PhD in computer science at MIT I developed a skill that’s rare and valuable to this particular economic segment.
So this guy thinks that getting emails from recruiters means that he has what it takes to be an entrepreneur? He thinks that a degree you get from a University teaches you something about running a business. Oh, and by the way, he would be fabulously successful at it if he wanted to. Yeah, I could dunk over Shaq too, it's just that I don't have any interest in playing basketball.
Being an entrepreneur has so little to do with skills (you can always learn those). It's about decision-making, ability to learn and pivot, and guts. Frankly, I find this guys ivory-tower preaching to be grating. He doesn't know jack about entrepreneurship and yet he's willing to take a dump all over someone who happened to be starting their first business in a market segment that was hit terribly hard by the recession.
- briancooley 17y agoIndeed, it seems to me that he would fail miserably at starting a company because he equates the product/service his company would make/offer with his education. It's as if Google would have been successful just by branding their search as "Google - the search engine developed by Stanford PhD's" What's rare and valuable are people that accomplish a lot with a little. I have no idea if the culture at MIT preferentially fosters that kind of dogged resourcefulness, but thinking you're done before you even get started because of a handful of letters on a piece of paper is a start in the wrong direction.
- neilc 17y agohe would fail miserably at starting a company because he equates the product/service his company would make/offer with his education I think you misunderstood the post. The author said nothing about how his PhD would directly relate to starting a new company (the author's research is theoretical, anyway). Rather, the point is that by acquiring a valuable skill (a PhD from MIT), his risk profile is lower: he could go and start a new venture, or equivalently wager all his assets at the roulette table; either way, his skills mean he would be able to find a good job if the gamble doesn't turn out well. If you like, substitute "MIT PhD" for "become one of the top 5 Linux kernel developers" for an equivalently rare, valuable skill that would help to ensure future employment.
- briancooley 17y agoUpon rereading, I agree with your assessment, but the crux of the issue is that his example of Lisa isn't so "pristine." He argues that her small business failed because her skills weren't rare and valuable. Then he says his skills are rare and valuable. A consistent argument springing from those two statements would be either a) my business won't fail because my skills are rare and valuable, or b) Lisa can't find another job in marketing (the job she held for a decade before quitting) because those skills aren't rare and valuable. He didn't make either of those arguments, instead focusing on her yoga instructor skills. It makes for a muddled post.
- csallen 17y agoI'm not sure the author is saying he has what it takes to be an amazing entrepreneur. He seems to be referencing his education and skillset to prove a much different point -- that even if he starts a business and fails, he won't have much to fear because getting a job will be easier for him. That's a valid point.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"By earning a PhD in computer science at MIT I developed a skill that’s rare and valuable to this particular economic segment." I think if the word "skill" is replaced by "asset", it reads better. OK, a little better. Maybe what he was trying to say was either (a) it is much easier to get a job in this economy if you have an MIT PhD or (b) he could get funding etc easily thanks to his MIT PhD or (c) while working through his PhD he acquired unique skills which enable him to found a company (as compared to someone who did a course in Yoga). (c) is more dubious than (a) or (b), as dasil003 points out above) I am just guessing here but it might be the case that the problem might be with the phrasing than the underlying idea. I agree that as written, the sentence seems to imply that he could be an entrepreneur just bacuse his MIT PhD is "rare".