3 ms·
The issue is not overall scarcity, but scarcity in specific places—the cities responsible for a disproportionate amount of the world’s output. The high price of
by jseliger 11y ago
The issue is not overall scarcity, but scarcity in specific places—the cities responsible for a disproportionate amount of the world’s output. The high price of land in these places is in part an unavoidable concomitant of success. But it is also the product of distortions that cost the world dear
The article is good but the title isn't great; the real story isn't about land per se, but about land-use regulation: the topics are related but quite distinct (and indeed the article says, "The spread of land-use regulation is not hard to understand"). As Matt Yglesias is fond of pointing out, steel-framed construction and elevators are well-understood, century-old technologies (http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/03/silicon_valley_housing_boom_there_s_no_such_thing.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/03/silicon_valle...).
But laws against deploying them have become important constraints on growth. The problems are really legal and political. The solutions will be (or won't be) as well.
- creshal 11y agoBoth land-use regulations, and land owners (ab-)using their oligopoly to drive up rents to insane levels, which combined cripple the rest of the economy by preventing growth.
- deelowe 11y agoWhere has rent control ever worked favorably for the cities that have implemented it? It's simple economics, as value is derived from a city, the city itself becomes more valuable. A more valuable city has more valuable real estate. More valuable real estate costs more to purchase and develop. "Location, location, location" isn't just some cliche realtors like to use. In the majority of cases, there's no conspiracy. Rent goes up, because the real value has gone up. It really is that simple.
- srtjstjsj 11y agoDefine "real value". Prices are driven my many-to-many auctions, and each market (housing) interacts with its supplements (transportation, food, energy, finance,...). The value varies from person to person, and much of the value is parasitic: I derive value from getting paid by my job, and my home, transport, etc enable me to do that job. If I make $100K/yr, is my home providing $10k/yr of value? Or $40k/yr? If I get a raise, is my home more valuable because it supports my higher income? Or is my transportation more valuable? Or is my food more valuable, as it keeps me healthy?
- deelowe 11y agoDid you skip macro economics? None of this really makes much sense when talking about rent prices in a market driven economy.