9 ms·
I wonder if I am an outlier in that I have a massive paranoia about being thrown into jail randomly because of being in the wrong place at the wrong time or cop
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
I wonder if I am an outlier in that I have a massive paranoia about being thrown into jail randomly because of being in the wrong place at the wrong time or cops executing a warrant on the wrong house.
Maybe it's because I am mixed race and grew up in a poor minority neighborhood but it seems like the system is just eager and waiting to put everyone in it. Kind of like a low grade terror all the time.
- theseatoms 11y agoHave you read 'The Trial' by Kafka? Maybe you shouldn't, but it's a good read.
- cven714 11y agoReminds me of the intro to Brazil: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSQ5EsbT4cE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSQ5EsbT4cE
- jonlucc 11y agoI started thinking about this a lot while listening to the last season of Serial. At times, there is enough doubt in the case to think that he might have been just a high school boy who's girlfriend was heinously murdered. Then, next thing you know, he's being arrested and the state is demanding that he account for his whereabouts 6 weeks ago.
- astazangasta 11y agoI recently went to traffic court where i watched a young central American man get funneled into providing the state with free labor, merely because he was vulnerable and the opportunity was there. Our judicial system is for chewing up poor people. But it was ever thus; high-minded notions of justice cannot be carried by bureaucrats.
- thesagan 11y agoI noticed the same thing one time in a very similar circumstance. One guy after another being assigned to state work that very day.
- mason240 11y agoThe court is an inefficient way of providing the state with free labor. He could have skipped the court and just gotten a job and started paying income taxes.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoTell it to the prison-industrial complex.
- wpietri 11y agoIf everybody's metric of success is national maximized social/economic utility, your point would be fine. But that isn't the case. Many people prefer a positional metric, where they'd rather be poor as long as other people are poorer. See, e.g.: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167268198000894 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167268198... If the point is money, then yes, you'd be right. But for a lot of people the point is status, not money. Taking a vulnerable or visibly different group of people and forcing them into a subordinate state is going to feel like success to a lot of people.
- ManFromUranus 11y ago>Our judicial system is for chewing up poor people Hyperbolic statement with absolutely no details about this situation? Seems legit.
- atom-morgan 11y agoThe last time I was in court (two weeks ago) it was _filled_ with poor people for non-violent victimless crimes. And I was there for something that is NOT a law, written in plain English at DMV.org. But the cop wrote me a ticket so I have to waste countless hours of my life dealing with their shit.
- vfdfv 11y agoSame deal if you stand in line at a car impound lot. I once got my car towed on a snowy night, one of ~1000 other cars towed that night in Minneapolis (on Christmas Eve no less!). The line at the impound lot was filled with poorer (looking) people, especially Somali, Hispanic, and Asian people for whom English was not their first language. My dad drove me there and stood in line with me, and I could tell it had a profound effect on his outlook. My dad has always been quite liberal, but being a rich, older white guy living in the suburbs, he hadn't seen firsthand some of the more subtle ways that poor / minority people are disadvantaged by the system.
- dysfunction 11y agoAre you saying that something is not a law because DMV.org says so, or that the cop thought something was a law because DMV.org said so? DMV.org is not a government website.
- Raphmedia 11y agoTo be honest, I'm afraid of travelling (to America even) and of leaving the relative safety of Canada because of that. I've heard so many stories about people ending up in jail in the USA or Mexico or other countries from things that would be considered minor and them having to fight their way out of it. Missed bribe there, racist cops there, at least I'm safe home where the only time I have to worry about the police is during protests.
- thesagan 11y agoMy cousins live in London, Ontario, but spend maybe 1/2 of their time in the states, where their mother (my aunt) was born and raised. They cross the border all of the time. They love to joke about the Canadian attitudes towards their risk exposure coming into the states; although it has become more frustrating to cross the border, the mythology is a bit hyped. I would say, however, and they'd probably agree, you'll find a huge variation in policing between regions and urban areas vs rural ones. I'm from the country (now in the city) and rural cops scare me more than urban cops because... hard to express.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Missed bribe there Lived in the US my whole life and never had to bribe anyone. Europe? I've bribed people more than a few times to get shit done. Mostly Eastern, but the idea that the US is on par with Mexico via corruption is fairly laughable.
- Someone1234 11y agoBribery in the US is definitely NOT a day to day occurrance. That being said, the US is definitely corrupt, but in the US corruption is legal as long as you follow the corruption rules. For example, I can donate $100K to my favourite political candidate right now and then ask them for favours, totally legal, but yet corrupt. We're coming up to election season and candidates have already started bragging about who is paying their way (e.g. Wall Street, Koch Brothers, Big Oil, etc) and if anyone doesn't think this type of thing is an investment into future political favours then they're very naive. PS - While there is corruption in every country, the US's electoral finance rules make it particularly bad.
- baldfat 11y agoBeing arrested due to a mistake by police is my only reoccurring nightmare ever since I was 13. Usually it is a bank robbery. Sadly one of my friends were arrested and convicted of a crime with not one piece of evidence besides one person saying something about them. They could have plea bargained for 18 months but instead they thought I am innocent so might as well be found not guilty. He got 12 years.
- adekok 11y agoUncorroborated accomplice testimony is insufficient to convict someone. See https://www.justia.com/criminal/docs/calcrim/500/708.html https://www.justia.com/criminal/docs/calcrim/500/708.html, among others. Why was he convicted? Because the law matters only when it's convenient. I used to believe that "ignorance of the law is no excuse". I no longer do. The people enforcing the laws (prosecutor, judge, police, etc.) are explicitly protected from misapplying the law. There are excuses for them for not knowing the law, or not applying it correctly. I claim the same rights as them. If ignorance of the law is an excuse for them, it's an excuse for me. And yes, on the bare face of it, your friend should have been found not guilty.
- leaveyou 11y agoI don't want to think what will happen to that "witness" after 12 years..
- Tomte 11y agowith not one piece of evidence besides one person saying something about them There's your evidence. Witnesses are evidence.
- venomsnake 11y agoNo they are not. Humans are too unrealiable. Also some humans lie.
- Tomte 11y agoYou're operating with a very idiosyncratic and totally impractical definition of "evidence". So unless you start speaking the same language as everyone else, there's not much use in any discussion.
- sixothree 11y agoI don't think it's that paranoid. Our criminal justice system is far from perfect. I've heard estimates that up to 10% of people imprisoned are innocent of that particular crime. And just look at the number of people on death row who have been exonerated. Cases that get that much scrutiny should have a zero percent change of being incorrect but that's so far from the truth it's shocking.
- furyofantares 11y agoHave you made any attempt to estimate the probability of that happening and then compare it to other risks you are able to take without paranoia?
- hessenwolf 11y ago1% of people in America are in jail. I don't know what is illegal. That is way outside of my risk management zone.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThe law is more complicated than any one person understands, but I'd bet 99% of the incarcerated population was jailed for things you already know are illegal.
- Raphmedia 11y agoI would rather travel to the back-countries of a lof of European countries than visiting the USA outside tourist spots.