4 ms·
The notion that we could turn speech in to searchable text in a useful way betrays the author's knowledge of spoken communication. Very often it's not the words
by onion2k 11y ago
The notion that we could turn speech in to searchable text in a useful way betrays the author's knowledge of spoken communication. Very often it's not the words that are the important bit. Unless the recording medium can add in 'Person A shrugged' or 'Person B replied 'Yes' but was being sarcastic', any system will be next to useless.
- RyanMcGreal 11y agoThe spoken word would simply become subject to the same channel constraint that the written word already faces today. A huge amount of conflict and misunderstanding in online discussion stems directly from the fact that sarcasm is very difficult to convey reliably through plain text. (A sarcasm tag would work, of course, but half the point of sarcasm is that the listener/reader "gets it". Indicating that you are about to say/write something sarcastic destroys the in-group feeling that comes from being able to recognize and pick up on it.)
- etiam 11y agoChances are you could already get a sentiment vector with every sound-bite with respect to tone. Body language will clearly need more than a microphone as sensor to do it well, but as RyanMcGreal's comment hints at, the fact that a system like this isn't particularly good is no guarantee that it won't be used.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoIt'll still be useful, but for worse purposes. To be able to quote what someone says with out being able to tell what is sarcasm will allow you to create great attacks against that person which a significant portion of the population will buy into. Imagine if we had every sarcastic quip from Snowden. I'm sure there is at least one thing he has ever said that would make a lot of people made if it were taken out of context.
- zaroth 11y agoPresumably the searchable text is just metadata overlay on the full unredacted HD video stream with high fidelity audio using microphone arrays which allow post-process beamforming and noise reduction. Even if it's "only" 10-20 years out, we're still all fucked.