6 ms·
In 2010, Demand For US Fixed Income Has To Increase Elevenfold... Or Else
- anigbrowl 17y agoAn interesting argument (as always from zerohedge) but one that seems to be predicated on the idea that the government has no intention of reducing the deficit. Opponents of Keynesian policies always argue as if fiscal stimulus is meant to function as a new normal rather than a temporary corrective. By analogy, this would be like alternative health folks pointing out the downsides of permanent antibiotic consumption, although antibiotics are usually only administered long enough to overcome the progress of disease. The Fed will certainly put up interest rates, almost certainly during 2010; I just think they're trying to hold off doing so to any substantial degree until growth hits a steady 3% and unemployment falls below 10%.
- pmorici 17y agoAre they talking about the long term though? I think they are mainly discussing the situation the government is committed to in the 2010 fiscal year.
- anigbrowl 17y agoIndeed, but I took it to read that the market would be valuing bonds on the basis of permanent deficits. If they're expecting a combination of reasonable growth and a stabilizing of the debt load then rather than treating the recent increases as a trend, then I don't think we'll see bond spreads widen very dramatically. ZeroHedge seems to be assuming a kind of late bull market complacency that's blinding everyone everyone else to what the federal government is at, whereas in reality the Fed and the treasury are under close scrutiny worldwide.
- rodyancy 17y agoI appreciate your analogy, however, I believe the author is saying that discontinuing the use of the antibiotic at anytime in the next year, will lead to a detrimental relapse. I don't necessarily agree, but the argument is predicated on, amongst other things, the Fed not being able to raise interest rates and maintain steady 3% growth.
- dgordon 17y agoHistory indicates that running at a deficit did indeed become the new normal. "There is nothing so normal as a temporary government program."
- tptacek 17y agoThat's some quality snark there, but as the Fed does in fact routinely increase interest rates, I think your comment is basically content-free.
- anamax 17y ago> That's some quality snark there, but as the Fed does in fact routinely increase interest rates, I think your comment is basically content-free. The question is not whether the Fed increases interest rates, it's how close the budget is to balanced.
- jeremyw 17y agoHard to argue with the data. The norm is deficits. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_annual_federal_deficits_over_receipts_1901_to_2006.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_annual_federal_deficits...
- sethg 17y agoDoes your history include the Clinton Administration, which ran a surplus?
- anamax 17y ago> Does your history include the Clinton Administration, which ran a surplus? Yes, it does. Clinton benefitted from the end of the cold war and a repub congress. They couldn't figure out how to spend the "savings" fast enough. (A Repub president with a dem congress might have had the same problem.) What "war" do you see ending that will produce comparable savings? (Obama is winding down Iraq on Bush's schedule.)
- 17y ago
- mattchew 17y ago> the idea that the government has no intention of reducing the deficit. Close. How about this: reducing the deficit would be extremely painful and therefore postponed as long as possible, and then undertaken in a half-hearted manner. How much of our current financial stability relies on banks having access to zero percent interest rates and being paid interest on the reserves they hold? How much of the apparent recovery is based on stimulus/deficit spending? I hope the answer is "not much", but I'm afraid the answer is "a lot". Banks are sitting on reserves, not lending. The P/E ratio for the stock market is somewhere up in bubble territory. Unemployment may have bottomed, but it is still at terrible levels. We have states in the U.S. and nations in the Eurozone that are hinting at defaults. I think with continued signs of instability, we'll continue to run high deficits (financed in part by Fed purchases). We'll undertake austerity measure when the living-off-debt chickens start coming home to roost. Not before.
- guelo 17y agoHuh? I wonder if a CS article would ever receive any attention on a finance website.
- sp332 17y agoThis isn't a CS website. "On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity." http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- guelo 17y agoWhat I meant to imply is that the article is incomprehensible, at least to me, and I was wondering if a technical CS article would be of interest to finance people.
- motters 17y agoI also found this article to be pretty much incomprehensible. It lacks conciseness and clarity. What are they suggesting will happen to the US economy in 2010?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- robotrout 17y agoThey are suggesting that the US Government needs to borrow a very large amount of money in 2010. To do this, one of three things needs to occur. 1) Another round of quantitative easing (Fed increases the money supply) This will lead to a dollar collapse, or at the very least, a severe dollar devaluation, which is generally not good for the economy. 2) Fed raises interest rates. With higher interest rates, more people are willing to buy treasuries, and so, there's more money coming in to pay the bills coming due in 2010. Higher interest rates are generally not good for the economy, particularly if it's already sick. 3) US Government engineers a stock market collapse, to send people scurrying to the safety of treasuries (and thereby allowing government to borrow what they need to). Of course, stock market collapses are generally bad for the economy. So, in summary, I'd say they are predicting that the U.S. economy will have a rough 2010.
- mark_l_watson 17y agoYeah, this article is probably much more accurate than what you see on the corporate news media. Fortunately for our 'masters', there are always news stories about terrorism, etc. that they can use to keep public consciousness off of higher importance things like the economy. I got out of the stock market 2 years ago, started easing back in about 9 months ago, and now I want to get back out.
- Tichy 17y agoWhat is "issuance"? Printing money?
- ghshephard 17y agoFrom: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Treasury_security http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Treasury_security "Treasury bills are sold by single price auctions held weekly. Offering amounts for 13-week and 26-week bills are announced each Thursday for auction, usually at 11:30 am, on the following Monday and settlement, or issuance, on Thursday."
- nod 17y agoIs this guy a nutcase? He reads kind of like a doom-and-gloom nutcase, but I am not an economist. Could one comment on his basic validity level?
- ars 17y agoHe's trying to say that america needs to issue lots more debt, but soon no one will want to buy any debt. He's also assuming america won't do anything about it.