2 ms·
Monopolies and taxes are two different things.
by EGreg 11y ago
Monopolies and taxes are two different things.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThe distinction between monopoly rents from a government-mandated monopoly and a tax on the category of service for which it is a monopoly is very hard to see.
- EGreg 11y agoA tax would be if a certain class of people were forced to pay for the monopoly service, in this case some people would be forced to play the lottery.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> A tax would be if a certain class of people were forced to pay for the monopoly service, in this case some people would be forced to play the lottery. If the government taxes a particular non-monopoly service, no one is forced to buy the service, but the tax is still recognized as a tax. Mandating a monopoly on a class of service, which monopoly then extracts monopoly rents -- especially where the state receives the rents, or a share thereof -- is pretty hard to meaningfully distinguish from taxing the class of service. Sure, no one is compelled to purchase the service, but a tax on alcohol or tobacco doesn't stop being a tax because no one is forced to purchase alcohol or tobacco.