4 ms·
And as long as ads are syntactically indistinguishable from site content, they can't programatically block ads.
by SilasX 11y ago
And as long as ads are syntactically indistinguishable from site content, they can't programatically block ads.
- oconnore 11y agoIf ad networks ever go out of style, ad blockers will combine sentiment analysis with a brand recognizer. Any content that promotes Tide Fabric Softener too heavily/at all will get squashed. This: http://jonathandub.in/cognizance/ http://jonathandub.in/cognizance/ will always be easier to do in the relatively constrained environment of the web.
- rblatz 11y agoWho is to say that the ad won't be jibberish to the computer? With web fonts you can make the screen say anything to humans while presenting very different text to the machine.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoAnd then the ad-blocker starts examining the screen itself with OCR as opposed to just fonts. Again, the cat and mouse game continues. And the ads cannot win while the user has control over their own computer.
- hollerith 11y ago-- which is one reason I disabled web fonts (by setting gfx.downloadable_fonts.enabled to false in about:config in Firefox).
- oconnore 11y agoYou didn't click on my link, did you?
- johnward 11y agoThis is why "content marketing" has grown so much in the past few years.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoHow so? Syntax is not the only thing that distinguishes ads. If you are willing to compromise on precision and recall, you could classify text/images/whatever using other methods (after appropriate segmentation). Buy viagra today. Sure, you can embed ads in regular text, but if humans can detect it then maybe computers can, too. Of course, it might be harder to detect product placement. You should read the chapter about that in my upcoming book. It's only $9.99.
- johnward 11y agoThink about the products you see announced on this very site. Most of those people are writing helpful blog posts and using them to promote an ebook or some type of product. Technically those posts are advertisements or marketing materials. How would you ban those? Would you even want to ban those if they are actually useful to people? HN itself is one big advertising platform to promote Y Combinator Startups.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoI, personally, don't care about blocking ads. I wish to block a few things, and ads tend to fall under these categories. If ads did not fall under these categories, I wouldn't mind them: -I wish to minimize my attack surface. -I wish to minimize resource consumption. -I wish to use my display to see the content I am focused on. -I wish to not worry about distracting / annoying / being judged by others. -I wish to not be tracked - preferably not by the site I am visiting, and definitely not by random third parties, and certainly not by random third parties in countries with questionable laws. Unfortunately, most ads seem to fall under all of these categories.