7 ms·
FuckAdBlock
- pritambaral 11y agoMention must be made of the nemesis: Anti-Adblock Killer[0], which can be enabled with just one check in uBlock Origin's preferences 0: https://github.com/reek/anti-adblock-killer#supported-sites https://github.com/reek/anti-adblock-killer#supported-sites
- alkonaut 11y agoIf you are very paranoid about people seeing content but not ads then just render the content and the ad into the same pre-baked image. You don't even need to bake all the content with the ads, just enough to make the content useless without the ad+content bits. It will be bad for bandwidth, bad for readability, bad for layout. But it'll likely make no one see content without ads.
- dwb 11y agoThe web is, by and large, a distracting, surveilling mess with ads. At least ads in the real world are just distracting (the surveillance comes from elsewhere). So no, I'll keep my ad blocker thanks.
- paulhauggis 11y agoThe irony is that many people here that want to create a startup and earn any kind of living will have a diminishing chance over time because of the increased usage of ad blockers..many of whom support ad blocking with a passion.
- runin2k1 11y agoThe problem is that much of the times ads are disruptive, annoying, and potentially harmful. When your choices are to have a) a safer, less disruptive browsing experience, b) potentially have your entire screen taken over with alerts offering to clean out the viruses found on you computer, the smart consumer is going to take option A every time. The advertising industry, and those that employ it, need to aggressively move against bad practices, or the consumers will continue to do it for them.
- johnward 11y agoDoes B actually exist? I've never used an ad blocker and I don't experience this. It's either an exaggeration or you're visiting some shady sites :) edit: B did exist in the days of windows 95 but I don't see it as a problem now. The biggest issue is auto play video or audio which even browsers makers are taking on.
- runin2k1 11y agoBeing the "IT" person amongst my friends and families, I routinely get asked how to fix a computer that has been hacked. In every single case the problem isn't that the computer got hacked, it was them clicking an ad that stated they had a virus, or they downloaded something random because they couldn't see through the noise. See my CNet link below in another response. Savvy users can tune these things out, and/or know sites to avoid, but for the lay-person it is hazardous.
- johnward 11y agoI guess that makes sense. I let my mom use my computer a few weeks ago and I ended up with 20 different "coupon printers".
- paulhauggis 11y ago" potentially have your entire screen taken over with alerts offering to clean out the viruses found on you computer, the smart consumer is going to take option A every time." The only time I've seen this is when I've gone to shady websites (porn, filesharing, etc). Legitimate websites don't want to piss off their user base and don't have ads like this. "The problem is that much of the times ads are disruptive, annoying, and potentially harmful" Do you have statistics to back this up? We seem to need scientific evidence in every other case, but with things like this, you can pull it out of thin air. There are a small percentage of ads that are disruptive, but the majority are not. It sounds to me like Sysadmins need to start doing their job. "The advertising industry, and those that employ it, need to aggressively move against bad practices, or the consumers will continue to do it for them." The consumers will only get punished. Ads are on their way out. What's becoming more popular? Paywalls, ads disguised as movies/videos/actual content. Think of things like Dr. Phil and Dr. Oz. This is the direct result of consumers creating a culture of avoiding ads. How about if all of the major Internet providers decide to cut off anyone trying to use Bittorrent because of a small percentage of people abusing it for illegal content?? This is the equivalent of adblocker: punishing all businesses for the actions of a few. Funny how the same people that are against this behavior has no problem using it when it is in their favor. More bullshit hypocrisy.
- swagv 11y agoI've worked for ad-supported properties with 100s of millions of monthly uniques. I adopted ad blockers not so much because of not wanting to see the ads, but more because the JavaScript, media file, and other technologies supporting the ads killed my browser performance. I'd be happy to view ads in context if it didn't suck up all my CPU cycles and free memory.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoAds are not the only way to make money on the internet. FULL STOP
- johnward 11y agoI agree but they seem to be a major part of the online economy. I think users and advertisers are going to have to reach some kind of agreement for "free" sites to continue to exist. I know there are other business models but I would not be surprised if we hit a point where ad supported content no longer exists. I hope some new "free" business model is developed because I certainly don't want a pay as you go model.
- nosuchthing 11y agoNetflix, Mubi, monthly ISP, web hosting, phone lines, Amazon Prime, delivery services... plenty of people are fine paying for rental or pay as you go services.
- johnward 11y agoPeople still want to consume content. What is the business model for content sites? Die? Right now it seems like people want to leach the content with out paying the bills.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoI happen to know a fair bit about a particular fairly popular content site. Ads make up a minority of their overall revenue, though it's still a significant chunk. They would survive quite easily without ads. The main advantage of ads is that they are potentially brain-dead easy to enable profitability if you have lots of traffic. But even then that's not necessarily an objectively good thing. Also, I wouldn't say that "people want to leach ... with out paying" is accurate whatsoever. Between merch, events, crowd funding, and patronage (patreon et al) there is a massive and rapidly growing amount of money that has been going to content creators direct from content consumers. It's easier than it's been in a long time, perhaps ever, for a creator to support themselves, aside from ads, and it's only getting easier.
- dukerutledge 11y agoHow about a business plan other than mine my users' info and sell them ads?
- justizin 11y agoWhen you've worked in an office with a hundred people all running AdBlock because on top of the line hardware, your site is unusable without it, let's talk.
- davidgerard 11y agoIf your startup relies on malwaring your users, your business plan may not be sufficiently robust.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 11y agoGo to an ad company and see how many people are running an ad blocker. It was essentially 100% when I was working for one. The exception was a guy doing testing on the live web. It's not really a contradiction. You're just like a drug dealer who knows better than using the product yourself.
- Recurecur 11y agoI had never blocked ads, since sometimes they're actually interesting, until the recent spate of malware propagated by ad servers. AdBlockerPlus (Chrome extension) allows ads as long as there's no video, animation, or js shenanigans. That seems reasonable enough to me. It's actually been amazing how nice things are with faster page loads, and fewer annoying distractions...not to mention no video/audio autoplay. I for one would rather not see an ad versus ad blocker arms race.
- devopsproject 11y ago"until the recent spate of malware propagated by ad servers" Same for me. I can live with the annoying ads but losing a day rebuilding my computer is not worth it
- djur 11y agoI didn't use adblockers for years, but there was a point where I felt like advertisers had just broken down the mutually-understood norms that made online advertising acceptable. So I wrote an angry rant (http://supox.dingis-west.com/asshole.html http://supox.dingis-west.com/asshole.html) and installed adblockers on everything I could. Life has been much better with adblock. I turn it off on sites that I know don't use abusive advertising practices, but it's strictly opt-in at this point.
- wsc981 11y agoFrom what I've read it'll be possible in iOS 9 to use add block extensions on mobile devices. And this will result in way less traffic, so the internet bundle will be more effective and sites will load quicker. For mobile devices blocking adds is very useful indeed. Here's a short explanation on how an add blocker might be build for iOS 9: https://www.hackingwithswift.com/safari-content-blocking-ios9 https://www.hackingwithswift.com/safari-content-blocking-ios...
- Zarel 11y agoI don't see an "AdBlockerPlus" in the Chrome Web Store, and a google search tells me that "Max AdBlocker Plus" is malware. Can you link to the extension you're talking about?
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThis is why it's important not to use easily fingerprintable add-ons, but to simply make use of your operating system's name services, instead (in this case hosts(5) being the simplest route).
- joepie91_ 11y agoYour hosts file will not cover all cases. Many locally-operated ad systems, for example, can't be blocked with it.
- mpol 11y agoShouldn't Adblock be able to block this JavaScript from loading?
- thoughtsimple 11y agoI would think that NoScript will block it.
- probably_wrong 11y agoIt does. I had to enable scripts on the site to see the message.
- kolme 11y agoIt is, that's why the author recommends the following: // Recommended audit because AdBlock lock the file 'fuckadblock.js' // If the file is not called, the variable does not exist 'fuckAdBlock' // This means that AdBlock is present if(typeof fuckAdBlock === 'undefined') { adBlockDetected(); } else {
- skrowl 11y agoWindows 10 + Firefox Dev Edition 42.0a2 (2015-09-02) x64 bit / e10s on + uBlock Origin 1.1.0.0 with everything checked in 3rd party filters other than "multipurpose"... AdBlock is not enabled
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoAnd so the cat and mouse game continues. That being said, ultimately as long as the user has control over what runs on their computer, they have control. Period. Things like this are doomed to failure.
- mbrownnyc 11y agoYes. I've just immediately not gone to a site that didn't load content because I was using an ad blocker. Your content has to be very worth it for me to disable my ad blocker.
- kuschku 11y agotime.com has that issue, and I just ended up writing a small userstyle to fix it.
- Animats 11y agoTime.com is so broken. They disable scroll, but their pages are longer than the screen height. It's so silly. Their pages are static.
- Zarel 11y agoIt's unclear why the website would care, since you're clearly not a revenue source for them.
- nicolewhite 11y agoI like what OkCupid does. If you have an ad blocker enabled, they explain in the space where an ad would normally be that while OkCupid is free, it runs on ad revenue, with a link to their donation page.
- gk1 11y agoThat's the purpose of this script (as I see it): Detect if an ad blocker is being used, and if so, display some custom message.
- staunch 11y agoCry "Havoc!", and let slip the dogs of war! I'm on the other side, with the good guys and all the technical advantages. Good luck to your side!
- NullCharacter 11y agoSeems like it's a matter of perspective and, like most things, not as black-and-white as "good guys vs. bad guys".
- staunch 11y agoThe only purpose of ads is to forcefully track, distract, and exploit people's privacy for financial gain. The surest way to bring about new ethical business models is to destroy the existing ones.
- dzeanah 11y agoYou learn something every day. I thought the purpose of ads was to generate revenue so that content could be created in infrastructure built. You know, like it's been done for a few centuries now...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- staunch 11y agoWhat businesses were ad supported centries ago? People used to pay for things and they liked it! Netflix, HBO, and Amazon are creating the best content in the world and they're not using advertising to pay for it. Low margin ad-supported television is one of the worst aspects of modern cultures.
- NullCharacter 11y agoHey look at that, I found one from 1704 (bottom right). http://i.imgur.com/PbmXyhf.jpg http://i.imgur.com/PbmXyhf.jpg And that's just from the Americas.
- davidgerard 11y agoIt's entirely unclear what the thinking is behind this sort of thing. "You won't fuck me? Well, well, I won't fuck you! So there!"
- johnward 11y agoI'm interested in this just for analytical purpose. I'd like to see how many of my users do block ads, but they probably block 3rd party analytics also. My only question is: If users can block ads should content creators not be able to detect that and not serve the request? It may be a horrible business decision but it only seems fair to me.
- whyenot 11y ago> My only question is: If users can block ads should content creators not be able to detect that and not serve the request? Yes, of course, but how are you going to do that, and is the end result going to be what you want? It seems to me like if a website goes down that road, it ends up in an arms race with some of its users and the authors of adblockers.
- johnward 11y agoI never said it was a good idea it just seems fair to be able to choose not "waste" bandwidth. Although the argument that hosting is becoming so cheap it doesn't matters could be made. The biggest issue with being able to detect ad blockers is that you could do something nefarious, so I understand why the blockers don't want to be detected. I could just imagine my someone going to an innocent site with an adblocker enable and getting goatse'd for example.
- thatusertwo 11y agoI've always got Ghostery running on my computer, I use it to block everything, still see ads sometimes but it certainly enhances my web experience.
- Geekette 11y agoEh, long live ad blocking! Its great being able to view clean, distraction-free webpages and I just move on if a site refuses to load otherwise. Since a lot of content I view online falls under entertainment, the worst case scenario is that such a page cuts my procrastination/break time short, which obviously isn't a bad thing. Plus, ads are not the only way to make money online. So, if it isn't working for a company, then it's time to change the business model.
- edem 11y agoI never blocked ads (like AdSense) until the proliferation of popups, unstoppable videos and such crap. I'm blocking everything since then and the site has to be really important for me to disable blocking. This is an arms race you have no chance of winning. If I don't like your blocker I just disable that script in my browser or null out its reference or whatever since it is __my__ browser after all and you have no control over it. AdBlock is the answer for the useless shitstorm of obtrusive ads and while we have them it is here to stay. I bet there will be a FuckAdBlockFucker tomorrow or even sooner.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoName and intent aside, being able to detect when an ad-blocker is run and present alternate messages to the visitor can be helpful in many instances. As a bit of an outlier example, PortableApps.com makes use of another detection technique to then show a simple message in place of the first ad on the page and hide any remnants of the other ads so that the page layout doesn't look sloppy for ad-block users. The message is shown on all internal pages (not the homepage) when ads are blocked and asks users to consider allowing ads for our site with a link to a page explaining how to ad an exception or making a donation to help keep us funded. The small message uses the same fonts and colors as the rest of the sidebar navigation so it's not distracting and has CSS that reserves space for it in the event of ads being blocked so the content doesn't jump at all and distract from reading a page. I realize it's a bit of an outlier case, of course, but many users do then allow ads or make a donation. Granted our ads are bit less intrusive than many sites with only a single sidebar ad above the fold, no banner ad, no popouts/flyovers, no download button ads, no ads that autoplay sound, etc and many of our visitors are open source/free software fans. For the curious, here's a link to an internal page so you can see it in action with your ad-blocker active: http://portableapps.com/support http://portableapps.com/support