4 ms·
Tarsnap (a service that acts like your description) is quite nice, but the problem of "customer lost the keys" is a very real one. I love the idea, but someone
by protomyth 11y ago
Tarsnap (a service that acts like your description) is quite nice, but the problem of "customer lost the keys" is a very real one. I love the idea, but someone really needs to come up with some decent key management (and offline backup and key migration) to make this consumer friendly.
- bertomartin 11y agoThen, we need a good service to store keys, with a key to get to your key
- toyg 11y agoAnd that will be a sweet, sweet target...
- jfindley 11y agoI wrote a PoC app [0] a while ago to do just this - allow storing and sharing of keys, with the server holding the encrypted keys never seeing the decryption key. Sharing a key involves downloading it from the server, asymetrically encrypting it with the public key of the reciever, and uploading to the server again. It also allowed sharing with groups via intermediate keys decrypt-able by multiple users. Obviously it's just a PoC - noone should use it for actually important data, and I certainly don't promise that it's actually secure - but it does (more or less) work. As it requires client-side crypto, it's not an ideal candidate for a web-service either (although one could potentially use browser extensions to make that more reasonable). 0: https://github.com/jfindley/skds https://github.com/jfindley/skds
- kgilpin 11y agoCan't this just be my phone?
- Filligree 11y agoAnd when your phone breaks...?
- dbbolton 11y ago>decent key management What about Hashicorp's Vault?
- Intermernet 11y agoIt's not really something that can be made "consumer friendly" as far as I can tell (But I'd love to be proven wrong!). How do you securely store the key to your securely stored data? Admittedly, there are some recommendations on the Tarsnap site (http://www.tarsnap.com/gettingstarted.html http://www.tarsnap.com/gettingstarted.html): "5. Keep your key file safe Store your /root/tarsnap.key somewhere safe. If you lose tarsnap.key, you will not be able to access your archived data. The same encryption which ensures your data security also means that there is no way for anybody (including Tarsnap Backup Inc.) to restore your data without this key. There are many ways to keep it safe: Copy it to a different system. Put it on a USB disk. Give it to a friend. Print it out (it is printable text). Store it in a bank vault. Pick at least one and do it!" The only other way I can think of to keep the key even safer would be to use Shamir's Secret Sharing to divide the key up and share it among trusted friends and family. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing).
- gknoy 11y agoThe above is exactly correct, though: Write it down, put it in a safety deposit box (or two if you're paranoid about losing it?). Note that fireproof safes normally won't protect digital media (temperature) but paper survives well (I hear).