3 ms·
I partially agree with this view; however, to be fair, this is not a problem with academic economics, but rather with "pop economics". There is no lack of acad
by toyg 11y ago
I partially agree with this view; however, to be fair, this is not a problem with academic economics, but rather with "pop economics".
There is no lack of academic economists who can (and do) prove how austerity programs and trickle-down are wrong; in fact, they're the only ones really leading the charge on this matter in the political world at the moment.
The problem is that policy leaders not trained in advanced economic studies (most of them lawyers by trade, as you would expect in the business of writing laws) are awash in "pop economics", cheap literature peddled by suspect gurus sponsored by interested parties. This creates a hegemonic but distorted view of the field that is then very hard to shake.
- JupiterMoon 11y ago> There is no lack of academic economists who can (and do) prove how austerity programs and trickle-down are wrong; in fact, they're the only ones really leading the charge on this matter in the political world at the moment. The thing is you can pretty much find an academic economist to back up whatever argument you want to make.
- pjc50 11y agoIt's not just lawyer-politicians, but economic organisations like the IMF and the ECB. Stiglitz' book on the subject is excellent, including the anecdote about how we know that their advice is the same whatever the country and situation because someone once forgot to search-and-replace the country name before sending it out. Then there's the Rheinhart-Rogoff excel error: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/19/opinion/krugman-the-excel-depression.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/19/opinion/krugman-the-excel-...
- toyg 11y agoThose organisations are sclerotic because they ultimately answer to politicians, not to academics; they are political constructs first and foremost, serving specific national interests, with heads nominated by political leaders and (surprise) often lawyers themselves (e.g. Lagarde). In fact, during recent events in Greece it became clear how their own researchers disagreed with the policies being pushed from the top. It's like developers were forced to write websites in PASCAL because their employers told them to. The Excel error is also exemplary of what I referred to as "pop economics": a single argument was "divulged to death" and transformed into mainstream orthodoxy even though it was still being confuted in academic circles.
- mcguire 11y agoThe membrane between academia and pop economics (i.e. the suspect gurus) is exceedingly porous.