2 ms·
I didn't RTA, but I find it interesting you compare science and democracy. In a good democracy, the politicians are assumed to be gaining the system for person
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I didn't RTA, but I find it interesting you compare science and democracy.
In a good democracy, the politicians are assumed to be gaining the system for personal power. That is, the political system is built up to make it extremely difficult for power to centralize in any one spot for a long period of time. There are lots of ways to do this, checks and balances, term limits, parliamentary systems, etc.
However in the current "scientific" system -- the system that allocates political and monetary power to scientists -- none of this seems to be in place. It's much at the same place democracies were in the 1600s or so; there is a lot of reliance on the "right" people being in power.
I'm not at all trying to slam science -- it is truly the best thing we have -- but I found your metaphor very enlightening, perhaps in ways you didn't realize? Thanks for sharing it.
- tensor 17y agoActually, the allocation of money has nothing to do with the idea of science, but is rather a simple necessity brought on by, ironically, politics. That allocation process also has many of the same safe-guards you mention. The part of the metaphor that is completely incorrect, is that democracy is a truth finding system at all! You can not vote the law of gravity out of existence, for example. As a truth finding tool, democracy is only as strong as the education of its members, and even then, it provides no strict framework for judging quality or correctness of results. In that sense, democracy has little at all to do with science. It is merely a tool for managing and controlling human actions.