2 ms·
I think we agree that their null hypothesis is "there is a background, with events coming from all the known particles". I think we agree that their conclusion
by kgwgk 11y ago
I think we agree that their null hypothesis is "there is a background, with events coming from all the known particles". I think we agree that their conclusion is "these results provide conclusive evidence for the discovery of a new particle". I don't see how can they say that there is a new particle without rejecting the hypothesis that there is no such new particle. Of course you can say that the null hypothesis can never be rejected (relevant Dilbert strip: http://dilbert.com/strip/2001-10-25 http://dilbert.com/strip/2001-10-25) but then they can never discover a new particle either.
Regarding p-values in general, your definition is the same I've been using all along. But I don't think it is meaningless when the null hypothesis does not hold. The meaning is clear: "the probability of getting a value for the statistic as high as the observed one if the null hypothesis was true". For example, there would be one chance in several millions of observing the kind of data they found at the LHC if the Higgs boson didn't exist.
You might want to look into the theory yourself, because the notion of p-values trending towards 1 if the null hypothesis is true is nonsense. By definition, if the null hypothesis is true the p-value is uniformly distributed between 0 and 1. If you have at some point a p-value close to one (or to any other number for that matter) and keep adding data, in the long run it will still be uniformly distributed between 0 and 1.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIf the null-hypothesis is true, every observation made should be consistent with it. This will result in P(X|H) trending to 1 (since there will be experimental variance). No other experimental design makes sense. >The meaning [of p-value when H is false] is clear: "the probability of getting a value for the statistic as high as the observed one if the null hypothesis was true" This is a logical fallacy. It is counterfactual to consider a world where the null hypothesis is true, when it is not. In fact, this is precisely the feature of the universe that p-value based experimentation exploits and is essentially the only way for us to gain any information about 'reality'. >By definition, if the null hypothesis is true the p-value is uniformly distributed between 0 and 1. I don't think so. If that were true, p-value would be entirely useless.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If the null-hypothesis is true, every observation made should be consistent with it. This will result in P(X|H) trending to 1 Every observation being consistent with H doesn't mean that for each event X that occurs, the conditional probability of X given H will be, or "trend toward", 1. Assuming a perfectly deterministic universe, the P(X|everything else that is true) will be 1 for every X that occurs, but that doesn't mean P(X|H) for any particular true proposition H will be anything like that.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>Every observation being consistent with H doesn't mean that for each event X that occurs, the conditional probability of X given H will be, or "trend toward", 1. Agreed. If you plot P(X|H) (computed over all observations) over time, in a well-formed experiment the line will trend to 1 if the null-hypothesis is true and to 0 if the null-hypothesis is false. It really is that simple.
- kgwgk 11y agoYou definitely do not know what a p-value is. When you wrote "P(X|H)" I though X was shorthand for T>T(X) where T is the statistic, not that you were referring to the actual data X. P(X|H) doesn't have the properties you claim, anyway. P(X|H)=1 corresponds to the case where only one outcome is possible. In non-trivial cases, the more data you add the lower this number will be. Assume H="you have a fair coin". You throw it once: heads. P(X|H)=P(h|faircoin)=1/2 You throw it again: tails. P(X|H)=P(ht|faircoin)=1/4. You throw it again: tails. P(X|H)=P(htt|faircoin)=1/8. I guess the experiment is not well-formed...
- jsprogrammer 11y agoX can be any random variable that satisfies the requirements of the null-hypothesis. A more appropriate variable for your experiment would probably be the ratio of heads to tails (may need to add a bias to avoid division by 0). "you have a fair coin" is not a hypothesis, at least not a well-defined one.