4 ms·
The State loves control, especially when it is packaged as "fairness." In the case of rent control, it's simply "fair" that you should be able to afford a place
by clarkmoody 11y ago
The State loves control, especially when it is packaged as "fairness." In the case of rent control, it's simply "fair" that you should be able to afford a place to live in the city and not have the evil capitalists prey upon the middle class. As the article mentions, price controls are nearly universally understood as inefficient among economists. The inefficiency expresses itself as a shortage of housing. Those who are able to find a place will enjoy cheap rent and then thank the politician who gave it to them. The rest will need to commute so they are out of the voting district anyway :-)
The article mentions building limits. Call it "zoning" or "neighborhood preservation" or "green belts" but it's all State control over what should be private property decisions made by individuals. Artificially limiting supply through a restrictive building permitting process will drive up costs. Hence, the need for rent controls.
So the State controls both the supply and price of housing in these metro areas. Any public figure or pundit who blames "capitalists" or "failure of the free market" for the housing woes should be laughed out of the room.
How can we solve the problem? Stop trying to fix it with government. Allow rents to equalize at the market rate and allow supply to be determined by the market. Until the statists relinquish control, the problem will never be resolved. But the upside is that we will get to read these nice Economist articles forever.
- ConfuciusSay 11y agoThere's two other major factors beyond rent control and zoning. One is cheap credit, insured by the government, and the second is the massive flow of foreign money coming into NA real estate. If you don't take care of all those factors together, you won't get true price discovery. The other thing is, the moment you do get true price discovery, you're popping a giant financialized bubble, and potentially triggering another self-reinforcing downward cycle (we'll be facing that soon anyways though).