5 ms·
The point was, I thought, that Fibonacci numbers don't appear in nature, and nor does the golden ratio. Spirals, yes; logarithmic growth patterns, yes; fixed ra
by jameshart 11y ago
The point was, I thought, that Fibonacci numbers don't appear in nature, and nor does the golden ratio. Spirals, yes; logarithmic growth patterns, yes; fixed ratios, yes; but Fibonacci... no, not specifically. Did you have an example in mind where you believe the Fibonacci sequence actually does crop up, naturally?
- jMyles 11y agoReally? It's like we're reading a different article. The author says several times that, sure, spirals that approximately but predictably implement the golden ratio exist, but so do others. As if that's supposed to convince the reader of something. I took this to be the thesis: > We have noted above that not all spirals in mathematics or in nature are golden spirals. Likewise, spirals can be produced by non-biological processes if the discrete elements which make up the spiral are laid down according to some simple rules. The problem for biologists is to find those rules. Merely asserting that "nature seems to prefer fibonacci numbers" (most of the time, in certain particular cases) isn't an explanation. If this is the "flim flam" that's being debunked, it's blaspheming a religion with no followers.
- jules 11y agoThe point of the article is that the fibonacci spiral isn't particularly more common than any other spiral. There is a whole range of spirals in nature, yet people worship fibonacci spirals as if it is something special.
- fvirexi 11y agoThe fibonacci spirals _are_ something special. The simple continued fraction of the golden mean is [1;1,1,...], and its convergents (the sequence of fractions that best approximates it) is ratios of fibonacci numbers. In short, due to the 1,1,1,... nature of the golden mean's SCF, it is _the_ number that is hardest to approximate by any rational number. This is why anything that evolves to reduce "periodicity", they will try to approximate this number, and it is best approximated by ratios of fibonacci.
- jules 11y agoWhy would something evolve in such a way that the ratio of two lengths of its body parts is hard to approximate by a rational number?
- fvirexi 11y agoI don't know about limbs, but it could explain sunflower seeds and branches of trees. If they are distributed with a period, every n'th time around they will shade for other seeds (or branches). Approximating \phi is then a good way to reduce such shading.
- jules 11y agoThat argument is too hand wavy to be convincing. Can you make it precise? How exactly are the seeds or branches being distributed in 2d/3d space, and how does that minimize shading? Why would sunflower seeds want to minimize shading in the first place? There's also the trouble that sunflower seeds and branches of trees do not actually approximate phi in any meaningful way. Check out this picture: http://www.wingsdailynews.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/fibonacci-sunflower.jpg http://www.wingsdailynews.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/fib... No doubt it was cherry picked and the spiral placed in the best position, yet the match is abysmal (look at how far the center of the spiral is from the center of the flower). The seeds are just packed tightly together and this produces some patterns due to the seeds on the outside being more developed than those on the inside.
- fvirexi 11y agoI only meant it as a possible explanation for why it wouldn't be unreasonable to think phi appears often in nature. I don't really have enough knowledge of nature to say if it's the case. Distribute the seeds of a sunflower radially, placing one seed every 360*x degrees, gradually increasing radius. If x=a/b, after placing b seeds, you will be back to the initial position and the next b seeds will be (radially) shaded from the first b seeds (which I admit, might not be how shading works in practice). If x is irrational, but closely approximated by a/b, the seeds won't line up perfectly, but still enough to shade quite a bit. If x is phi, then they will shade as little as theoretically possible (I think.. This is by no means a proof, just some thoughts). IIRC, the "sunflower seed pattern" is actually achieved only if you simulate such a seed placing with x close to phi.
- tizzdogg 11y agoThe point is also that in fact the 'fibonacci spirals' which do show up in nature are crude approximations. There are no real perfect fibonacci spirals in nature, just a continuum of different spirals. People like to see fibonacci patterns where they dont exist.
- jMyles 11y agoPerhaps then it turns on a view of whether the nature of the universe is beautiful / compelling / inspirational. Sure, archimedes spirals are awesome. Pi is awesome. And, to me, golden spirals (about which, by the way, Fibonacci had no idea) are really really awesome. The fact that other shapes, patterns, sequences, and algorithms exist (an utterly impotent and self-evident assertion) does nothing to diminish my appreciation for Fibonacci numbers or the golden ratio. And there's nothing "flim flam" about that.
- jameshart 11y agoWhat's "really really" awesome about Fibonacci spirals? They're just log spirals whose growth factor is phi. I can generate an infinite number of log spirals with different ratios. What's so awesome about generating them with a ratio of (one plus root five) over two? Would one generated with a ratio of pi be even more awesome? what about e? Sure, phi is the solution to x - 1 = 1 / x. That just means it's the solution to x^2 - x - 1 = 0. It's just the answer to a polynomial. It's not even the unique answer! both phi and 1/phi answer it. What about x^3 - x^2 - x - 1 = 0? That seems to be related, and it has a unique real solution - 1.839. Maybe that number has magic properties when used as the ratio for a log spiral?