3 ms·
> The interesting part of the conversation to me is the plateau itself - according to many people, all people and especially individuals are the same, calories
by grecy 11y ago
> The interesting part of the conversation to me is the plateau itself - according to many people, all people and especially individuals are the same, calories in minus exercise equals weight gained (or lost), there is no such thing as flux, every day is exactly the same, literally the only variable is your weight, and that hardly changes at all day to day.
I've never seen anyone claim that calories in / calories out will have an immediate impact and should be visible on the scales within days. On any given day your body might hold onto lots of water, so you don't lose weight. Later you might get really dehydrated on a hot day, so you appear to have lost weight, etc. etc. Times one million variations for why you won't see "results" "instantly".
Don't for one second think that any of this is measured on the scale of days, or weeks. You are completely deluding yourself if you think it is.
A scale of months hardly makes sense either. Do everything for a minimum of 3 months before you expect to see a difference, on the scales or in the mirror. Everything takes time, and you're in this for the rest of your life, so what's the difference anyway.
> Correct. However, you can absorb less than you eat! Eat 2000 calories, absorb 1500, poop out the rest, gee, I wonder if that might have any effect on weight loss?
It won't, because that's how your body has been functioning for a long time.
If you're trying to lose weight, you just have to feed it less, who cares how much it's extracting, it's completely irrelevant.
Like I said, it doesn't matter if you're in a car that gets 30mpg or one that gets 50mpg, as long as you put less gas in the tank than you are using, sooner or later the tank will run out!
Stop trying to make this harder than it needs to be, or more complicated that it needs to be.
Consume less calories than you burn, and in the long run you will lose weight.
- mistermann 11y ago> Like I said, it doesn't matter if you're in a car that gets 30mpg or one that gets 50mpg But what if the car adjusts its fuel efficiency dynamically? If that's the case, it might be something worth investigating and understanding, no? > Stop trying to make this harder than it needs to be, or more complicated that it needs to be. Consume less calories than you burn, and in the long run you will lose weight. Correct, but if certain levels of caloric deficit can cause physiological changes that affect rate of weight loss, altering the difficulty of losing weight, why be opposed to discussing that idea? Why not maximize efficiency of weight loss?
- grecy 11y ago> But what if the car adjusts its fuel efficiency dynamically? And your body does just that. That's why you continually re-evaluate what your calorie needs are and adjust your intake accordingly. Weight Watchers does this every single week. See how much you weigh, figure out what your "maintenance" calories are, and make sure you eat 200-300 less than that. Then, yes, your body changes, adapts and becomes more efficient, because you're changing things, and it's getting lighter so be definition it needs less calories. So then check-in again a week later repeat. And repeat. And repeat. > If certain levels of caloric deficit can cause physiological changes that affect rate of weight loss I wouldn't go there. I mean, if you want to change the rate of weight loss, just eat absolutely zero calories for 6 months. I grantee you'll lose a massive amount of weight. Is that a good idea? absolutely not. There is an amount that's sensible and works well. It's something like 200-300 less calories than your maintenance requires. > * Why not maximize efficiency of weight loss* It's interesting to me you're still viewing this as "weight loss", and something to be maximized and made more efficient, and something with an end date. What hasn't dawned on you yet (and usually takes most weight watchers people a very long time to get) is that, at some point in the future, you will weigh your goal weight. When you get there, your calorie requirements to maintain that are going to be massively lower than they are now. Actually, they're going to be right around what you were eating the week before you got to your goal weight. Guess what? That's now what you're going to eat for the rest of your life. You can't really maximize the efficiency of the rest of your life. So just start working towards it, today.
- mistermann 11y ago> Then, yes, your body changes, adapts and becomes more efficient, because you're changing things, and it's getting lighter so be definition it needs less calories. This doesn't require any "adjustment" on the body's part, it is a natural outcome of having less mass to maintain. I am speaking of something different, of the possibility of the body sensing starvation and shifting into kind of a high efficiency sustainment mode, perhaps lower metabolism, perhaps more efficient extraction of calories from food. Does this actually happen, I don't know, but I believe from personal experience and reading forums that there is a phenomenon of hitting a weight plateau that is not explained by the simplistic calories in, calories out theory. I don't know why this idea seems so offensive to people. > I wouldn't go there. I mean, if you want to change the rate of weight loss, just eat absolutely zero calories for 6 months. I grantee you'll lose a massive amount of weight. Why do conversations on certain topics have to degrade to nonsense if someone doesn't agree with your point of view? > It's interesting to me you're still viewing this as "weight loss", and something to be maximized and made more efficient Some people, me for example, can diet for a period, drop <x> pounds, and then I'm good for years with paying very little attention to diet - not everyone has it that easy though. But while I am dieting, I prefer to optimize it so it's over as quickly as possible. The idea of optimizing things is a fairly common theme on this site, but again, there seems to be something about the topic of dieting that changes the way people think.